User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > nfratami says: Endorsements - There Needs to Be More Than 1 Given Per Position
Page:
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Even if you are the most famous player in your league for you, you really don't have a good chance of getting an item, and with the odds you will see below, most people won't ever see an endorsement item.

For my example I will use DEs.

For this example let us say that each team in a league has 3 DEs (conservative estimate this will most likely be more but this will just go to show you how unlikely it will be to get an endorsement item).

Now let us say that the DEs in your league average at 500 fame. Let us now say that your player is tops in the league for DE fame with 900.

Endorsements are said to be done in a lottery system. I assume it will work as in the equation below.

So...

3 DEs x 32 teams = 96 DEs in the league (conservative estimate)

Take 96 DEs and multiply that by average fame of 500 and you get 48,000 total fame for DEs in your league.

Now your DE is the most famous with 900. but his chances aren't good to win the lottery.

900/48000 = 1.875%

So, In conclusion even if you are the most famous player at your position in your league, you are probably not going to get an endorsement, probably ever.

Increase the number of items per position, it doesn't make any sense to add an item like this that won't increases the enjoyment of the vast majority of the game.

You could have the lottery take the top 5 selected for each position and make items 1-5 deteriorate in quality from 1 to 5. I'm sure you guys could have some other ideas.

Edit: typo
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 11:17:02
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
I said this the day they were announced.

Even the top 10 would be nice, obviously have the strength of them diminish as it gets closer to the end, but still. Something is better than nothing.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
LETS IMPLEMENT THIS GREAT IDEA ASAP
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
I said this the day they were announced.

Even the top 10 would be nice, obviously have the strength of them diminish as it gets closer to the end, but still. Something is better than nothing.


Yeah, there are a lot of possible solutions, having more endorsement items seems like the easiest, but it may be difficult to scale that many items while still making the #1 received awesome, and the #10 significantly less awesome but not crappy.

Maybe even selecting the top 5-10 most famous from a position and then doing a random drawing from there could work?
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 77racing
LETS IMPLEMENT THIS GREAT IDEA ASAP


ty for your support
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
100% agreed. As it is, even good players have only a small chance of seeing an endorsement. At the very leasy, having decremental levels of awesome:
1st place endorsement: +X Foo +X% Bar
2nd place endorsement: +X/2 Foo +X/2% Bar
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
No Thank you for a GREAT suggestion!
 
Link
 
Yeah, I was thinking about this just the other day myself... it seems like there won't be enough endorsement pieces for one, and the chance to get the 1 piece per position is way to small even if you're the most famous player in the whole league.
Instead of 5 per position (which I think may be a bit too many?) , what about 3 ? Would that significantly unbalance the game?
And yeah, make them all on a "quality scale" of some sort...
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Should be one per conference, not league.

Maybe do 3 per conference.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami

Yeah, there are a lot of possible solutions, having more endorsement items seems like the easiest, but it may be difficult to scale that many items while still making the #1 received awesome, and the #10 significantly less awesome but not crappy.


They get their own equipment slot...so even if the last person gets a +1 to stamina...that is still SOMETHING.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Should be one per conference, not league.

Maybe do 3 per conference.



Yeah, thx for reminding me I forgot- currently its only 1 piece per position per league... 3 per conference sounds A LOT better !
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
I would also like to see the players names listed and the product they are endorsing after the lottery is complete... I mean it is FAME afterall
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Should be one per conference, not league.

Maybe do 3 per conference.


1 per conference would still theoretically be a longshot, with the above example the star DE's chance would just double to 3.75%.

3 per conference is more on the right track
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by nfratami


Yeah, there are a lot of possible solutions, having more endorsement items seems like the easiest, but it may be difficult to scale that many items while still making the #1 received awesome, and the #10 significantly less awesome but not crappy.


They get their own equipment slot...so even if the last person gets a +1 to stamina...that is still SOMETHING.


Good point.
 
Saints_25
offline
Link
 
Every team should have at least one player with an endorsement. If you look at all sports there will be regional endorsements even on the worst teams. The Detroit Lions will still have a few players get regional endorsements while Payton Manning gets the national endorsements.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.