User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Legionnaire11
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=746

How does this happen? I made one change in tactics.

game 1: rush 50% / pass 50%
rushed 45 times for 145 yards
passed 48 times for 215 yards
gave up 75 rushing and 263 passing
won 27-20

game 2: rush 60% / pass 40%
rushed 53 times for 275 yards
passed 20 times for 92 yards
gave up 16 rushing and 192 passing
won 31-10

game 3: rush 50% / pass 50%
rushed 16 times for 27 yards
passed 52 times for 183 yards
gave up 359 rushing and 121 passing
lost 35-0

game 3 was also against a team that was previously winless and has only scored something like 16 points in 2 games. They didn't make significant roster updates prior to the game, so it just seems very odd that the results would be so extreme.

is the sim engine schizo or something?
 
packers0491
offline
Link
 
the last team was much better then yous
 
oddsewer
offline
Link
 
last game you threw the ball a ton more and ran for significantly less yards??
 
DT35
offline
Link
 
You had the ball less
 
Link
 
you were playing catchup, and the computer takes over the gameplan (since running would have been pointless).

Tactic-wise, you got schooled
 
Legionnaire11
offline
Link
 
i'm not complaining about the loss. a loss is fine. but you'd expect the result to be not quite as extreme.

what i'm asking is how can the sim go from one extreme where I win 31-10 and put up 275 rushing yards, to losing 35-0 and only 27 rushing yards? I know I was playing catchup, but how does it get to that point in the first place. That team has scored 3 and 10 points in it's previous two games, then explodes on my team with the same roster that they had before.

just questioning the consistency of the sim engine
Last edited Apr 2, 2008 20:23:56
 
Lohengrin
offline
Link
 
If the sim was too consistent, you wouldn't have underdog victories like the last game. Though 275 rushing yards does seem a bit extreme - didn't help that guys had a ton of missed tackles, though ... as evidenced here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=643096

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Auto adjust?

Also, don't underestimate the power of confidence. In-game morale simulates the idea of momentum. If your players have low confidence, momentum can very quickly swing away from you as they get demoralized from missing tackles or giving up points or turning the ball over, etc. If your confidence is very low, your player feels like he might as well give up and will not play as well.
 
Legionnaire11
offline
Link
 
well 28-14 I would have called it a bad loss and looked at what I did wrong.

35-0 with those rushing stats makes me think that there are still a few tweaks that need to be made to how the AI does the auto adjust, and how much the morale/confidence affects things. So I don't know if it's something to look into or not, but I thought i'd present the results as being something odd in case you wanted to check it out.
 
blackplague
offline
Link
 
You also have to take into account if the owner of the other team put in some hours on the game tapes and figured out your tendencies. The sim is what it is, if the guy had you pegged you're not going to do very well.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lohengrin
If the sim was too consistent, you wouldn't have underdog victories like the last game. Though 275 rushing yards does seem a bit extreme - didn't help that guys had a ton of missed tackles, though ... as evidenced here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=643096



Well, it seems to me that the sim engine doesn't properly run off enough time. I'm seeing games where teams run 80 plays each. That just doesn't happen in the NFL, theres not enough time.


Your opponent rushed 55 times and threw 27, you threw 52 times and ran 16. Thats 150 plays. The average NFL game is more like 110-120, with 130 being high, so I wouldn't worry too much about the yardage totals.
 
Legionnaire11
offline
Link
 
check out http://www.goodhockey.com/ they have a terrific sim engine, and the game is set up very well. I'm hopeful that GLB will be as good some day.

also http://www.simdynasty.com/ has a good engine, the game itself isn't that great compared to GLB or Good Hockey, but I really like their sims.

no other sim sites have even come close to goal line blitz, good hockey, or sim dynasty.

Check out hockeyarena.net for a game that you don't want to be like, it's pretty terrible.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.