User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Same play decay
Page:
 
manx
offline
Link
 
I am pretty sure this has been suggested, but I could not find a thread about it to bump.

Rather then nerfing the over-used plays out there, just incorporate some sort of handicap against a team that runs them over and over again. Either raise the attributes of the defense by a % each time the play is run past a certain threshold, or decrease the offense attributes by a similar percentage. I personally have not been on the receiving end of one of these games, but have read enough posts to agree that it is pretty stupid and VERY unrealistic.

I just feel like it could be a pretty realistic and widely appreciated fix.
 
manx
offline
Link
 
just bumping this because it seems like I was foretelling my own future. Game after I posted this we got offtackle rushed into the ground despite like a 90% blitz on D
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.
 
Link
 
+1
 
Link
 
+1
 
bdnannac
offline
Link
 
Signed.
 
Link
 
I agree with your views and would like to subscribe to your newsletter.
 
basshound3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it
 
Link
 
formation != play
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by basshound3
Originally posted by OttawaShane

agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it


how is that wildcat formation now? it has been shutdown. 29 or so yards in 3 games or something like that!

the thins is the defense is not even jumping it. not once!

+1 on this. and please check out my suggestion about this. check the game.
 
SoCalWhoDat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by basshound3
Originally posted by OttawaShane

agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it


Wildcat formations generally use misdirection and play-action of some sort to confound the defense even further. That doesn't exist in GLB. Eventually, the defense would and should see these exact same blocking assignments over and over and be able to react to where the holes are opening up (assuming the teams are relatively equal).

+1 to OP
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
+1
 
basshound3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by basshound3

Originally posted by OttawaShane


agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it


how is that wildcat formation now? it has been shutdown. 29 or so yards in 3 games or something like that!

the thins is the defense is not even jumping it. not once!

+1 on this. and please check out my suggestion about this. check the game.


well it's a formation (the specific play was Ronnie Brown taking the direct snap and running it up the middle) that should only work in pop warner and was the most obvious i could think of for an example. Coordinators have been able to study dissect and game plan for the formation now. But it's not that unusual to mix up a playbook and throw something at a defense that they're not expecting. The idea is good but there should be a on a percentage for chance of decay. As there are some plays that just knock a defense on its ass
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by basshound3
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by basshound3


Originally posted by OttawaShane



agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it


how is that wildcat formation now? it has been shutdown. 29 or so yards in 3 games or something like that!

the thins is the defense is not even jumping it. not once!

+1 on this. and please check out my suggestion about this. check the game.


well it's a formation (the specific play was Ronnie Brown taking the direct snap and running it up the middle) that should only work in pop warner and was the most obvious i could think of for an example. Coordinators have been able to study dissect and game plan for the formation now. But it's not that unusual to mix up a playbook and throw something at a defense that they're not expecting. The idea is good but there should be a on a percentage for chance of decay. As there are some plays that just knock a defense on its ass


the thing is when we say decay, it is some form of nerfing. what my suggestion is (in another thread below this) for the defense to "wisen up". probably attempt to jump it.

my suggestion is to have "intelligence" for the defense as a whole or individual players. this way nothing is nerfed. players or teams just get a boost.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by basshound3

Originally posted by PaqMarq11


Originally posted by basshound3



Originally posted by OttawaShane




agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.

Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.


i would have to disagree... How many times did the Dolphins bust out the Wildcat formation successfully on the Patriots earlier in the NFL season. Some plays just confuse the hell out of a defense or a defense is simply unable to stop it


how is that wildcat formation now? it has been shutdown. 29 or so yards in 3 games or something like that!

the thins is the defense is not even jumping it. not once!

+1 on this. and please check out my suggestion about this. check the game.


well it's a formation (the specific play was Ronnie Brown taking the direct snap and running it up the middle) that should only work in pop warner and was the most obvious i could think of for an example. Coordinators have been able to study dissect and game plan for the formation now. But it's not that unusual to mix up a playbook and throw something at a defense that they're not expecting. The idea is good but there should be a on a percentage for chance of decay. As there are some plays that just knock a defense on its ass


the thing is when we say decay, it is some form of nerfing. what my suggestion is (in another thread below this) for the defense to "wisen up". probably attempt to jump it.

my suggestion is to have "intelligence" for the defense as a whole or individual players. this way nothing is nerfed. players or teams just get a boost.


Per my suggestion that everyone on defence gets a bit more vision everytime the play is run after x times.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.