User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Recalculating Fame
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
I realize that this may be somewhat similar to SCACE's thread, but since fame is coming to play a more important role in the game, I wanted to have a thread where we can discuss how it can be reworked and improved.

First, let's discuss our theories about how fame is currently calculated. Bort has released the formula, so there's going to be guessing involved. Here's my guess.

-Definite factors:

1. Games played
This seems to be the major component. You get a flat amount of fame for each game you play in, and that number is modified by the caliber of the league that you play in, with games played in higher leagues resulting in more fame.

2. Team Trophies
The first round of endorsements was a fame based lottery, with higher fame players (based on last season's #s only) getting more tickets. The players who won the bulk of endorsements were on the team that one the league championship. Based on this, it seems safe to conclude that team trophies are the second major factor, after games played.

-Possible Factors (things that may currently fame, but are not certain)

1. Individual Stats
I've seen people claim that high in-game stats resulted in more fame being earned for that game. Yet, I've seen people claim the reverse, and endorsements did not wind up going to players with high stats from last season. So I'm unconvinced. More evidence would be great either way. I'll be tracking how much my player's fame increments per game this season, and I encourage others to do the same.

2. Individual Trophies
I've seen a smaller amount of people claim this plays a role, but I've seen not evidence to support it. I'm very skeptical.

So that's the way things are now. What follows are factors that could be added to the way fame is calculated, hopefully improving it's usefulness in distinguishing great players from average ones. I don't necessarily support each one of these equally, but I want to put them out there. This is also where I really want your input.

1. Individual Stats
A player's on-field performance should be the key factor in determining his individual fame. That seems self evident to me. The problem is, most people think stats as they are now don't really indicate how good a player is, and they're mostly right. Comparing stats across positions is tricky, and playing gutted teams skews things even further. Suggestion about how stats could be processed to serve as a useful indicator are very welcome. I think justafish's Pro Bowl formulas are a good place to start, in terms of calculating what stats are important for what position: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1218134 The next big question is how to automatically process stats so that the distortion introduced by playing gutted teams is reduced.

2. Individual Trophies
It may be double dipping (the guys who get trophies automatically have high stats), but it makes perfect sense to me. In any sport, the most famous players are the ones who have won awards for their individual performance. I also think that the range of individual trophies should be expanded, but that's separate.

3. Team performance
I'm not totally sold on this, but players on good teams (regular season + playoff record) should be at least a little bit more famous. Problem is, there are definitely a lot of very famous players on lousy teams, so we don't want it to count too much.

4. Past Performance
This is complicated, and I'm not sure how to calculate it, but players who have a long track record of excellence should get higher fame in a single season than players who have just one good season, even if their performance was equal for that season. I realize that this falls prey to the "rich get richer" problem, and might be excluded for that reason, but an RB who manages to string together 4 1000+ yd rushing seasons is going to be significantly more famous than an otherwise comparable player who only has one.

Ok, that's enough from me. What do you have to add? This is an important, and potentially really fun aspect of the game, and I want to help Bort get it right.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 04:30:53
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Might be nice to see endorsements going to the player with the highest base stat in each category, for each league.
Maybe team-distributable endorsement deals? Maybe confidence should play a factor in receiving an endorsement? # of plays played? This would be so much easier to do if instead of endorsements there was an all - star calculation at the end of each season.. Could just give the endorsements to those guys.
 
tieio
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Might be nice to see endorsements going to the player with the highest base stat in each category, for each league.
Maybe team-distributable endorsement deals? Maybe confidence should play a factor in receiving an endorsement? # of plays played? This would be so much easier to do if instead of endorsements there was an all - star calculation at the end of each season.. Could just give the endorsements to those guys.


What to do about endorsements is a whole separate discussion. But it looks like Fame is here to stay, and if so, I want to see it become a useful indicator of player performance. Any suggestions about that would be great, because currently it looks really underdeveloped.
 
uoY_redruM
offline
Link
 
+1 man, I always seem to like your ideas.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uoY_redruM
+1 man, I always seem to like your ideas.


