User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
Page:
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
If a team runs 2 plays over and over all game, the defense should be given a bonus to adapting and stopping the play.

No one in real football runs 2 plays and wins.
 
Flobby
offline
Link
 
like the defense starts catching on to the plays?



i like this idea
 
Rofl
offline
Link
 
this already happens. Starting positions of players are slightly changed if they see a formation that's used over and over again.
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rofl
this already happens. Starting positions of players are slightly changed if they see a formation that's used over and over again.



Maybe change the "slightly"?
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
There needs to be a significant vision increase after a play has been run over and over. I mean truthfully if someone decided to run the same play 50 times in a game, the defense should have a substantial vision increase, something along the lines of 25%.
 
pinonium
offline
Link
 
Does this mean that if the Offense runs the same play 9 times, and then a different play the 10th time, they could fool the defense?
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
If the tenth play used the same formation as the previous nine, I would say yes.
 
bayou bengals
offline
Link
 
you could run 2 or 3 plays all game and the defense would never know what it would be if those 2 or 3 plays were all from the same formation
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Best way to go about this imo is...give defenses bonuses to their rolls.

More likely to break their block, more likely to make tackles, more likely to get a PD or Int, less likely to fail vision checks, less likely to get faked...all that good stuff.

It seems like it would actually get the job done, and it would be more realistic than say, 5% bonus to all attributes or something.

The % modifiers would be dependent on several factors. Obviously, the more that a team runs a play, the higher it will be. I think it should also increase at a rate relative to vision. Higher vision = higher % modifiers per consecutive play, lower vision = lower % modifiers.
Last edited Mar 13, 2009 16:32:35
 
simmjer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Best way to go about this imo is...give defenses bonuses to their rolls.

More likely to break their block, more likely to make tackles, more likely to get a PD or Int, less likely to fail vision checks, less likely to get faked...all that good stuff.

It seems like it would actually get the job done, and it would be more realistic than say, 5% bonus to all attributes or something.

The % modifiers would be dependent on several factors. Obviously, the more that a team runs a play, the higher it will be. I think it should also increase at a rate relative to vision. Higher vision = higher % modifiers per consecutive play, lower vision = lower % modifiers.


+1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
There needs to be a significant vision increase after a play has been run over and over. I mean truthfully if someone decided to run the same play 50 times in a game, the defense should have a substantial vision increase, something along the lines of 25%.


I agree with this, but I think that it should approach 100 vision asymptotically. It could be like 50 plays to get to 100 vision. I disagree with allowing the defense to get bonuses to rolls (other than vision ones). I don't think the players should get better at deflecting passes or tackling someone simply because they've seen the play before. I do think that they should be able to get a jump on an interception, PD, or tackle due to their vision.
 
lunchbox
offline
Link
 
I like this idea a lot. Madden started doing this sort of with players that were "smart" they could start reading plays that were ran over and over again. It could be tied in to the "general" sp abilities the more you have the easier it is to identify the play and then can call it out to the rest of the defense.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
This is EPIC suggestion.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
This is SUPER EPIC
 
conanfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

There needs to be a significant vision increase after a play has been run over and over. I mean truthfully if someone decided to run the same play 50 times in a game, the defense should have a substantial vision increase, something along the lines of 25%.


I agree with this, but I think that it should approach 100 vision asymptotically. It could be like 50 plays to get to 100 vision. I disagree with allowing the defense to get bonuses to rolls (other than vision ones). I don't think the players should get better at deflecting passes or tackling someone simply because they've seen the play before. I do think that they should be able to get a jump on an interception, PD, or tackle due to their vision.


maybe an across the board defensive bonus to SA's like First Step as well.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.