For something like this I think it'd be fair to only mention your own teammates for everyone else to consider, but if you're going to pick names then it should be only from other teams... to reduce the amount of bias involved.
Who wouldnt vote for their own players? Thats like running for pres and not voting for yourself. Just look at the stats as a whole and make reasonable choices.
First these are all based on current stats, not going to look at game tape to decide, as of may 17th.
QB: Top pick - Mike Dat....he has the yards and enough TDs, but mostly its the TD/INT ratio that puts him to the top for me.
Nominations -Eddy Hoyt....good yardage, still below Dat though, the 7 INT is why i didn't put him on top, but he would be my 2nd. -Joe Idaho.....With 12 TDs and only 6 picks he makes it to the top, only thing that held him back to the top is his low passing yards. (Dat actually has a slightly better TD/INT ratio too) -Chad Henney......Awesome amount of passing yards, obviously with 15 INT and 7 TDs no way he is going to be the top pick, but he has 600 more yards then the next guy so i thought he deserved to be up here. His team is very, very, very pass heavy, so that has something to do it.
ok, my picks are done, tough not to put your own guy for nominations though....i say we hold off until end of season to make it official though, but its a good time to start looking.
Originally posted by hostyle Who wouldnt vote for their own players? Thats like running for pres and not voting for yourself.5 people running for president go to the polls and vote for themselves and you'll have 5 candidates with one vote each, getting them nowhere.
we are planning to run a probowl sim on madden and uploading the video so it can be watched. One team per league so the best of the East and West will play together against the other Canada AA leagues. I PMed all of the owners but if I havn't recieved nominations from them yet then please GMs feel free to PM me with your nomintions(from you own team) I will send out a ballot after next weeks games. any other questions about it feel free to PM me.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.