User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > BIG Bug in Def AI vs. Shotgun 5 WR set
Page:
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Before anyone starts with it's user error in AI. It's not.

I have inputs for Shotgun 3WR by down and yardage. I even have the WR settings in the input set to 0-4 just for the heck of it even though there are no 4 WR sets.

I have a whole separate input for Shotgun 5WR sets. It has settings for 5-5 WR (yes I can likely fix it by going 4-5 or maybe 0-5 in that setting). Whenever there is a shotgun 5 WR set I have a 3-1-7 D formation set up on the inputs. That's the only formation set to be used vs. shotgun 5 WR.

For first time, in today's game I noticed that in 5WR sets it was throwing out a 4-1-6 (which is what I have set to sometimes use when facing the shotgun 3 WR offensive formations instead) of using the D AI specified setting of 3-1-7.

This manned the MLB against the #5 WR instead of my 5th CB as desired and specifically set-up in the AI.

An example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=243592&pbp_id=8539025

Looking at the offense, their 5th WR is actually a TE. Apparently, the sim is counting the actual WRs playing on the field in the formation instead of the offense's actually selected shotgun 5WR formation to arrive at the D AI input choice. So, the sim sees 4WR/1TE and runs the input for shotgun 3 WR (because I do have it set to 0-4 WR, btw. I can fix that to 0-3, but that's not really the point here at all.)

That begs the question of why the D AI settings are keying off the players on the field (4WR/1TE) instead of keying off the actual offensive formation set selected. If an offense goes with shotgun 5 WR formation, the D AI input for shotgun 5 WR should be utilized...always.

I can see plenty of exploits here if someone were to use, say 2 WR/3TE in that formation, then the D AI would key on what? Use a 2 WR D AI set-up like a 4-3/4-2-5 since there are only 2 actual WRs on the field??? What if the offense throws in CBs to play a few WR slots? 1 WR/1TE/3CBs? How badly would that throw off the D AI if it is keying off of players positions in position slots instead of actual formations used?

This is a HUGE D AI bug and needs to be corrected ASAP. No way should the thing be keying off the player positions instead of the actual formation being called when the D AI inputs are set correctly.

I know others have encountered the same thing. The question is why the heck is it coded like this?
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 20:05:09
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
More...

I can sort of see what the code is doing...

I have a Shotgun 3 WR input that has the following:

Ballspot: Opp G - My 10.
Down: 1 to 3
Yds to first: depends as I have different inputs for different yardage situations
Opp. Formation: Shotgun
# of WRs: 0 to 4

For the Shotgun 5 WR input it is:

Ballspot: Opp G - My 10.
Down: 1 to 3
Yds to first: 0-30
Opp. Formation: Shotgun
# of WRs: 5 to 5

As far as I can tell, the code is reading the input selections in a progression from 1st to last. It hits the formation: Shotgun sees only 4 WRs in a Shotgun 5 WR set-up and then defaults to the input for shotgun 3 WR because there are actually 4 WR/1 TE on field. I can fix my settings for that. But, you can't select between shotgun 3 WR/Shotgun 5 WR in the dropdown. So have to finagle it in the inputs. IMO, the sim should be keying off the offensive formation. If an offense goes shotgun 5 WR then the D AI input settings for shotgun 5 WR should be used regardless of who is actually playing in the WR slot be it a TE or a CB or a FB or whatever.

I figured the D AI would key on the offensive formation setting and not the players physically playing in the formation slots. As I said, I can fix it in the D AI, but it shouldn't be doing that, IMO.
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 20:15:10
 
Link
 
I've noticed the same thing with my AI. I've got it set to 3-1-7 defense whenever the other team has 5 WRs, but it uses the settings I've got for 4 WR sets, which just like in your case, means I have a MLB lined up against a WR. Even worse, a lot of times, its the backup MLB, who's a slower run stopping MLB rather than the starting MLB who's got much more speed.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Any blitzing on the intended defensive play? If so, did you put in zero for the guys you don't want to blitz (leaving fields blank will result in randomly choosen blitzers, this resulting in invalid defensive plays and the AI will call a general play instead of the intended play)?
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
No blitzing and I always have all blitz fields set with a 0 for non-blitzers or a percentage with blitzing positions. But, not on those.

The short version of all the above is:

The GLB code appears to be defining the D AI input setting for "# of WRs" from the actual number of player WRs on the field and not from the number of WR positions in a selected formation.

