User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A real fix to speed
Page:
 
czman
offline
Link
 
The problem with Bort’s idea and a lot of the speed ideas are they do not address why people build all speed.

I think people build speed agility at a majority of positions is twofold.

Strength is an under powered attribute, no pun intended. There is no bump and run coverage so CBs and WRs do not need much of it. DE can outrun OTs therefore they do not get touched to they do not need. LBs do not need much of it to be good tacklers. It does not seem to add much to breaking tackles. Strengths overall importance is so small in the game that we have successful Des with 4x more speed than strength. That is ridiculous.
2) Zone coverage does not work. Therefore, people have to play man to man to be successful. IF you are forced to lock up in man to man then you have to get to the QB quickly. This leads to blitzing with fast LBs and teams wanting Des that are very speed oriented.
All of the speed on defense has forced offenses to get faster. Moreover, strength does not seem to help breaking tackles much, as stated above.
Furthermore, because zone is so ineffective Bort has had to make man-to-man coverage way more effective than it should be. In reality WRs have the advantage over CBs. If a WR is equal to a CB in speed and agility he will beat the CB most plays in 1 on 1 coverage. That is not the case in GLB.
Because the game is so speed and agility based lower level teams have no way of keeping the games close. You can either run with someone or you cannot. Slower teams cannot play zone and cover people. Safeties in this game play terrible over the top defense.

Conclusion:
Until strength has a greater impact on the game people are going to build all speed agility.
Zone needs to be fixed. If zone is fixed it will help keep scores closer because lower level teams will be able to play a bend but do not break defense. Additionally, if zone Is fixed man-to-man can be brought back to where it should be. This way teams cannot blitz ever down and just overwhelm lower level teams.
Fixing the importance of strength across the board, zone defense, and man-to-man defense will allow people to still build fast players but a cost. Lastly, it will bring the game to aplace where overwhelming teams with pure speed is not an option.
Example:
If you could quantify a speed rushers ability at the NFL level I doubt you would find that their speed was even twice their strength let alone 3x to 4x.

I might add more later. I cranked this out fast because Bort is online.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to GLB.

Maybe I just need to let those go, but I also don't want to see power backs get 50 ypc all the time.

I'd like to add bump coverage for sure at some point, which would require strength for sure.
 
Link
 
Solid for cranking it out quicker than you wanted too.


See your doing good in the Pros as well. I've been keeping track. That gives me hope if we make it up this season.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Maybe I just need to let those go, but I also don't want to see power backs get 50 ypc all the time.

I'd like to add bump coverage for sure at some point, which would require strength for sure.


1: I love my CB's, I have a couple now. But I agree that is something that just needs to be let go. If they don't want missed tackles then it would be wise to invest in Str and not bitch about it.

2: As a CB owner........I wanted this when I started..Bump and run/Jammin at the line.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe I just need to let those go


Pretty much all the complaining threads should be ignored imo.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
It is not just breaking tackles it is everything. Coverage, coming off blocks, catching the ball in traffic, holding your position on both sides of the LOS. Everything in football takes strength. It is a collision/contact sport.

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by suntansuperman
Originally posted by Bort

Maybe I just need to let those go


Pretty much all the complaining threads should be ignored imo.


Exactly. The other day someone was suggesting ST was too energy draining, then when I said he should raise his stamina the response was "BUT STAMINA IS WORTHLESS"
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Like I typed though I really think speed as become so important because zone is so ineffective. If zone is fixed it would completely change the way defense can be played. That can lead to other changes like increasing strength. Increasing the value of strength without fixing zone gives to much of a bonus to the offense.

It is much harder to run against a zone coverage in football than a man-to-man. In man-to-man people are lined up over the person that is going to block them many times and they are focused more on the player in front of them. Zone should allow LBs to flow to the ball easier.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Gang tackling is the best way to prevent Power Backs from running wild but I'm not sure if it works in the GLB world. Its how people deal with Brandon Jacobs though. One on one.. well LaRon Landry found out just how much that sucks once.

Ofcourse you have to remember Jacobs needs a head of steam to run someone over, GLB backs should need the same, can't have a guy jogging while guys bounce off of him. Its a big system thing and since I don't know how the system works on these matters all I can do is throw things up and hope Bort finds something that can stick.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by suntansuperman

Originally posted by Bort


Maybe I just need to let those go


Pretty much all the complaining threads should be ignored imo.


Exactly. The other day someone was suggesting ST was too energy draining, then when I said he should raise his stamina the response was "BUT STAMINA IS WORTHLESS"


Pretty much. I never had a problem with my OT getting beat, I mean, he is in the internet world only "human" I don't expect my players to be perfect, or even near it really, I think a lot of people are expecting way to much out of lvl 35-45 guys. Pretty sure even the best in the NFL make mistakes, and a bunch of them.

Now understandably, there are some things that needed to be fixed. (such as OL/DL interaction) but as far as all these people complaining, it's just getting tiresome.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
So the real suggestion here breaks down to:

Stop listening to the squeaky wheels, and just do what you originally intended to do?


LOL, I'm going to try and figure out some of what squeaky wheels got since season 1's version:

1) It was harder to make tackles on high strength backs without high tackling skill. People complained there were too many broken tackles. Tackling became easier.

2) Leagues had a much larger disparity in ticket prices (bottom league was less than half of Pro) because we wanted to separate talent for later levels. People complained they were not all getting the same product when they bought a team. Ticket prices in low leagues got raised.

3) Catching was harder without high catching skill, even when wide open. People complained about too many drops. "Wide Open" got a larger bonus.

4) Weak OL got trucked by high strength DT and DE's. People complained that D Line was too good. Run blocking got a boost.

I'm sure there's more.

I'm seeing a trend: "Don't nerf my build! Nerf the other guy's build!"
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 21:07:04
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So the real suggestion here breaks down to:

Stop listening to the squeaky wheels, and just do what you originally intended to do?


LOL, I'm going to try and figure out some of what squeaky wheels got since season 1's version:

1) It was harder to make tackles on high strength backs without high tackling skill. People complained there were too many broken tackles. Tackling became easier.

2) Leagues had a much larger disparity in ticket prices (bottom league was less than half of Pro) because we wanted to separate talent for later levels. People complained they were not all getting the same product when they bought a team. Ticket prices in low leagues got raised.

3) Catching was harder without high catching skill, even when wide open. People complained about too many drops. "Wide Open" got a larger bonus.

4) Weak OL got trucked by high strength DT and DE's. People complained that D Line was too good. Run blocking got a boost.

I'm sure there's more.

I'm seeing a trend...


Me too. I bolded something that might fix it.
 
HighRoller74
offline
Link
 
5) Slow OT's got raped by Fast DE's. People complained, OT's got a boost, people still complained
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 21:08:49
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm seeing a trend: "Don't nerf my build! Nerf the other guy's build!"


Exactly, I think most of peoples complaints equate to the fact that they think their player is perfect, when in reality, it's nowhere near. Now we're getting complaints the other way around, especially on #4. Most likely because people were used to the old way, and now that they're player is just a little less effective, they're pissed.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
I do not know about all of that Bort.

I just think that Zone coverage needs a boost, and I am sure that is very hard to code.

Man-to-man needs to be decreased so people can not blitz and overwhelm teams with speed.

Strength should effect every calculation in the game when players interact with each other. If it already does it should effect it to a greater level.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.