We've made steps in the right direction by tweaking the acceleration values to include weight in the equations, from what I understand, but I would like to see things changed a touch more.
My Ideas:
1. Top speed, as well as acceleration and cutting ability need to be influenced by player size:
-Why?: A 300lb offensive tackle should never be able to run a 4.2 40, even with 100 speed.
Consider a player weighing 200lbs to be a sports car. The 300+lb lineman is a truck. Can trucks get up and move? Yes, but they take extraordinary power to do so, and are nowhere near as agile, quick, or top line fast as a sports car (under normal circumstances)
Running a 4.3 40 puts your average speed at about 19.02748 miles per hour.
Now, it takes 1155 newtons of force to propel a 300lb human being that distance
It only takes 771 newtons of force to get a 200lb CB to an average of 19MPH. Obviously, it takes more force, so an offensive lineman should NEVER be able to hit 4.3 MPH (in this game)
Top Skill Position 40: 4.24
Top Offensive Lineman 40: 4.99
2. Changing direction: The heavier you are, the more power you need in order to get that weight to move, AND, the more strength you need to stop that weight, much less change it's direction. Offensive and defensive linemen should NOT be as agile as corner backs, running backs, or wide receivers.
Look at the 3 Cone Drill for 2008 NFL Combine: http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers#tp-tab-set-1:tp-grid-container-three-cone-drill
Top Performers:
RB: 6.65 - WR: 6.57 - DB: 6.74
Now look at the linemen:
DL: 6.90 - OL: 7.21
Any ideas on how to work this in, or am I just overlooking changes that are already in place? From what I see, offensive linemen are moving just as well as CBs with similar agility. Granted, they are a touch slower, but many have 60 speed instead of the 90+ with CBs. Defensive linemen are bouncing all over the place like little jackrabbits and OTs are manhandling lighter, much more mobile defensive ends.
In my opinion, there should be a little more "realism" (word of the season) in terms of player movement and abilities.
My Ideas:
1. Top speed, as well as acceleration and cutting ability need to be influenced by player size:
-Why?: A 300lb offensive tackle should never be able to run a 4.2 40, even with 100 speed.
Consider a player weighing 200lbs to be a sports car. The 300+lb lineman is a truck. Can trucks get up and move? Yes, but they take extraordinary power to do so, and are nowhere near as agile, quick, or top line fast as a sports car (under normal circumstances)
Running a 4.3 40 puts your average speed at about 19.02748 miles per hour.
Now, it takes 1155 newtons of force to propel a 300lb human being that distance
It only takes 771 newtons of force to get a 200lb CB to an average of 19MPH. Obviously, it takes more force, so an offensive lineman should NEVER be able to hit 4.3 MPH (in this game)
Top Skill Position 40: 4.24
Top Offensive Lineman 40: 4.99
2. Changing direction: The heavier you are, the more power you need in order to get that weight to move, AND, the more strength you need to stop that weight, much less change it's direction. Offensive and defensive linemen should NOT be as agile as corner backs, running backs, or wide receivers.
Look at the 3 Cone Drill for 2008 NFL Combine: http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers#tp-tab-set-1:tp-grid-container-three-cone-drill
Top Performers:
RB: 6.65 - WR: 6.57 - DB: 6.74
Now look at the linemen:
DL: 6.90 - OL: 7.21
Any ideas on how to work this in, or am I just overlooking changes that are already in place? From what I see, offensive linemen are moving just as well as CBs with similar agility. Granted, they are a touch slower, but many have 60 speed instead of the 90+ with CBs. Defensive linemen are bouncing all over the place like little jackrabbits and OTs are manhandling lighter, much more mobile defensive ends.
In my opinion, there should be a little more "realism" (word of the season) in terms of player movement and abilities.






























