User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Player Results Affected by Size
Page:
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
We've made steps in the right direction by tweaking the acceleration values to include weight in the equations, from what I understand, but I would like to see things changed a touch more.

My Ideas:
1. Top speed, as well as acceleration and cutting ability need to be influenced by player size:
-Why?: A 300lb offensive tackle should never be able to run a 4.2 40, even with 100 speed.
Consider a player weighing 200lbs to be a sports car. The 300+lb lineman is a truck. Can trucks get up and move? Yes, but they take extraordinary power to do so, and are nowhere near as agile, quick, or top line fast as a sports car (under normal circumstances)

Running a 4.3 40 puts your average speed at about 19.02748 miles per hour.

Now, it takes 1155 newtons of force to propel a 300lb human being that distance
It only takes 771 newtons of force to get a 200lb CB to an average of 19MPH. Obviously, it takes more force, so an offensive lineman should NEVER be able to hit 4.3 MPH (in this game)

Top Skill Position 40: 4.24
Top Offensive Lineman 40: 4.99

2. Changing direction: The heavier you are, the more power you need in order to get that weight to move, AND, the more strength you need to stop that weight, much less change it's direction. Offensive and defensive linemen should NOT be as agile as corner backs, running backs, or wide receivers.

Look at the 3 Cone Drill for 2008 NFL Combine: http://www.nfl.com/combine/top-performers#tp-tab-set-1:tp-grid-container-three-cone-drill

Top Performers:
RB: 6.65 - WR: 6.57 - DB: 6.74

Now look at the linemen:

DL: 6.90 - OL: 7.21


Any ideas on how to work this in, or am I just overlooking changes that are already in place? From what I see, offensive linemen are moving just as well as CBs with similar agility. Granted, they are a touch slower, but many have 60 speed instead of the 90+ with CBs. Defensive linemen are bouncing all over the place like little jackrabbits and OTs are manhandling lighter, much more mobile defensive ends.

In my opinion, there should be a little more "realism" (word of the season) in terms of player movement and abilities.
 
Link
 
hmmmmmm........ Interesting
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
For months, atleast 6, I've argued that Player Weights should be determined by Physical Attributes.

I posted dozens of times a formula which could be used to make weights better reflect the actual attributes of Players - but for some reason Bort seems to think that how strong a Player is has no impact upon how much they weigh. Probably for the same reason that OT's are able to weigh 300 lbs and still run as fast as WRs.
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
As long as its done by weight and not position, I like it. I should however be able to make a 200lb DE, who will be incredibly fast, just have no strength.
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
i have supported this in the past. also, a type of weight training system would work well as well with this.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
I thought about making strength relative to size as well, but I couldn't find anything to back up my opinion.

However, Yoshi is right. There is NO way offensive linemen should be as mobile as skill positions. Should they have quick feet? Sure, but nothing like a WR or CB
 
al0x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz

However, Yoshi is right. There is NO way offensive linemen should be as mobile as skill positions. Should they have quick feet? Sure, but nothing like a WR or CB


Always use weights, not positions. An OT could weigh the same as a CB, would be as agile, and would be terrible as he would be as strong. But it could be possible.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
For months, atleast 6, I've argued that Player Weights should be determined by Physical Attributes.

I posted dozens of times a formula which could be used to make weights better reflect the actual attributes of Players - but for some reason Bort seems to think that how strong a Player is has no impact upon how much they weigh. Probably for the same reason that OT's are able to weigh 300 lbs and still run as fast as WRs.


This is something that I have come to support fully. However, I'm not sure how it would work in this current sim.

I'm a strong believer that it COULD happen that someone who weighs 300 lbs could run a 4.2 but it would take a lot of work, and take away from some other things.

So therefore, I think that if it was made so that the Level Caps were lowered based on weight size and positon..it might seem a little more realistic.

100 speed would still be 100 speed but would require a lot more SPs.

 
Staz
offline
Link
 
I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.


I think you are right, and I think if he's not gonna go for that he's never gonna do anything about it.

He tried to start a thread about it back in the day, and he got blasted by the whiners..so that usually means they win.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alex2544
Originally posted by Staz


However, Yoshi is right. There is NO way offensive linemen should be as mobile as skill positions. Should they have quick feet? Sure, but nothing like a WR or CB


Always use weights, not positions. An OT could weigh the same as a CB, would be as agile, and would be terrible as he would be as strong. But it could be possible.


Yeah, I agree with you on this one. Weight should be the main factor, and not position.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ThaOutlaw
Originally posted by Staz

I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.


I think you are right, and I think if he's not gonna go for that he's never gonna do anything about it.

He tried to start a thread about it back in the day, and he got blasted by the whiners..so that usually means they win.


I think he knows that something needs to be done, but if you take a look at all the stuff on his plate, it just stacks up. Hopefully, Thorn aiding in the coding of the game will speed things up and increase the rate and quality of the 'fixes'
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staz
Originally posted by ThaOutlaw

Originally posted by Staz


I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.


I think you are right, and I think if he's not gonna go for that he's never gonna do anything about it.

He tried to start a thread about it back in the day, and he got blasted by the whiners..so that usually means they win.


I think he knows that something needs to be done, but if you take a look at all the stuff on his plate, it just stacks up. Hopefully, Thorn aiding in the coding of the game will speed things up and increase the rate and quality of the 'fixes'


I'm not sure, the amount of flaming he took for even suggesting that weight should play a part in speed/acceleraion I think may have completely turned him off from it.

Not enough people like to support good ideas, as look to flame them.

I hope he decides to implement SOMETHING though.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
That's because everybody wants to be able to build a super player without any intelligence. He just needs to mystery update things lol
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
just my $.02. but, if bort decides to go with the "realism" route like his poll then maybe height/weight will matter more? since we are heading for a more realistic game?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.