User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Auto SP's in minor and major attributes not consistent???
Page:
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
After looking around the FA market and working on a side project for proof to another issue I discovered that there is a few different fractional numbers on players built after the elimination of fractional training.

If we are only allowed to get fractional points via the 3 points divided amongst the minor and major attributes then mathematical law states all fractional points will be identical on the same position and level of player. However that is not the case.

How is this possible?


Here is an example

This level 24 CB built in season 6 has very different fractional points then this one built in season 5. We started the nonfractional training in season 5.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1101082

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=944037

Same with these OTs both built in season 6

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1122520

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1082895


To me there is a bug that has gone undetected and needs to be looked into






Last edited Apr 8, 2009 19:23:01
 
cmac821
offline
Link
 
DON"T ASK QUESTIONS!
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Only thing I can think of is perhaps there's some bug with boosting x3 (or x2) over the natural growth drops (level 22, level 30, level 38, level 46, etc.). Like perhaps the person boosting at level 21 x3 receives the pre-level 22 drop natural growth for each level up.
Last edited Apr 8, 2009 19:23:48
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
I do believe that there is a slight difference when boosting x1 (apply skill points) at time vs x3 at once. A number of folks have run the numbers and I've there's something relevant on the Wiki.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Yes there is a bug where you boost 3x all at once instead of 1x at a time.

If you boost, boost 1x at a time and you wont have the problem.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Only thing I can think of is perhaps there's some bug with boosting x3 (or x2) over the natural growth drops (level 22, level 30, level 38, level 46, etc.). Like perhaps the person boosting at level 21 x3 receives the pre-level 22 drop natural growth for each level up.


It looks a lot like it's this - and I don't see anything relevant about this on the wiki on my first pass, if it's there, it's pretty well hidden. I looked at the OTs because this is really easy to verify - OTs always have a 10 on tackling to start, and it's pretty safe that no one has spent SPs on them so you can work out the math exactly.
OT #1: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1122520
He should have:
10 initial
20 lvl gains at .5 each = +10
3 lvl gains at .38 each = +1.13
Total = 21.13, which is his tackling

OT #2: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1082895
Same level, should have 21.13, but has 21.26
If instead he got:
10 initial
21 lvl gains at .5 each = +10.5
2 lvl gains at .38 each = +0.76
Total = 21.26, which is his tackling. Similar logic would reveal that he's gotten an extra .1 on his major skills to go with the extra .13 on the minor skills.

That means there's a EXPLOIT here for minor amounts of stat points, not a bug where people *don't* get stat points. It's pretty narrow - there are only 3 breakpoints in a player's career that this could be abused, and if you can get it for 2 lvls worth at each breakpoint it's a total of 3.46875 stat points (distributed over the various major/minor skills) over the player's entire career. But since people are planning out builds down to the tenths of a point gain, that's going to annoy a LOT of people. It should probably either be fixed or described as a feature of boosting. Fixing it without making it retroactive would be okay in my book, but I bet a lot of people would complain. Not as loudly as if you retroactively stole points from people somehow, though.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Only thing I can think of is perhaps there's some bug with boosting x3 (or x2) over the natural growth drops (level 22, level 30, level 38, level 46, etc.). Like perhaps the person boosting at level 21 x3 receives the pre-level 22 drop natural growth for each level up.


Wow, you probably just nailed it.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Yes there is a bug where you boost 3x all at once instead of 1x at a time.

If you boost, boost 1x at a time and you wont have the problem.


If you have a level 1 CB and boost 3x at once, your speed will go up by 1. If you boost 3x one-at-a-time, it will go up by 0.99. Whether or not it's right to use all 3 simultaneously depends on what the attribute gain for each level is being rounded to. The true "value" of the attribute gain is always going to be a fraction. You get "1/3" speed per level. Boosting 3x just multiplies 1/3 x 3. Boosting 1x three times awards 1/3 rounded to the nearest hundredth, three times.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
It will be different for HB, WR, G, DT, LB, CB depending on how players are boosted, 1 level at a time or 3 at a time, due to the division of attribute points on the natural level gains.

If you boost once for a CB you get a .33 major increase before level 21, because they divide 2 points between 6 skills. Do that 3 times, you get .99 points.

If you boost 3 times for a CB, they add the 2 points for each level together, then divide by 3, which is a perfect 1 point, instead of .99.

There may also be some carry over when boosting across level drops, as well, I've never really paid that much attention to it, because I boost one level at a time.
 
Caiderman98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Norsemanvike
I do believe that there is a slight difference when boosting x1 (apply skill points) at time vs x3 at once. A number of folks have run the numbers and I've there's something relevant on the Wiki.

Listen to the great mod.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
So folks, I'm thinking that this isn't a bug. Could a few of the regulars chime so we can have some community confirmation?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Norsemanvike
So folks, I'm thinking that this isn't a bug. Could a few of the regulars chime so we can have some community confirmation?


Well, NiborRis' post seems to indicate that there's a minor opportunity to exploit the system.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
But is it really worth worrying about? Slow builds in general take much more advantage by not applying skill points.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Norsemanvike
But is it really worth worrying about? Slow builds in general take much more advantage by not applying skill points.


Probably not. If his numbers are right, a gain of 3 or so attributes over the course of a career is hardly a deal breaker. Still though, it should be uniformly rounded, whether it's 1 boost or 3, or however those extra digits are gained. I won't lose any sleep over it though.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Universally rounded will be an issue for people that can only boost 1x, i.e. by using the free flex that Bort hands out periodically, so he's got to break that to 1/3 as much as possible. In the end though, I think that we can lock this if you're good with it Forbin.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.