User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A FIX without nerfing player builds!!!
Page:
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
The biggest problem is not being able to choose which defenders are in the game based on what offensive players are in the game.

It wouldnt be hard to have a setting that says:

If opponents HB#1 is in than LB # ? is in.

If opponents HB#2 is in than LB # ? is in.

If WR #1 is in than CB# ? is in.

This could be done for each position and would dramatically help. No need to nerf builds if the defense could specifically choose who is on certain plays. At that point it would be up to the teams to find the right talent and sub them in accordingly.

PLEASE BORT....this can be done!!!!!
 
Nino
offline
Link
 
Agree completely!!!

No need to nerf power backs or anyone else. Just find the right talent and sub them in...great idea!!!
 
Destroyer
offline
Link
 
Definitely!! This would solve so many things!!!

Gets my vote!!!!
 
Muscleheads
offline
Link
 
Gets my vote too! Great idea!
 
mikejano
offline
Link
 
Perfect!!!! Quit changing the abilities of players and rather allow proper subbing to match talent to talent
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Sure and this could lead to 12 men on the field penalties depending on how tired the defenders are who are constantly subbing in and out.

Actually this is a great idea, I'd put the following provisions in:

If implemented, no one could ever whine about players being to good or not good enough again with the sole exception of people on offense who may need to be boosted to compensate for the advantage the D has of lining people up as they please.
Last edited Jan 6, 2009 13:10:36
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
would the offense get this too.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
This doesn't solve anything for the teams that don't modify their entire AI for each game, which are the vast majority of GLB teams. The game needs to be balanced regardless of who's on the field (which is not to say that having reaction substitutions is bad - just that it won't solve the overall problem of overpowered specific builds).
 
Chessey
offline
Link
 
Nerfing is done so players aren't too dominate. SO if you don't nerf they will still be too good. They need to be nerfed because no one can compete.
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
because if the offense gets this how would you do this logic defense player 2 goes in if hb goes in hb goes in if defense 2 is in. which one goes in first? i would have to say offense beccause they could sub and hike the ball before the defense could get on the field.
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chessey
Nerfing is done so players aren't too dominate. SO if you don't nerf they will still be too good. They need to be nerfed because no one can compete.


but when every position needs nerfed who do you start with.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mbking
would the offense get this too.


No because the defense is selecting based off who is in on offense.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chessey
Nerfing is done so players aren't too dominate. SO if you don't nerf they will still be too good. They need to be nerfed because no one can compete.


Power backs needs LB's with 60-70 strength and 60-70 tackling. That will stop the powerbacks. But then they cant stop the elusive backs. Thats the problem!!

We just need to be able to properly sub based on the offensive personnel.
 
Crawly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
We just need to be able to properly sub based on the offensive personnel.

No, we just need builds to be reasonably realistic. You don't get the entire defense changing every time the Giants sub out Jacobs and bring in Ward. The same group of defenders should be reasonably capable of stopping both speed, agility, and power backs, in theory (and should be reasonably vulnerable to all three, too). Having multiple distinct defensive units sub in and out based on who's in the game doesn't solve anything.

 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crawly
This doesn't solve anything for the teams that don't modify their entire AI for each game, which are the vast majority of GLB teams. The game needs to be balanced regardless of who's on the field (which is not to say that having reaction substitutions is bad - just that it won't solve the overall problem of overpowered specific builds).


Is it our fault that teams dont utilize the functions of this game. The AI is instrumental in success. Its part of the game.

If you choose not to use it than thats your choice but it is a part of the game and if used properly it can make your team compete no matter who you are facing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.