User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Fame suggestions for Bort
Page:
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
If this fame thing is to mean anything, 3 things need to be true.

1) Individual trophies should be worth more than team trophies. Nobody remembers the New York Giants' right guard just because they won the super bowl. People know Randy Moss because he broke the TD record.
2) 1st place trophies should be worth more than 2nd place trophies. Nobody remembers who finished behind Randy Moss in the TD chase. 2nd place is the first loser tbqh.
3) Pro trophies should be worth more than BBB trophies. Pro > AAA > AA > A > BBB. Otherwise the most famous players will be great players who go play in the BBB leagues. Fame is on the biggest stages.


 
bigwillray
offline
Link
 
I agree with this, individual is more remembered
 
itshim
offline
Link
 
agree
 
jackATTACK55
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itshim
agree


 
Link
 
Originally posted by itshim
agree


 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
It's going to be a nightmare if fame/vet skills are tied to trophies only.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
It's going to be a nightmare if fame/vet skills are tied to trophies only.


I don't know about a nightmare. I'd like it if it were tied to more stats than merely those that garnish a trophy, like the greasemonkey script that's floating around, but I'm not sure what they're thinking of.
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
I feel fame should not be added. There are already level 20's asking for 10k a day in the marketplace....... Srsly. fame will just fuck rebuilding teams in the ass
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

It's going to be a nightmare if fame/vet skills are tied to trophies only.


I don't know about a nightmare. I'd like it if it were tied to more stats than merely those that garnish a trophy, like the greasemonkey script that's floating around, but I'm not sure what they're thinking of.


Yea a real expansion of the awards/trophies would be a good start, but what worries me is how easy it would be to pad stats for a just a few players on the team. In most cases, with honorable teams this won't be a problem, but one of my players had to fight off a player who was being fed the ball and even though it didn't work for him, we know there are those that will take advantage of it big time if it means additional fame.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imnotthatstupid
I feel fame should not be added. There are already level 20's asking for 10k a day in the marketplace....... Srsly. fame will just fuck rebuilding teams in the ass


Not really. Most level 20s won't have alot of fame. And the ones that do would never sign with a new team - welcome to real life. How many 5* recruits does Cleveland State pull in every year?
 
Link
 
Yep, if your good you play for a good team.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82


1) Individual trophies should be worth more than team trophies. Nobody remembers the New York Giants' right guard just because they won the super bowl. People know Randy Moss because he broke the TD record.



hahaha.. not to be that guy.. but i know exactly who the RG for the giants is.. Chris Snee.. great guard.. big contract.. married to the coach's daughter haha

also.. to follow everything every young person is taught.. and they point out whenever there is a big mouth on a sports team.. the team is more important than the individual player..

i agree with your other points though. and if they were to use that first point.. it would have to be very slight difference for me to agree..
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigwillray
I agree with this, individual is more remembered


Really? I know which team won the Superbowl most years...but I couldn't tell you who the leading rusher, leading receiver or even sack leader was in most years (maybe a few)

You have this backwards...

Most people know the Giants won the Super Bowl last year...but how many know who led the league in tackles? Sacks? Return yardage? Interceptions? Shall I continue?

Heck that's last year...I can tell you for example that the Bears won the Superbowl in 85...the 49ers in 88 and 89, etc. I can list off players by position on those teams...but other than knowing who the top players were in that era, I'd be taking a wild guess as to who led the league in any particular stat.

Sure everyone knows Moss last year because he broke the all-time record...but who led the league in Receiving yards in 2005? Bet you'd have to look it up...
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 13:04:55
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rapidfirebanjo
hahaha.. not to be that guy.. but i know exactly who the RG for the giants is.. Chris Snee.. great guard.. big contract.. married to the coach's daughter haha

also.. to follow everything every young person is taught.. and they point out whenever there is a big mouth on a sports team.. the team is more important than the individual player..

i agree with your other points though. and if they were to use that first point.. it would have to be very slight difference for me to agree..


Originally posted by Yukon Don


Really? I know which team won the Superbowl most years...but I couldn't tell you who the leading rusher, leading receiver or even sack leader was in most years (maybe a few)

You have this backwards...

Most people know the Giants won the Super Bowl last year...but how many know who led the league in tackles? Sacks? Return yardage? Interceptions? Shall I continue?

Heck that's last year...I can tell you for example that the Bears won the Superbowl in 85...the 49ers in 88 and 89, etc. I can list off players by position on those teams...but other than knowing who the top players were in that era, I'd be taking a wild guess as to who led the league in any particular stat.


Sorry but this isn't accurate.

Rapidfire, just because the team is more important than the individual doesn't mean it makes you more famous. You could sit the bench on a championship team and rack up the trophies, but your fame should rightfully be about 0. We're not talking about justice here, we're talking about how fame really works. It's based on your abilities as an individual more than the team you're a part of.

Yukon, you're also missing the point. You can tell me which TEAM won the super bowl, but that's not the question. You can't tell me all the inconsequential players on the team that won the super bowl, and if you can, it's only because you're a trivia buff or a hardcore fan - namely the exception rather than the rule. That's the real question here: Whether a terrific player on a bad team should be more famous than a bad player on a terrific team. The answer is quite obviously yes.

Let me know when Snee gets a multimillion dollar endorsement deal guys.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 13:08:01
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
I actually think that team trophies are worth quite a bit.

Also, there might be a possibility for team awards based on team league stats in categories...best rushing defense, best passing defense, lowest points yielded, etc.

Speaking to the points made, many folks can name the members of the Pittsburgh "Steel Curtain" or the Cowboys "Doomsday Defense" or the Denver "Orange Crush," the Chicago Defensive line up from '85, the Ravens Superbowls defensive unit, the Chargers offense from the 80's...

Even if/though those players didn't have individual trophies, they were part of a unit that was indeed famous and they are remembered as such.


My point is to emphasize the players that are part of a successful unit over the players with stats that shine in large part due to the poor performance of the rest of their team. 120 tackles for a CB is not a good thing in most cases, and 150 tackles for a LB on a 0-16 team isn't very meaningful.

DEs or HBs (and a few others) can easily be superstars on a great team, but the rest of the defense (in particular) is unlikely to lead the league in anything...especially LBs.

This needs to be addressed in some fashion, imo.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 13:23:05
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.