User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Start with:

Overall: 75
Offense: 75
Defense: 75

When you drop a player on offense, it subtracts it from both the offense and the overall.

Thus we have:

Overall: 72
Offense: 72
Defense: 75

Now, say you drop someone from Defense. Again it takes from both defense and overall

Overall: 69
Offense: 72
Defense: 72

This is working exactly as intended. If the overall were an average of the offense and defense there would be no point in calculating it. As Bort has said in a different thread, it takes "more" to get an entire team on the same page (overall chemistry) than it does to get half a team going (offense or defense).
 
nautilus
offline
Link
 
Still don't understand what exact impact it has...any insight?
Last edited Oct 19, 2008 23:58:31
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
I guess I don't understand either so let me put it this way, using your example:

Start with:

Overall 75
Offesne 75
Defense 75

I drop 2 backup WR's (-6 from offense AND overall)
I then pick up a WR and OT (- 4 from offense AND -4 from overall)

Thus we have:

Overall 65
Offense 65
Defense 75



Given this example of Chemistry working as intended, is my defense affected, on the field, by the overall drop? They should still be playing @ 75 since no change has affected them, no? If so, doesn't their existing strength weigh into the calculation of overall chemistry? If not, how does this make sense?
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=153234

I think only Bort/DigitalDaggers know the exact impact it has. Having chemistry will "boost" your players abilities on the field, while having low chemistry will "lessen" them.

As to how each effects you, I am not 100% sure. Obviously Defense and Offense affect those sides of the ball. However, the overall also affects all the players. Both are taken into account when considering how much of a "boost" they get during the game.

The trick is, chemistry on offense may and often does affect the chemistry on defense. Just look at some of the better defensive teams the last few years, and notice some of them had pretty bad offenses.

I am a Vikings fan, so I use them for an example. The last couple of years their offense has not clicked, but their defense has been quite good. However, this caused much controversy in the clubhouse, because the defense was unhappy with the way the offense performed. Thus, they were affected and felt that playing "top notch" defense was worthless because the offense would not back them up with points.

Hope that helps the logic to it a little. I only know how chemistry changes, and my opinion on why it does change like it does. I cannot give information on exactly "what" it does in the sim.


--You can look at the flip side as well. The offensive chemistry of the Patriots and Colts the last few years has certainly affected the way the defense plays. They know they have the big time offenses backing their moves up, so they feel they can't "let" the offense down either.
Last edited May 6, 2008 09:45:48
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=153234

I think only Bort/DigitalDaggers know the exact impact it has. Having chemistry will "boost" your players abilities on the field, while having low chemistry will "lessen" them.

As to how each effects you, I am not 100% sure. Obviously Defense and Offense affect those sides of the ball. However, the overall also affects all the players. Both are taken into account when considering how much of a "boost" they get during the game.

The trick is, chemistry on offense may and often does affect the chemistry on defense. Just look at some of the better defensive teams the last few years, and notice some of them had pretty bad offenses.

I am a Vikings fan, so I use them for an example. The last couple of years their offense has not clicked, but their defense has been quite good. However, this caused much controversy in the clubhouse, because the defense was unhappy with the way the offense performed. Thus, they were affected and felt that playing "top notch" defense was worthless because the offense would not back them up with points.

Hope that helps the logic to it a little. I only know how chemistry changes, and my opinion on why it does change like it does. I cannot give information on exactly "what" it does in the sim.


--You can look at the flip side as well. The offensive chemistry of the Patriots and Colts the last few years has certainly affected the way the defense plays. They know they have the big time offenses backing their moves up, so they feel they can't "let" the offense down either.



I'm not a Bears fan but there is another side to that arguement. The 2006 Bears Defense was amazing! I think the fact that the offense sucked (and let's face it, Turner, Smith, and Angelo could ruin the Colts or Pats) made the defense even stronger. They knew they'd have to pull off the win on defense to compensate for Rex and the O-Line (or lack there-of).

