User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, so I set up this up based on a suggestion last season:

Instead of processing all promotions/relegations at the start of day 41 and moving all the teams then and there, process it and "flag" the teams who will be moving, and keep doing so each day as teams get sold throughout the offseason. Teams flagged to move up out of the capped leagues get to sign players at their new league's cap. Then at the end of offseason, you move all the teams. Sounds simple enough, right?

I started thinking about it, though, and there are two potential problems with it:

1) Let's say a team a team expires. We flag it, and flag all the teams below to move up. The team owner contacts support and says "Ooops! I forgot to renew my team!" or "I wanted to transfer to my GM" or whatever. Now there is one less team flagged to move down, so one of the "fringe" capped teams is now un-flagged. Problem is: they've been able to recruit above the cap, and now they're not moving. Hrm.

2) Let's say the next season starts on the day after day 45. A team gets sold on day 45. Now somebody gets flagged to move up and literally has less than a day to recruit and prepare for their new league. That doesn't sound fun.

The only thing I've been able to come up with is to do promotion/relegation on day 42, to allow for dealing with people selling teams late or failing team renewals. Then have a roster freeze on day 41 so nobody gets an "unfair advantage" towards recruiting. Sounds like a waste of a day though.

Ideas? Thoughts?
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 14:47:36
 
StinkCheese
offline
Link
 
hootie hoo bort
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.
 
DM
offline
Link
 
hi Bort
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.


this.
 
manning015
offline
Link
 
I think it would cause more problems that solve.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.


Erm, so the CPU's get moved to the first uncapped league? Doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of letting people start at the bottom? You gotta promote from the bottom up.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 14:52:16
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
it's definitely a tough problem...

in response to your #1 - i don't think you can come up with a plan specifically to protect those people who 'accidentally' forget to renew - they already get a warning and an alert right??

i think your idea #2 is better -

but - what happens to gutted teams that aren't sold? are they only going to get down the ladder with multiple seasons of losing (and sucking the fun out of their conference?)
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knick

Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.


Erm, so the CPU's get moved to the first uncapped league? Doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of letting people start at the bottom? You gotta promote from the bottom up.


leave them at higher leagues destroys all the fun. my Conference had 2 cpu teams and 2 slow build teams. 4 free wins. i dont know why they were in my league.
 
kb2120
offline
Link
 
You definitely don't want that team moving up at the last minute to have any lesser advantage since they are probably a team that doesn't have the players good enough to move up anyhow since they were the last to be chosen to move up.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knick

Why not just move the terrible team down to the lowest uncapped league.

I don't really enjoy seeing teams forced to disband because of promotion anyway.


Erm, so the CPU's get moved to the first uncapped league? Doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of letting people start at the bottom?


Sort of, but the way its currently set up, no matter how good you are in your capped league you're going to be destroyed when you get promoted. (My CB's team was conference runner-up in a capped league, and we got promoted last season. Brought in 8ish new high-lvl'ed guys and still only hit 9th place)

I like how you made the caps lift gradually, but for the first season I'd say NO promotion/regulation for capped leagues. However, I'm off topic.

Freezing rosters in offseason will just cause everyone to throw a fit. I say just do like you did last season.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
it's definitely a tough problem...

in response to your #1 - i don't think you can come up with a plan specifically to protect those people who 'accidentally' forget to renew - they already get a warning and an alert right??

i think your idea #2 is better -

but - what happens to gutted teams that aren't sold? are they only going to get down the ladder with multiple seasons of losing (and sucking the fun out of their conference?)


They aren't separate ideas.

They're both problems with the idea of processing at the end of the off-season. It just seems like the only "clean" way to do it is to do it once and once only, early enough in the offseason that it gives teams a chance to recruit.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
i think that:

1st - you need to announce which specific day sold teams will be relocated - and I personally think you should include in that all teams that are 90% + (or maybe 100%) cpu players.

2nd - those teams would be moved to the bottom of the ladder - AND have their cash/stadiums reset so that they don't have an obscene advantage in a capped league.

3rd - on day -1 - re-evaluate how many newly CPU teams you've got - if it is a manageable number - have another re-assignment just before the new season begins - I know it would be labor intensive - but perhaps you could have a way for teams to flag themselves as 'open to promotion'...in order to get one of those last minute promotions - you must have flagged your team.



this would allow team owners to keep their team and work their way down to a capped league by doing nothing but releasing everyone (or letting all contracts expire)
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 15:02:31
 
DM
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarlinsDynasty
hi Bort


 
haleykrl DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve

but - what happens to gutted teams that aren't sold? are they only going to get down the ladder with multiple seasons of losing (and sucking the fun out of their conference?)


This is my question, as my team has went the way of Slow Build, I did send a message to support, but have heard nothing back. I am only looking to go down to allow the other teams in my League that I respect the ability to play a competitive season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.