User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > 4th and 7.5 to go on their 24 yard line...
Page:
 
Romulan
offline
Link
 
We lost the game by 3 points. I noticed that even though I have two SOLID kickers my team decided to go for it on 4th and 7 from the 24.

WTF? is this a bug? it cost me the game and I cant think of any other reason besides a bug.
 
Romulan
offline
Link
 
I realize this is a beta but WOW...

I was looking at the play by play of my team in this morning's game which we lost 10-7.

We went for it on 4th down about 3 to 4 times in different quarters from their red zone.

As far as I know I have not option to decide how... aggresive I want to set my game plan when it comes to 4th downs, and its not like I didnt have my kickers on the depth chart.

Is this a known bug?
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
are you sure you have a solid kicker?
Because he has only 10.5 Strength, which means he has a really bad range
 
Romulan
offline
Link
 
Serenity I understand what your saying but we are talking about inside the 20... then again I am not a alpha tester so maybe your right and that is what it was.
 
xTrav
offline
Link
 
Same thing happened to my team too.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romulan
Serenity I understand what your saying but we are talking about inside the 20... then again I am not a alpha tester so maybe your right and that is what it was.

I'm guessing it was this play you're talking about

0:53 4th & 0.5 OPP 13.5 HEGEMON HELLAS pass to Marlon Daigle over the middle (incomplete) (turnover on downs)
That's about a 30.5 yard FG, which would be pretty far for someone with 10 strength

get your kicker to work on strength and vision and you'll see his range get farther out
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
if your team isn't kicking the field goal at that range it is because your kicker can't hit them from that range...improve the kicker and you'll see more FG attempts...

think pop-warner for levels 1-10...
 
Fat Banana
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
if your team isn't kicking the field goal at that range it is because your kicker can't hit them from that range...improve the kicker and you'll see more FG attempts...

think pop-warner for levels 1-10...


In our game there was enough time for one more play before halftime. Our team had the ball on the opponents 13 yards line. The play called is a run up the middle for four yards and then it's halftime?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=6531&mode=pbp

I would think that even in pop-warner if there is only enough time for one more play on the opponents 13 yard line they'd at least attempt a field goal. Later in the fourth quarter our kicker hit a longer FG from the opponents 18 yard line. A FG before the half could have meant the difference in the game as our team ended up losing by 3 in OT.

 
longshot201
offline
Link
 
same thing, look at this last few plays of the game

0:45 4th & 2 OPP 31.5 Edward Trents pass to Huddie Ledbetter up the right side (6.5 yd gain) [tackle: JD Benjamin] Replay
0:11 1st & 10 OPP 25 Edward Trents pass to Kory Reid up the right side [deflected by Speed Killer] (incomplete) Replay
0:08 2nd & 10 OPP 25 Edward Trents pass to Kory Reid up the right side (8.5 yd gain) [tackle: Michael McLaren]

with the clock stoped on 25 yard line, it should just be natural to have the kicker kick it
 
arscola
offline
Link
 
I really don't think this is a true bug, more of a gameplan type issue IMHO.

Probably wouldn't be a bad idea to put something in the gameplan to combat these type of situations. Maybe a slider bar for Max FG Length. This way if the GM puts his kicker in to kick 50+ yard FG's and they almost certainly miss then it's on the GM.

Also maybe something for those final seconds before halftime to run the kicker in, instead of running up the middle or throwing a short pass that kills the final few seconds on the clock. Maybe a checkbox to say "Attempt FG Inside 25 yard line Final 10 seconds before the half? Yes or No".
 
Fat Banana
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arscola
I really don't think this is a true bug, more of a gameplan type issue IMHO.

Probably wouldn't be a bad idea to put something in the gameplan to combat these type of situations. Maybe a slider bar for Max FG Length. This way if the GM puts his kicker in to kick 50+ yard FG's and they almost certainly miss then it's on the GM.

Also maybe something for those final seconds before halftime to run the kicker in, instead of running up the middle or throwing a short pass that kills the final few seconds on the clock. Maybe a checkbox to say "Attempt FG Inside 25 yard line Final 10 seconds before the half? Yes or No".



That sounds like it could work. Something is needed because to have the ball on your opponents 13 yard line just before halftime and not even at least attempt a field goal on the final play of the half IMO is not very realistic even for pop warner.
 
reo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romulan
I realize this is a beta but WOW...

I was looking at the play by play of my team in this morning's game which we lost 10-7.

We went for it on 4th down about 3 to 4 times in different quarters from their red zone.

As far as I know I have not option to decide how... aggresive I want to set my game plan when it comes to 4th downs, and its not like I didnt have my kickers on the depth chart.

Is this a known bug?


Since this is Beta. When do they plan on wiping everyone and starting all over? Do they plan on giving all our flex points back?
 
Romulan
offline
Link
 
I do like the idea of giving us a slider for FG's that was mentioned in this thread. We definately need more say in the game plan.
But something tells me the Devs are already taking care of that...
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reo
Originally posted by Romulan

I realize this is a beta but WOW...

I was looking at the play by play of my team in this morning's game which we lost 10-7.

We went for it on 4th down about 3 to 4 times in different quarters from their red zone.

As far as I know I have not option to decide how... aggresive I want to set my game plan when it comes to 4th downs, and its not like I didnt have my kickers on the depth chart.

Is this a known bug?


Since this is Beta. When do they plan on wiping everyone and starting all over? Do they plan on giving all our flex points back?


we wiped alpha, not wiping beta. beta = "work in progress"
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romulan
I do like the idea of giving us a slider for FG's that was mentioned in this thread. We definately need more say in the game plan.
But something tells me the Devs are already taking care of that...


yes, we have more advanced tactics already being worked on that solve the issue.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.