User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > Possible flaw with the QB spike?
Page:
 
US American
offline
Link
 
If you set the input to a specific down, wouldn't he still spike it on that down ignoring the fact that the previous play may have been an incomplete?

The input gives you the ability to set the spike with time, timeouts, downs, ball spot, and score difference. But it doesn't say anything about the previous down whether it was a completion or an incompletion.

Example:

If I set my input for inside 1 minute spiking it on 2nd and 3rd downs when my team is losing with 0 timeouts, my QB will spike it on 2nd and 3rd downs....but what if my QB throws an incomplete on 1st down? Since my AI says to spike it on 2nd and 3rd down....wouldn't he still spike it even if the previous play was an incomplete time stoppage?

Does it automatically trigger when the time continues? Will it accicentally trigger when the time is stopped?

I'd love to hear Borts take on this.
 
Link
 
should only be used in case of emergency then to kick a FG with under 10 seconds left and no TO's. If it burns a play on 2nd or 3rd down, who cares? ..... you are kicking anyway.
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Interesting I don't have it set anymore anyway just to add on what if your WR steps out of bounds on like a 9 yard gain or so
 
Link
 
it is a positive addition to the game regardless of whether it is "perfect" or not
 
US American
offline
Link
 
Don't think you understood what I was talking about. The question I'm asking with the way the AI is set, is if the previous play was an incomplete will the QB still spike it based on way the AI is set up.



Originally posted by SteelersInsider
it is a positive addition to the game regardless of whether it is "perfect" or not


I know it's a positive step...after all, it was in my epic suggestion o_O
 
dead_marine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
should only be used in case of emergency then to kick a FG with under 10 seconds left and no TO's. If it burns a play on 2nd or 3rd down, who cares? ..... you are kicking anyway.


good point, but like manhood said, why bother if the previous play already stopped the clock? wouldn't that result in a waste of a play? and then, the play itself (spiking it) might take up like half a second. What if you don't have that time to waste??? what if ur down by 1, in range to score field goal, have .2 seconds left on clock by incomplete pass, then end up wasting the .2 seconds spiking it???


1 more thing, im 6th
Last edited Dec 28, 2008 00:06:14
 
US American
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dead_marine


good point, but like manhood said, why bother if the previous play already stopped the clock?


Exactly. We can even use a kicking scenario.

Lets say that you are out of your AI kicking range by...i dont know lets say 5 yards. 25 seconds left on the clock and you have no timeouts left. It's first down, you throw it and it's incomplete.

Now it's second down and based on the fact that you have the input to spike it on downs of 2nd and 3rd, instead of passing it, your QB spikes it when the clock was already stopped. Now it's 3rd down and based on your AI you spike it again. Now you went from spiking it on 2nd down and having a shot on 3rd down to accidentally spiking it twice in a row due to the AI leaving you with a 4th and long with probably 20 seconds left on the clock.

I'm sure we'll get our answer by the first preseason game, but I'd love to hear Borts take on this before an actual game.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Interesting question...
 
dead_marine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Manhoodg2199


I'm sure we'll get our answer by the first preseason game, but I'd love to hear Borts take on this before an actual game.


Last edited Dec 28, 2008 00:17:48
 
BWN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dead_marine
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

should only be used in case of emergency then to kick a FG with under 10 seconds left and no TO's. If it burns a play on 2nd or 3rd down, who cares? ..... you are kicking anyway.


good point, but like manhood said, why bother if the previous play already stopped the clock? wouldn't that result in a waste of a play? and then, the play itself (spiking it) might take up like half a second. What if you don't have that time to waste??? what if ur down by 1, in range to score field goal, have .2 seconds left on clock by incomplete pass, then end up wasting the .2 seconds spiking it???


1 more thing, im 6th


If you've managed to get into FG range with that amount of time left, then you should have your FG play ahead of your Spike play in the playbook.
 
Link
 
this sounds epic
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
doesnt make sense.
 
DAKING
offline
Link
 
I am sure on 1st down you will either lose or gain some yardage. If it does not stay the same put 2nd and and 3rd and Spkie Ball.
 
chargers85
offline
Link
 
Would like to know about this to.
 
Tigroklaws
offline
Link
 
i would hope there is a built in script to the sim that the spike AI setting would only take effect if the game clock is considered still running. much like a team calling a timeout. I dont believe i recall teams calling TO's when clock has already been stopped or that would have been a fix already in the works as well.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.