User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia A Leagues > Southeast Asia A #1 > SE Asia Power Rankings Combined
swinter95
offline
Link
 
Well I've finished the combined power rankings, and overall stats & strength of schedule all play a part in this. Only posting the Top 16. Softness in schedule really helps and also hurts some of these teams rankings right now, because everyone hasn't played everyone. Plus some of the rankings just don't make sense.

Hakone is the best team in Naga, but yet they're ranked lower than some in their own conference.

Well at any rate its back to the drawing board and at least it gives us something to debate.

1. Lea Lea Furniture (G)
2. Taipei Yonghe soybean milk (G)
3. Georgetown United (G)
4. Surabaya Poison Dart Frogs (N)
5. Jakarta Wolves (G)
6. Manila Gorillas (G)
7. Phenom Pehn Samurai (N)
8. Hakone Heroes (N)
9. Christmas Island (N)
10. Beijing Drifters (G)
11. Maldives Moles (G)
12. Burma Black Dragons (N)
13. Panay Phoenix (N)
14. Bangar PEACEING PUNISHINGMENTS (N)
15. Laos Chaos (G)
16. Singapore Stallions (N)
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
Wow no Snatchers.
 
Link
 
moles 11 even though we beat wolves and gorrilas, but hey thanks for taking the time and effort
 
marshks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by viperz2k5
Wow no Snatchers.


No way Singapore and Laos Chaos are better than the Snatchers It looks to me like there is too much love to Garuda here and I don't like it

Seriously, though, I wonder if the fact that Garuda has more gutted teams skewed the numbers.

Maybe the rankings could consider the overall team rating for judging the quality of a win.

In Garuda, Lea Lea is a 51, there are 6 teams at 48 (Taipei, Laos, Beijing, Maldives, Jakarta, and Georgetown), 1 at 45 (Gorillas), 1 at 42 (Chiang Mai) 1 at 39 (Zoolander), 1 at 33 (Envelopes), 3 at 30 (Borneo, Povida, and LA), 1 at 27 (Vietnam), and 1 at 24 (Seoul Patrol).

In Naga, Christmas Island and Seoul are a 51, there are 7 teams at 48 (Hakone, Bangar, Burma, Panay, Surabaya, Singapore, and Phnom Penh), 2 teams at 45 (Manheim & Triads), 1 team at 42 (Hogn Kong Patriots), 1 at 39 (Mekong), 1 at 36 (Sioux City), 1 at 33 (Rancho), and 1 at 27 (Asbury Park).

This would not be perfect, either, but it does seem the weakness at the bottom half of Garuda is somehow propping up those teams. As you said, Hakone is too low.

Another example: Bangar beat the Manila Gorillas 72-7 in game 1.

Like you said, though, I'd rather have something to discuss. Maybe you could weight your conference rankings with overall conference or schedule strength and see how the numbers come out? I thought the conference rankings were looking pretty close.
Last edited Dec 6, 2008 02:54:35
 
swinter95
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marshks
Originally posted by viperz2k5

Wow no Snatchers.


No way Singapore and Laos Chaos are better than the Snatchers It looks to me like there is too much love to Garuda here and I don't like it

Seriously, though, I wonder if the fact that Garuda has more gutted teams skewed the numbers.

Maybe the rankings could consider the overall team rating for judging the quality of a win.

In Garuda, Lea Lea is a 51, there are 6 teams at 48 (Taipei, Laos, Beijing, Maldives, Jakarta, and Georgetown), 1 at 45 (Gorillas), 1 at 42 (Chiang Mai) 1 at 39 (Zoolander), 1 at 33 (Envelopes), 3 at 30 (Borneo, Povida, and LA), 1 at 27 (Vietnam), and 1 at 24 (Seoul Patrol).

In Naga, Christmas Island and Seoul are a 51, there are 7 teams at 48 (Hakone, Bangar, Burma, Panay, Surabaya, Singapore, and Phnom Penh), 2 teams at 45 (Manheim & Triads), 1 team at 42 (Hogn Kong Patriots), 1 at 39 (Mekong), 1 at 36 (Sioux City), 1 at 33 (Rancho), and 1 at 27 (Asbury Park).

This would not be perfect, either, but it does seem the weakness at the bottom half of Garuda is somehow propping up those teams. As you said, Hakone is too low.

Another example: Bangar beat the Manila Gorillas 72-7 in game 1.

Like you said, though, I'd rather have something to discuss. Maybe you could weight your conference rankings with overall conference or schedule strength and see how the numbers come out? I thought the conference rankings were looking pretty close.


marshks, now you know better. I could have done the 900 page template in the forums, but once again that takes time I already don't have. Softness in some of the Garuda Teams helps them statistically. This doesn't take into account the owners and gm gameplanning, chemistry or overall ratings. There's no way to account for all that. I guess if I was a full time GLB'er, maybe Bort could pay me a salary and I could spend my days figuring it out.
 
marshks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by swinter95


marshks, now you know better. I could have done the 900 page template in the forums, but once again that takes time I already don't have. Softness in some of the Garuda Teams helps them statistically. This doesn't take into account the owners and gm gameplanning, chemistry or overall ratings. There's no way to account for all that. I guess if I was a full time GLB'er, maybe Bort could pay me a salary and I could spend my days figuring it out.


I'd take 1/3 of Bort's salary without even knowing what it is.

Nice job on the rankings. It is great to have you doing these.

I was just trying to suggest giving Naga teams a 10% conference strength boost to their overall scores (due to more highly rated teams).

Regardless, today's games should shake things up a lot! Tons of great games out there!
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Naga rankings don't even matter, TBH.

Who cares about a 2nd place trophy? Really, come on.
 
marshks
offline
Link
 
You really think Lea Lea is that much of a lock to win, eh?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Week 16 Lea Lea vs. Georgetown will give us the league champion preview.
 
brentlewis
offline
Link
 
Looks good, except I would replace Bangar with the Snatchers.
 
marshks
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Week 16 Lea Lea vs. Georgetown will give us the league champion preview.


All that game will give us is the only compelling contest in Garuda all season long, oh, and the 'B' division champ.
 
swinter95
offline
Link
 
Snatchers are hurt by int's, awful in the fumbles lost, officially on the sheet your ranked just outside the top 16 at #18
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Phnom should rise come the next power ranking list
 
viperz2k5
offline
Link
 
Snatchers may actually exist in the next ranking
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.