User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Force Fumbles - Why are there not enough of them?
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I understand in the nfl there not a ton in every game however if a player has over 60 in speed, agility, strength, and tackling I think he shoudl be good for 1 every other game or so. When these kind of LBs can't even force a fumble on a gutted team says there is something off.

Anyone agree with this?
 
Bopher1
offline
Link
 
I noticed they are down this year... A lot.. Maybe 1 or 2 a game is normal, but 0 over a 5 game span?
 
Jaxx
offline
Link
 
Subject has already been addressed in a long thread.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
I understand in the nfl there not a ton in every game however if a player has over 60 in speed, agility, strength, and tackling I think he shoudl be good for 1 every other game or so. When these kind of LBs can't even force a fumble on a gutted team says there is something off.

Anyone agree with this?


everytime I play a gutted team all my defensive guys get at least 1. One game my D.E. got 9 FF's in one game.
Last edited Jan 20, 2009 06:32:50
 
Paratroopa1
offline
Link
 
You know, forced fumbles are really pretty rare in actual football. I mean, if you're a strong defensive player with only 1 or 2 forced fumbles the whole year, that's pretty much par for the course. As for gutted teams, does it really need to be any worse for them?
Last edited Jan 20, 2009 06:34:42
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Paratroopa1
You know, forced fumbles are really pretty rare in actual football. I mean, if you're a strong defensive player with only 1 or 2 forced fumbles the whole year, that's pretty much par for the course. As for gutted teams, does it really need to be any worse for them?


exactly. but everyone will complain and it will be berfed and everyone will fumble next season watch.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
this topic is pretty ridiculous because if they get nerfed and everyone starts fumbling. the guys with 70+ str and 8 or 9 in monster hit, and 15 in power tackler will force 100 a season.
 
Paratroopa1
offline
Link
 
The problem with trying to build a player that forces fumbles is that's just... well, it's a bad idea, to put it bluntly. Forced fumbles aren't something that you go out and try to get, they're something that just happen. If the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (as in, properly covering up the ball) and the guy tackling the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (going for the tackle first and the strip second, not the other way around - and I HATE it when players do it the other way around in non-desperation situations), then forced fumbles just don't happen too frequently. A lot of "forced" fumbles are half hard hits but half freak accidents. Even then, you gotta be in the right place at the right time. You only make so many tackles in one game. Like maybe 6-7 at most (if you make any more than that chances are you're not playing particularly well). So... yeah, no. And definitely just saying "well I have 60 strength and tackling" doesn't cut it, you gotta have like 100 strength and 10 in Monster Hit before I go "yeah, you have a point," 60 in a stat really isn't a lot. And think about it, if lots of strength and lots of Big/Monster Hit were a surefire way to see an increased production in forced fumbles... then fumbles would be happening a LOT and this game would become an exploitable mess. I think the forced fumble rate is PERFECT as it stands, and players shouldn't be striving to try to force them. They just happen.
 
addddddum
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Paratroopa1
I think the forced fumble rate is PERFECT as it stands


QFT

/thread
 
l4boMb4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Paratroopa1
Forced fumbles aren't something that you go out and try to get, they're something that just happen. If the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (as in, properly covering up the ball) and the guy tackling the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (going for the tackle first and the strip second, not the other way around - and I HATE it when players do it the other way around in non-desperation situations), then forced fumbles just don't happen too frequently.


Forcing fumbles is something actively pursued by defensive personel. Proper tackling techniques, strips, helmet placement, etc. are all touched upon in almost every practice.

However, just because you make an incorrect statement...I still believe you are right in the notion that things shouldn't be touched much if at all. The fumble rate could be tweaked a tad, but its fairly close to being where it should be.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Paratroopa1
The problem with trying to build a player that forces fumbles is that's just... well, it's a bad idea, to put it bluntly. Forced fumbles aren't something that you go out and try to get, they're something that just happen. If the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (as in, properly covering up the ball) and the guy tackling the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (going for the tackle first and the strip second, not the other way around - and I HATE it when players do it the other way around in non-desperation situations), then forced fumbles just don't happen too frequently. A lot of "forced" fumbles are half hard hits but half freak accidents. Even then, you gotta be in the right place at the right time. You only make so many tackles in one game. Like maybe 6-7 at most (if you make any more than that chances are you're not playing particularly well). So... yeah, no. And definitely just saying "well I have 60 strength and tackling" doesn't cut it, you gotta have like 100 strength and 10 in Monster Hit before I go "yeah, you have a point," 60 in a stat really isn't a lot. And think about it, if lots of strength and lots of Big/Monster Hit were a surefire way to see an increased production in forced fumbles... then fumbles would be happening a LOT and this game would become an exploitable mess. I think the forced fumble rate is PERFECT as it stands, and players shouldn't be striving to try to force them. They just happen.


