I'm in the right thread, and I'm making a suggestion. While a specific issue may be addressed at times in this thread, it is meant for discussion on transparency from GLB administration as a whole, regardless of the issue.
I believe, strongly, that GLB has a PR problem. It seemed to be overcoming some of it, but today took a huge step backwards. As paying customers (BETA or not, people are spending money for a service /end BETA argument), people on this site deserve transparency from admins and mods and have a right to expect as much.
There are great admins on this site and there are good mods, but there are times where you just want to pull your hair out and say enough with this. Today is one of those days.
First off, there need to be less secrets that give any advantage, real or perceived, to "those in the know". At some points, I've been "in the know" about things, and I do my best to share it with those who "aren't in the know" whenever I can. Maybe this post will lead to me not being "in the know" from now on, but whatever.
Secondly, when something is leaked from someone "in the know", there needs to be a process. Bort needs a "crisis binder" for a number of issues that a mod or another admin can look to in a time of need to determine how to best handle a situation.
**Case in point - Test Server becomes public knowlege**
How not to handle this
- Moving a thread with no explanation is not transparent
- Refusing to give an explanation is not transparent
- Deleting other threads on the subject is not transparent
- Locking other threads without explanation is not transparent
- Threatening any bans is not transparent (or a good way to keep a customer base happy)
How to handle it well
- Lock the thread with a good reason and explanation
- Stick that thread, or create a sticky thread about the issue explaining what steps are in progress
- Allow paying customers to freely discuss the issue among themselves as long as they are respectful and not breaking other forum rules.
- Keep the customer base up-to-date until an admin is prepared to speak on the issue.
This is just one example of how a simply situation can be A) a crisis or B) a discussion.
Feel free to discuss, as this should remain open -- I have broken no rules here. And please keep the discussion on transparency as the issue, citing examples only when they support the overall suggestion. Keep discussion relevant so that we can actually have somewhere to talk about this.
Scace
EDIT - A good example of how to handle a tough situation: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2067898
I believe, strongly, that GLB has a PR problem. It seemed to be overcoming some of it, but today took a huge step backwards. As paying customers (BETA or not, people are spending money for a service /end BETA argument), people on this site deserve transparency from admins and mods and have a right to expect as much.
There are great admins on this site and there are good mods, but there are times where you just want to pull your hair out and say enough with this. Today is one of those days.
First off, there need to be less secrets that give any advantage, real or perceived, to "those in the know". At some points, I've been "in the know" about things, and I do my best to share it with those who "aren't in the know" whenever I can. Maybe this post will lead to me not being "in the know" from now on, but whatever.
Secondly, when something is leaked from someone "in the know", there needs to be a process. Bort needs a "crisis binder" for a number of issues that a mod or another admin can look to in a time of need to determine how to best handle a situation.
**Case in point - Test Server becomes public knowlege**
How not to handle this
- Moving a thread with no explanation is not transparent
- Refusing to give an explanation is not transparent
- Deleting other threads on the subject is not transparent
- Locking other threads without explanation is not transparent
- Threatening any bans is not transparent (or a good way to keep a customer base happy)
How to handle it well
- Lock the thread with a good reason and explanation
- Stick that thread, or create a sticky thread about the issue explaining what steps are in progress
- Allow paying customers to freely discuss the issue among themselves as long as they are respectful and not breaking other forum rules.
- Keep the customer base up-to-date until an admin is prepared to speak on the issue.
This is just one example of how a simply situation can be A) a crisis or B) a discussion.
Feel free to discuss, as this should remain open -- I have broken no rules here. And please keep the discussion on transparency as the issue, citing examples only when they support the overall suggestion. Keep discussion relevant so that we can actually have somewhere to talk about this.
Scace
EDIT - A good example of how to handle a tough situation: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2067898
Last edited Feb 13, 2009 14:00:48






























