User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > CPU-owned teams should not be allowed to make the playoffs
Page:
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
In Western Europe AAA #1 Zeta, we had an owner quit towards the end of the season. It now looks like that team will probably end up making the playoffs as the #8 seed. That should not be allowed. It's bad enough that quitting late in the season has screwed up the playoff rankings (that team could've beaten some other teams to change the seeings), but for them to make it into the playoffs and give their first round opponent, in essence, a bye week is ridiculous, especially because it kicks a human owned team out.

If you quit, you shouldn't be in the playoffs, simple as that.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1927170
 
Skoll Wolfrun
offline
Link
 
ad nauseum: -1: no. The team still won enough games to make it in.

This gets Suggested every week:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1969235
Last edited Jan 30, 2009 21:46:03
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
ad nauseum: -1: no. The team still won enough games to make it in.


Bingo.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
How does a team gutting and quitting with 4 games left in the regular season help the game at all?

 
Moebuis
offline
Link
 
I can see if you are talking about a entire gutting (100% CPU players, CPU Owned, no GMs). But if there is one single player/gm left....then they have the right to go to the playoffs.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Valkyrie
I can see if you are talking about a entire gutting (100% CPU players, CPU Owned, no GMs). But if there is one single player/gm left....then they have the right to go to the playoffs.


I'd agree with that.

In this case, the team is 100% CPU, yet will probably make the playoffs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=3285

And no, this doesn't affect my team at all -- in fact, it helped us out by pushing us to (probably) the #4 seed. It still seems wrong though.
Last edited Jan 30, 2009 21:58:34
 
Moebuis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fezmid
Originally posted by Valkyrie

I can see if you are talking about a entire gutting (100% CPU players, CPU Owned, no GMs). But if there is one single player/gm left....then they have the right to go to the playoffs.


I'd agree with that.

In this case, the team is 100% CPU, yet will probably make the playoffs.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=3285


Then IMO that team shouldn't be allowed in. A script could be written to check the roster (owner, GM and player) of a playoff team and if found to be 100% CPU then the team wouldn't qualify. I would support that.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
-1. I hate artificial band-aid solutions.. especially when they are non-solutions fixing non-problems.

If a team doesn't make the Playoffs it is for exactly 1 reason: they didn't win enough games.
 
Moebuis
offline
Link
 
If I were on that team that didn't make the playoffs because of a 100% CPU team, I would be pissed (mind you I would also know that it was because of my team not winning enough). From my view if there isn't a paying customer on a team, why reward that team with the playoffs (which is the goal of the paying customer).

The entire idea behind this game going forward is to keep interest. If this were to happen to paying customers, its not keeping their interest.
Last edited Jan 30, 2009 22:04:51
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Well there's no real way of making sure this doesn't happen...it's just a strange, odd situation that happened here. I'm sure it's happened before and will happen again, but in small quantities...
 
rehash
offline
Link
 
i said something liek this a few days ago.

but instead of a built team disbanding

an owner signed cpu players higher than the league average and made the playoffs as the 8th seed
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Valkyrie
I can see if you are talking about a entire gutting (100% CPU players, CPU Owned, no GMs). But if there is one single player/gm left....then they have the right to go to the playoffs.


I agree completely with this statement. If there is a completely annihilation of the team, then that team should be replaced with another 'playoff worthy' team. But if the team simply goes CPU, the players on that team, should still have the right to play in the playoffs. Just because an owner loses a team or sells it back, shouldn't mean the players lose out as well.
 
Danny7185
offline
Link
 
If you can't beat an all CPU team in the standings you don't deserve to make the playoffs. Still if you were a human owned team that needed to remove a CPU team to make the playoffs you would get embarrassed in your first round game against the #1 seed anyways.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Danny7185
If you can't beat an all CPU team in the standings you don't deserve to make the playoffs. Still if you were a human owned team that needed to remove a CPU team to make the playoffs you would get embarrassed in your first round game against the #1 seed anyways.


What? I think the point of this is, that the Playoffs are about competition, not about GUARANTEED ROUTS. ACTUAL PLAYERS should have the opportunity to play in the playoffs not CPU players
 
rehash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Danny7185
If you can't beat an all CPU team in the standings you don't deserve to make the playoffs. Still if you were a human owned team that needed to remove a CPU team to make the playoffs you would get embarrassed in your first round game against the #1 seed anyways.


what if the team goes 9-0(beatin you), they sell go 100% cpu loss 7 in a row and you tie them for the 8th seed at 9-7, they have the tiebreaker...

thats how a cpu team beats u in standings
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.