User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ITT: Necessary and indisputable fixes to GLB
Page:
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
First and foremost, this isn't a complaint, just a general list of things that are (in my opinion) unarguably faults of the game that should be addressed sooner rather than later. This also isn't a suggestion; however, if Bort, DD, or another admin would like to hear my suggestions for these problems, I would be more than happy to address it via a PM. The thread is meant to bring up these issues and hopefully the community can give their opinions on what is within the thread in hopes of getting these things changed for the betterment of the game.

These are in no specific order
Some are very general and they don't necessarily relate to one another
Not included are things like CB Coverage, DE Nerfs, etc that aren't as cut and dry as these


- Throwing the ball away was implemented -- but I've never seen it happen.

- Timeouts are ridiculously inconsistent.

- Hands Special Ability and Smooth Operator Special Ability are beyond useless since there are currently no penalties.

- Monster Hit, Big Hit, and Big Sack seem to have zero additional effect of forcing fumbles.

- Spiking the ball or at the least kneeling the ball at the end of the game.

- Onside kicks aren't in the game. Down by 10 with less than 2 minutes to go? Game's over. Should be relatively easy to code.

- There are no two-point conversions. Down by 8 and on the goal line? Too bad. Again, shouldn't be too difficult to code.

- Quarterbacks rarely fumble the ball when they should be the most likely candidate to fumble.

- There are no replays for Field Goals, when they are a major source of scoring in the game. Seeing "made" or watching a kick is quite a big difference.

- Punt returns and coverage are ridiculous and that's all that needs to be said about them.

- WRs currently have no delayed reaction time when a ball is thrown off target. This could be the reason why CB coverage is a little screwy (See: ineffective).

- HBs are able to break 4+ tackles on a play (which in some cases is understandable), but the fact that broken tackles from behind occur a lot on those plays is iffy.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
so, deal with it.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
This should be moved to suggestions, and then locked because all this stuff is epic, so Bort can get back to not even looking at that forum.
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458

- Punt returns and coverage are ridiculous and that's all that needs to be said about them.


makes me wonder why I have 11 in SA Change Direction and Return Specialist! Still praying that this will come in handy one day...please!!!!
Last edited Jan 19, 2009 23:26:44
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Pretty much listed all the current issues, except for the issues with Dline vs. Oline, Run blocking seems fine, but pass blocking is all or nothing right now.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Also to add to the legit concerns, FB blocking is pretty bugged sometimes. FBs turn around to block LBs behind the HB because they see them as a threat. Today I saw a FB go through the hole, then turn around and run into the backfield because the RDE broke his block.

Here's some examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289999&pbp_id=6786437
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=355063&pbp_id=8026964 (the one I mentioned...terrible)

The first one wouldn't be so bad if the TE didn't already pick up that block...
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
This should be moved to suggestions, and then locked because all this stuff is epic, so Bort can get back to not even looking at that forum.


haha
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.
so? in real life they should be going for 2 more often too. 2pt conversion rate is approx 60% which means on average better to go for 2 (expected value 1.2 pts) than XP (expected value < 1 pt).

i for one would go for 2 on every play, but i'm also the guy that always went for it on 4th and 2 or less every time (because if you can't get 2 yards, you might as well give up)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
First and foremost, this isn't a complaint, just a general list of things that are (in my opinion) unarguably faults of the game that should be addressed sooner rather than later. This also isn't a suggestion; however, if Bort, DD, or another admin would like to hear my suggestions for these problems, I would be more than happy to address it via a PM. The thread is meant to bring up these issues and hopefully the community can give their opinions on what is within the thread in hopes of getting these things changed for the betterment of the game.

These are in no specific order
Some are very general and they don't necessarily relate to one another
Not included are things like CB Coverage, DE Nerfs, etc that aren't as cut and dry as these


- Throwing the ball away was implemented -- but I've never seen it happen.

- Timeouts are ridiculously inconsistent.

- Hands Special Ability and Smooth Operator Special Ability are beyond useless since there are currently no penalties.

- Monster Hit, Big Hit, and Big Sack seem to have zero additional effect of forcing fumbles.

- Spiking the ball or at the least kneeling the ball at the end of the game.

- Onside kicks aren't in the game. Down by 10 with less than 2 minutes to go? Game's over. Should be relatively easy to code.

- There are no two-point conversions. Down by 8 and on the goal line? Too bad. Again, shouldn't be too difficult to code.

- Quarterbacks rarely fumble the ball when they should be the most likely candidate to fumble.

- There are no replays for Field Goals, when they are a major source of scoring in the game. Seeing "made" or watching a kick is quite a big difference.

- Punt returns and coverage are ridiculous and that's all that needs to be said about them.

- WRs currently have no delayed reaction time when a ball is thrown off target. This could be the reason why CB coverage is a little screwy (See: ineffective).

- HBs are able to break 4+ tackles on a play (which in some cases is understandable), but the fact that broken tackles from behind occur a lot on those plays is iffy.



