User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Dealing with non responders...
Page:
 
JJsBlitz
offline
Link
 
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.

(edited by Bort with "real" suggestion)
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 15:24:04
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JJsBlitz
Once again, we have reached that lovely time of the year (no, I don't mean"_insert religous holidy of choice_"). I'm so don'e with goobers posting ads about thier players, than simply not responding to them. If you are in the market and post an ad, you should respond, even in the negative, to people who answer your ad. I propose anyone who doesn't reply to inquiries based on their own ad be docked 14 billion FPs, and busted back to level 1.


As annoying as it is that they don't respond, what if those players received 50 pm's??? would you respond to all of them??

Maybe there should be a button in between Accept offer and Reject offer that reads, offer not good enough, or change offer to let you know, you need to come with more money....
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


OK, much better than my idea....
 
Sarcoth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


I like that.
 
ShamsTron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


I would love this. When my FS was on the market I got a crapload of offers. I wanted to reply to each one but you can only do that for so many.
 
hb741
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


I don't know about penalties, but I *love* the status and feedback stuff -- recruiting season always gets me questioning why I do this to myself
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


EPIC
 
jpdeuce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


+1
 
Caiderman98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jpdeuce
Originally posted by kristof65

I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


+1


 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?
-you want my player for minimum salary and you want me to adhere to your strict build guidelines? cheap build nazi
etc...


 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hogfan
Originally posted by kristof65

I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?
-you want my player for minimum salary and you want me to adhere to your strict build guidelines? cheap build nazi
etc...




Good addition Hog, I knew we forgot something.. O_o
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


I proposed this EXACT idea two seasons ago, and it was as well responded. But not implemented. Can you believe that folks? Good ideas not getting implemented, while bad ones do routinely.
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
It's been proposed a couple of times, by different people, and well received every time. I will not claim ownership of the idea.

I think the problem is that it hasn't been noticed or hasn't been determined important enough to implement. My guess is that because it's a good idea, it's not generating enough controversy to keep it near the top of the suggestions thread and get it noticed.
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kristof65
It's been proposed a couple of times, by different people, and well received every time. I will not claim ownership of the idea.

I think the problem is that it hasn't been noticed or hasn't been determined important enough to implement. My guess is that because it's a good idea, it's not generating enough controversy to keep it near the top of the suggestions thread and get it noticed.


Well then were just going to have to keep talking about it..

Originally posted by kristof65
I do beleive that the Reject Offer needs to have a drop down box with several stock reasons that you can use to tell the other guy why're you're rejecting without resorting to having to write individual PMs. Stock answers could be:

- Thanks, but no thanks
- Offer pending with another team
- PM me, let's talk
- Too long
- not enough money
- didn't I make it clear I'd never play for you again?

etc...

There should also be an "Under Consideration" button that you could use to notify the team owner that his offer is being considered.

Once that's implemented, I think it would then be reasonable to 'penalize' FA players who fail to respond by yanking their ad off the marketplace.


I really do think the reply function would help with the overall negotiations, speed up trying to find a team, and give owners the info they need to either continue to go after a player, or move on to find someone else...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.