I pretty much agree with this, but there are three different tackling settings, and they should mean something. At the very least, power tackling should bring with it a significant increase in fumbling and missed tackles. Not necessarily a fumble per game against equal competition, but something close to the high-end of the rate of fumbles per tackle in the NFL (if the player otherwise has a build to support forcing fumbles).
Last edited Jan 20, 2009 06:58:24
 
Paratroopa1
offline
Link
 
I guess I said that kind of wrong - defensive players do attempt to strip the ball, yes, and that's the right thing to do - but it's not the kind of stat one actively pursues above all other things, you don't expect to strip the ball every play or even every game, and if you don't that's not considered a bad game.

Also, guys really should be making sure they're bringing the guy down before they try to punch the ball out. It's a really simple fundamental but it needs to be said. I've watched some terrible defenses over the years not get this one.
 
Paratroopa1
offline
Link
 
Also, as far as an increase in fumbling goes, there probably is an increase in fumbling, but the problem is, if you see, let's say, an average of 2 forced fumbles per season, which I feel is reasonable... let's say that's out of 70 tackles in one season for a player on a middle-of-the-road defense? So that'd be 1 forced fumble in 35 tackles, which sounds accurate to me. Maybe power tackling would increase that to what, an average of 1 forced fumble in 25 tackles? That's still averaging out to like 2.5 forced fumbles a season. It's gonna be a percentage thing, and it's just hard to see a definitive change in the number of forced fumbles you're seeing without there being WAY too many of them. It seems illogical but there's no way around it.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by l4boMb4
Originally posted by Paratroopa1

Forced fumbles aren't something that you go out and try to get, they're something that just happen. If the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (as in, properly covering up the ball) and the guy tackling the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (going for the tackle first and the strip second, not the other way around - and I HATE it when players do it the other way around in non-desperation situations), then forced fumbles just don't happen too frequently.


Forcing fumbles is something actively pursued by defensive personel. Proper tackling techniques, strips, helmet placement, etc. are all touched upon in almost every practice.

However, just because you make an incorrect statement...I still believe you are right in the notion that things shouldn't be touched much if at all. The fumble rate could be tweaked a tad, but its fairly close to being where it should be.


OOOOOOO and every practice the offense makes it a point to do hand off drills and making sure they hang on to the ball.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Paratroopa1

The problem with trying to build a player that forces fumbles is that's just... well, it's a bad idea, to put it bluntly. Forced fumbles aren't something that you go out and try to get, they're something that just happen. If the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (as in, properly covering up the ball) and the guy tackling the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (going for the tackle first and the strip second, not the other way around - and I HATE it when players do it the other way around in non-desperation situations), then forced fumbles just don't happen too frequently. A lot of "forced" fumbles are half hard hits but half freak accidents. Even then, you gotta be in the right place at the right time. You only make so many tackles in one game. Like maybe 6-7 at most (if you make any more than that chances are you're not playing particularly well). So... yeah, no. And definitely just saying "well I have 60 strength and tackling" doesn't cut it, you gotta have like 100 strength and 10 in Monster Hit before I go "yeah, you have a point," 60 in a stat really isn't a lot. And think about it, if lots of strength and lots of Big/Monster Hit were a surefire way to see an increased production in forced fumbles... then fumbles would be happening a LOT and this game would become an exploitable mess. I think the forced fumble rate is PERFECT as it stands, and players shouldn't be striving to try to force them. They just happen.


I pretty much agree with this, but there are three different tackling settings, and they should mean something. At the very least, power tackling should bring with it a significant increase in fumbling and missed tackles. Not necessarily a fumble per game against equal competition, but something close to the high-end of the rate of fumbles per tackle in the NFL (if the player otherwise has a build to support forcing fumbles).


Power tackling does work better than wrap up.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.