A lot of these things seem logical, but there are problems

1) 2-pt conversions can be coded, but they would be absurd in this game. It's ridiculously easy to get 2 yards for one. Bort can't seem to code a realistic 3rd/4th and short, so this would just be far too easy. Most teams would go for 2 100% of the time. In games where it's not an even matchup (ie most games), the dominant team would have a success rate approaching 100% even with the defender calling the best possible play.

2) Forcing fumbles is a tricky subject. As soon as this game introduces a reliable way to force fumbles, it will become a turnover-happy mess. The rate of FF's is one of the things GLB actually has right. Do you realize that the top players in the NFL usually only force 1-3 fumbles per year? Big Hit/Sack/Monster Hit should do different things. Maybe more of an effect on the ball carrier's stamina... make his backup more likely to take the next few snaps...

3) Quarterbacks fumbling when sacked is another touchy subject. We still have a HUGE parity problem in this game, meaning a slew of games see the QB sacked all game long. Do we really want to see the underdogs turning the ball over even more, and losing even worse? I'd agree that if we had better parity this would be a cool idea, but it's just not a good idea until Bort finds a way to get similar teams to play each other on a more reliable basis.



PS - I agree with you on pretty much all your other points though.
Last edited Jan 20, 2009 05:27:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.
so? in real life they should be going for 2 more often too. 2pt conversion rate is approx 60% which means on average better to go for 2 (expected value 1.2 pts) than XP (expected value < 1 pt).

i for one would go for 2 on every play, but i'm also the guy that always went for it on 4th and 2 or less every time (because if you can't get 2 yards, you might as well give up)


That's why people like you aren't allowed to coach football.
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury


A lot of these things seem logical, but there are problems

1) 2-pt conversions can be coded, but they would be absurd in this game. It's ridiculously easy to get 2 yards for one. Bort can't seem to code a realistic 3rd/4th and short, so this would just be far too easy. Most teams would go for 2 100% of the time. In games where it's not an even matchup (ie most games), the dominant team would have a success rate approaching 100% even with the defender calling the best possible play.

2) Forcing fumbles is a tricky subject. As soon as this game introduces a reliable way to force fumbles, it will become a turnover-happy mess. The rate of FF's is one of the things GLB actually has right. Do you realize that the top players in the NFL usually only force 1-3 fumbles per year? Big Hit/Sack/Monster Hit should do different things. Maybe more of an effect on the ball carrier's stamina... make his backup more likely to take the next few snaps...

3) Quarterbacks fumbling when sacked is another touchy subject. We still have a HUGE parity problem in this game, meaning a slew of games see the QB sacked all game long. Do we really want to see the underdogs turning the ball over even more, and losing even worse? I'd agree that if we had better parity this would be a cool idea, but it's just not a good idea until Bort finds a way to get similar teams to play each other on a more reliable basis.

PS - I agree with you on pretty much all your other points though.


1) Agreed. But there are ways around it. You can do 2 pt conversions ONLY in certain situations (when down by a certain amount) OR have them start from the 4 yard line instead of the 2 yard line. I know, it's not how they do it in the NFL, but let's face it, this game isn't the NFL. And getting 4 yards is far tougher than two.

2) It is a tricky subject, but I still think their should be more fumbles. If you build a guy that tries to force fumbles, he should force more fumbles and miss more tackles. The player should be more susceptible to spins & jukes & getting plowed over (even moreso than what power tackling is right now, but that's sort of a mystery so I won't get into that).

3) It still should happen more. Big Sack is essentially useless right now. Yeah, underdogs would get beat a little more, but they'd also get to the opposing QB as well. Offenses wouldn't be as good because of the turnovers (and right now they're overpowered). I'm not saying EVERY sack should be a fumble, but higher than the current percentage of 1%. Big sack should cause a fumble way more often. You could make a VA for QBs like "Blindside" to help protect them from fumbling. Carrying and vision could also be part of this (to prepare to get hit). Just throwing ideas out there.

My main point is -- I see what you're saying, but just because the way the game is built now doesn't mean we shouldn't explore these options of typical occurrences in the NFL (QBs fumbling, 2 pt conversions, etc.)
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.


I could see onside kicks being used in the same vein, if there was a decent chance of recovering them.

And no, not really all that easy to code. Bouncing footballs aren't exactly easy to model math-wise.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.


I could see onside kicks being used in the same vein, if there was a decent chance of recovering them.

And no, not really all that easy to code. Bouncing footballs aren't exactly easy to model math-wise.


sorry to hi-jack this but bort can you check this thread out

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1908165
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

I can see the 2 point conversion being abused. With how easy it is to get 2 yds, I bet people would go for 2 after every TD and succeed with regularity.


I could see onside kicks being used in the same vein, if there was a decent chance of recovering them.

And no, not really all that easy to code. Bouncing footballs aren't exactly easy to model math-wise.


Understandable. Then don't show it (like FGs). It'd then be just rolling dice. And it can only be used in certain situations.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.