I honestly get what you're saying but I disagree. In this case, the defense (I assume) felt the need to play stronger. Why would they NOT want a championship? Why would any "pro" just roll over and give up because the other side of the line is having problems? Yeah, it's happened, but not at/to the level GLB calculates it. Especialy when we're talking about 5 or 6 trades all on one side of the ball.

 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
It also depends if you are losing or winning. If both morale and chemistry is low, then you do not have a team defense that pushes to win. Obviously being 13-3 is a lot different then being 6-10.

Basically, it is just another "factor" in everything. If a team has high energy, chemistry, and morale, they will do quite well. If they have low in one of the categories, but high in the rest, they will still do pretty good. The real problems arise when you have problems in 2 or 3, or all of the categories.


So basically, to look at the Bears example, one could say the defense had:

100% chemistry
100% morale
95% energy
60% overall chemistry

Obviously the top 3 being so high would override the "overall" and they would still play extremely well.


Where, in my Vikings example the team as a whole was not winning, regardless of what the defense did. Thus their morale dropped quite low as well, and now having two "lows" began to affect the team.
Last edited May 6, 2008 10:30:55
 
Varsity18
offline
Link
 
Last edited May 7, 2008 00:24:08
 
jetsfan0327
offline
Link
 
stay on topic this is a stickey.

Last edited May 7, 2008 00:24:28
 
nancywhiskey
offline
Link
 
The question is though, lets take this example the other way. You could after making a number of moves (I think 10 is minimum right?)see offense and defense at 40 and overall at 10. Then 60 days go by with you doing nothing. Now offense and defense are at 100%, but overall your team is a 70%?!? What?

Also, in the Vikings example I think you are talking more about morale. The defense is pi$$ed because the offense sucks. My understanding of chemistry is knowing what the other members of the team are going to do on a given play, almost trusting them. I don't see how the TE getting cut, would have an effect on the defense's ability to perform on the field. It seems to me Chemistry should just focus on the individual units, and morale should effect the whole team.

 
ppking
offline
Link
 
I think overall should go 2 per day since each offense and defence category takes away from overall
 
The Caveman
offline
Link
 
Traded two level 5 players along with a couple of level fours for cash. Did not recieve any players in return. Yesterday, one level 5 on defense and one on offense. My offensive chemisty dropped 8 points and my defensive chemistry dropped another 8 points. My overall team chemistry went from 76 to 59.
I thought players under level 5 did not affect your chemistry? How did I lose so much??

My chemistry should be:
Offense: 73
Defense:73
Overall:70

What is going on?
Last edited May 8, 2008 06:34:49
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ppking
I think overall should go 2 per day since each offense and defence category takes away from overall




Agreed, was just popping in to bring this up. We lose the total chemistry lost from overall chemistry:
(-3)Offense + (-2)Defense = (-5)Overall

BUT only gain back the average:

[(+1)Offense + (+1)Defense]/2 = (+1)Overall


Why do the calculations not work the same in both directions?
 
Badfish1060
offline
Link
 
I started out with 70 70 70, not 75 75 75
 
Spoken Jr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
It also depends if you are losing or winning. If both morale and chemistry is low, then you do not have a team defense that pushes to win. Obviously being 13-3 is a lot different then being 6-10.

Basically, it is just another "factor" in everything. If a team has high energy, chemistry, and morale, they will do quite well. If they have low in one of the categories, but high in the rest, they will still do pretty good. The real problems arise when you have problems in 2 or 3, or all of the categories.


So basically, to look at the Bears example, one could say the defense had:

100% chemistry
100% morale
95% energy
60% overall chemistry

Obviously the top 3 being so high would override the "overall" and they would still play extremely well.


Where, in my Vikings example the team as a whole was not winning, regardless of what the defense did. Thus their morale dropped quite low as well, and now having two "lows" began to affect the team.


I beleive the Oakland Raiders of the last 5 years is an excellent example of the point you are trying to make.
 
HOODjelly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Badfish1060
I started out with 70 70 70, not 75 75 75


We all did. Galk used the 75 as an example and I just followed suit. Sorry for the confusion

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.