Thanks, kinda feels like I'm talking to myself sometimes.
 
jackATTACK55
offline
Link
 
i like this
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
A note on how it works at the moment:

Fame as it is right now is sort of a mixture of fame and sportsmanship.

You gain base fame points for playing in a game, starting at a base value based on your league. This number is modified downward if you are too high of a level in comparison to the other team, are outside the level range of the league, or if you blow the team out by a lot.

You gain extra points if you're a top performer in the game, unless it's a blowout vs a gut job, as above.

You get extra points per individual trophy you earn. League leader and champ trophies both count. Gold > silver > bronze.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
A note on how it works at the moment:

Fame as it is right now is sort of a mixture of fame and sportsmanship.

You gain base fame points for playing in a game, starting at a base value based on your league. This number is modified downward if you are too high of a level in comparison to the other team, are outside the level range of the league, or if you blow the team out by a lot.

You gain extra points if you're a top performer in the game, unless it's a blowout vs a gut job, as above.

You get extra points per individual trophy you earn. League leader and champ trophies both count. Gold > silver > bronze.


Yeah, after looking at some other threads, I realized that they (performance + trophies) probably do count. What I'm suggesting here is that they don't count enough. My calculation of fame, in terms of importance would go something like this:

1. Performance
2. Individual Trophies
3. Past Performance
4. Team Performance.

Exactly what the distribution should be, I don't know, but I'm pretty comfortable with that ranking.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus

4. Team Performance.


I honestly hate team performance being factored into this fame-thing, tbh.
The game is already too bent towards keeping the best teams on top and it just seems like we're trying to make it impossible for teams to realistically work their way up to the top.
I hate it. I think it is terrible for the game.

I think the best teams should have the satisfaction of getting trophies - that is their reward.
They don't need to be constantly further rewarded with bonuses that will keep them on top and make it hard for newer teams to ever topple them.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Capaneus


4. Team Performance.


I honestly hate team performance being factored into this fame-thing, tbh.
The game is already too bent towards keeping the best teams on top and it just seems like we're trying to make it impossible for teams to realistically work their way up to the top.
I hate it. I think it is terrible for the game.

I think the best teams should have the satisfaction of getting trophies - that is their reward.
They don't need to be constantly further rewarded with bonuses that will keep them on top and make it hard for newer teams to ever topple them.


As I said, if iit actually unbalances the game, I agree it's no good. However, in terms of coming up with ideas for what a good (i.e., sensible) version of fame would look like, my first thought is to model it on real life. And, IRL being on a team that is really successful does help get your name out. I have it ranked fourth, so I agree it's not an important factor. I think it's funny I've managed a Bort post but, am struggling to get ten replies. I've only so many ideas, I was hoping other people would have better ones
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 08:02:50
 
sblast1919
offline
Link
 
one thing I don't like/understand about fame is the non-glamor positions such as FS, the FS never gets trophies, or high stats. If he does that means your D sucks!! But a good FS can change a game simply by turning a HB to another direction or have a QB to check down, this goes for really good CB also, a good CB should have next to no stats!! This seems not fair to let's say a QB or a HB vs. a CB or FS if fame is calculated evenly. It seems to me that the only way to be fair about it all is to watch every game and analyze every play, but this is just not reasonable.

at least base fame on a position by position basis, but again I don't understand... it seems fame ( on the D side at least ) rewards bad D's and penalizes good ones
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
i know Bort once mentioned "sure I could do that" when I had mentioned getting O Linemen some extra fame when they play a game where no (or 1) sack is given up - don't know if that occurs or not...


it's just such a tough thing to figure out -


i doubt it will be popular - but would be interesting if you could lose fame as well - it doesn't seem right that fame is only accumulated - never goes down -

a HB averaged < 2 yards per carry in a game - loses some fame.

a qb with a QB rating < X loses fame

etc, etc - but i'm sure now we'd be talking about some crazy coding - and it would be tough to do
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.