This would allow an offense to do weird things to the D AI settings. Like in an I form, using a WR in the TE slot makes it look like 3 WR set instead of 2. So if a D AI input was set for "Any I" and also "0 to 2" WRs it wouldn't get triggered because there are 3 WRs on the field even though the I-form only has 2 WR slots in it. Things like that. That is what appears to be occurring with the shotgun sets.

# of WR should be derived from the formation number and not player positions in those slots, IMO.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Just set it to "any formation" and 5 to 5 WR's

It will call it up everytime
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
Just set it to "any formation" and 5 to 5 WR's

It will call it up everytime


No it won't which is exactly the problem. I had it set to shotgun and 5 to 5 WRs. That should be as good as any formation since it is the only formation with 5 WRs in it. The offense comes out in shotgun 5 WR set but uses 4 WRs and 1 TE in the 5 WR slots. The AI interpreted that as 4 WR (because there were only 4 WR in the 5 WR slots) and used a D AI input for shotgun 3 WR sets (on which I have it set from 0 to 4 WRs.)

Understand?
 
Genie1
offline
Link
 
I have had no problems with this. It is likely an error somewhere, whether you think so or not. Probably a play that has the wrong formation selected. Also make sure no preset play is selected.
Check every defensive play BEFORE the 5WR sets, and make sure that none are on shotgun, or random.

*note*
I played a team not too long ago that only used shotgun and shotgun 5wr forms every down. I had different defenses set for each, and they worked the way they should have. I can't see a game reason why it would change for you. From every game i've seen, it correctly identifies the # of receivers on the field, by the play itself, not the amount of wr players.

(if u can get me access, would be willing to look)
 
Genie1
offline
Link
 
Also, since you do it by yardage, make sure you dont have any conflicting yardage.
EG: 1 play set for 0-4 yards, and another play set 4-8 yards. If happens to be 4 yards to go, the game will choose whichever of the 2 is first.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Thanks, but not an AI error. It kicks of fine when a team in 5WR shotgun uses 5 actual WRs in the play. Doesn't when it's 4 WR/1 TE. I know my D settings and they are not wrong. I even listed them above.

This can be tested easily enough by 2 people in a scrimmage if they are willing.

Offense sets their plays and subs TE for WRs.

Defense inputs only key on # of WRs without anything else selected.

When offense comes out in shotgun 5 WR with 4 WR/1 TE, watch that if the 5 to 5 WR setting in D AI is selected. Or the 4 to 4 (yes there are no 4 I know). Then have offense run shotgun 5 WR with 3 WR/2 TE in WR slots. And see if the D AI selects the 3 to 3 WR input.

I'm willing to bet it would. I know I can fix it in the AI now that I know what is happening. That's not really the issue. The issue is the code appears to be keying of the WRs playing in slots instead of keying off the actual formation set slots for WRs.
 
Genie1
offline
Link
 
Oh, and put the exact settings for that play into the test defensive ai function, and see what comes up. (why ppl dont use this still, i dont know)
And dont be afraid to mention if you were wrong!
Hate when ppl are too ego to admit an error, and let ppl keep thinking about a possible bug!
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
The D AI tester comes out corret with a 3-1-7. You can't really test this since the tester doesn't allow to to choose Shotgun 5 WR but modified to 3/4 WRs and 1/2 TEs in the WR slots for that formation.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 06:33:46
 
Genie1
offline
Link
 
Again, i have to say. Don't give up on the chance of it being error.
This would be a huge bug, that would just now be being found. This seems VERY unlikely, as it probably would have been around for a long time.
Way too many people in the game/deep into the ai, to not have found this and said something.

 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Could be. Anyway,as I mentioned easy to test. I don't have a team though. Hope I AM wrong actually. But, regardless, I've adjusted the inputs to account for it so won't happen anymore. Thanks for the comments.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
Could be. Anyway,as I mentioned easy to test. I don't have a team though. Hope I AM wrong actually. But, regardless, I've adjusted the inputs to account for it so won't happen anymore. Thanks for the comments.


Your not, the only way to prevent it is to put in the WRs at 4-5. It's rare that a team will play two TEs in that spot and since there are no 4 WR sets in the game it is a safe play right now.

Happened to me 2 games in a row, changed the AI to be 4-5 WRs out of shotgun and problem was resolved.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.