User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add "holding" for OT's... without throwing the flag.
PDO
offline
Link
 
Since the flag for this still doesn't exist... I have a different solution. It seems since 90% of the time a DE gets by an OT, he gets shoved/pulled back in, why not add an aspect to the sim that results in an OT not being able to touch the DE once he passes a certain vector since it would result in the flag being tossed?

It's beyond ridiculous to watch a DE blow by an OT... and then be sucked back to him with no chance of a flag being tossed, so wouldn't this open up an easy alternative?


Edit: Fuck me, I meant to put this in the suggestion forum.
Last edited Jan 16, 2009 01:44:27
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Moved for you.

Interesting...
 
Link
 
i dont know why holding wasnt part of the false start and encroachment penatly add-on...probably since it doesnt require movement in the replay for it to happen...but i'd like to see in-game penalties to start coming aboard and holding can definitely become that kind of penalty...such as the OT let a sack happen and his confidence is low, so he holds the guy to make sure he doesnt do that again
 
PDO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Moved for you.

Interesting...


Thank you good sir.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PDO
Since the flag for this still doesn't exist... I have a different solution. It seems since 90% of the time a DE gets by an OT, he gets shoved/pulled back in, why not add an aspect to the sim that results in an OT not being able to touch the DE once he passes a certain vector since it would result in the flag being tossed?

It's beyond ridiculous to watch a DE blow by an OT... and then be sucked back to him with no chance of a flag being tossed, so wouldn't this open up an easy alternative?


Edit: Fuck me, I meant to put this in the suggestion forum.


Actually, once a DE reaches a certain vector the OT would shove him instead of try to stay in front of him - and the DE in many cases would run himself out of the play by sheer momentum (real life) - which allows the OT to re-establish himself for another go-round. That doesn't happen in GLB with the ability to turn 135 degrees at full speed.

Want to make the DE/OT battle a good one where we don't need constant nerfing - make that top end speed have a momentum penalty. You don't see 100 meter runners stop on a dime at the finish line for a reason - they'd risk seriously hurting themselves if they did. In GLB players not only do that - they proceed in the opposite direction they just came from in one fluid motion with virtually no speed loss. They cover 5 yards on the ground in the direction of the throw by the time the receiver catches the ball after it's been thrown - thats crazy. If the average speed of a pass is 40-45 mph then they stop their rush, do a 180 degree turn AND get up to 25 mpb INSTANTANEOUSLY.

There is your DE problem - in a nutshell - and DE's expect OT's to be able to do the exact same thing when they scream "get a better build". The whole argument is in fantasy land.
Last edited Jan 16, 2009 02:50:33
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by PDO

Since the flag for this still doesn't exist... I have a different solution. It seems since 90% of the time a DE gets by an OT, he gets shoved/pulled back in, why not add an aspect to the sim that results in an OT not being able to touch the DE once he passes a certain vector since it would result in the flag being tossed?

It's beyond ridiculous to watch a DE blow by an OT... and then be sucked back to him with no chance of a flag being tossed, so wouldn't this open up an easy alternative?


Edit: Fuck me, I meant to put this in the suggestion forum.


Actually, once a DE reaches a certain vector the OT would shove him instead of try to stay in front of him - and the DE in many cases would run himself out of the play by sheer momentum (real life) - which allows the OT to re-establish himself for another go-round. That doesn't happen in GLB with the ability to turn 135 degrees at full speed.

Want to make the DE/OT battle a good one where we don't need constant nerfing - make that top end speed have a momentum penalty. You don't see 100 meter runners stop on a dime at the finish line for a reason - they'd risk seriously hurting themselves if they did. In GLB players not only do that - they proceed in the opposite direction they just came from in one fluid motion with virtually no speed loss. They cover 5 yards on the ground in the direction of the throw by the time the receiver catches the ball after it's been thrown - thats crazy. If the average speed of a pass is 40-45 mph then they stop their rush, do a 180 degree turn AND get up to 25 mpb INSTANTANEOUSLY.

There is your DE problem - in a nutshell - and DE's expect OT's to be able to do the exact same thing when they scream "get a better build". The whole argument is in fantasy land.


this
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
I suggested this as a way to add it into the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1828170&page=last
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Since I don't want to start a quote pyramid, I'll just say greengoose nailed it there.

As for the OP, it's not just OTs, it's really all blockers. The worst is on run-blocking, the RB will get past the LoS and the D-line will still sometimes not be able to get off blocks. That's pretty bad.
 
SoxPhan21
offline
Link
 
hooty hoo
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
you could learn alot by watchin this show

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dN3nSuvUM0Q&feature=related
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose


Actually, once a DE reaches a certain vector the OT would shove him instead of try to stay in front of him - and the DE in many cases would run himself out of the play by sheer momentum (real life) - which allows the OT to re-establish himself for another go-round. That doesn't happen in GLB with the ability to turn 135 degrees at full speed.

Want to make the DE/OT battle a good one where we don't need constant nerfing - make that top end speed have a momentum penalty. You don't see 100 meter runners stop on a dime at the finish line for a reason - they'd risk seriously hurting themselves if they did. In GLB players not only do that - they proceed in the opposite direction they just came from in one fluid motion with virtually no speed loss. They cover 5 yards on the ground in the direction of the throw by the time the receiver catches the ball after it's been thrown - thats crazy. If the average speed of a pass is 40-45 mph then they stop their rush, do a 180 degree turn AND get up to 25 mpb INSTANTANEOUSLY.

There is your DE problem - in a nutshell - and DE's expect OT's to be able to do the exact same thing when they scream "get a better build". The whole argument is in fantasy land.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1852749

Point #2 - Momentum and Directional Vectors. Doesn't list this explicitly but such a thing would be done with a simulation reprogram and deal directly with changing movement mechanics.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.