User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > AI Offensive and Defense are not working
TCR
offline
Link
 
For the past few games I have seen some quirks in all of the teams I am involved with.So yesterday just to see if it was my imagination or not I went and stripped one of our teams AI's on both sides of the ball.Then I reinstalled a very basic logic for each side of the ball offense and defense.

For offense I chose 5 basic plays for each down and set the distance for 0-30 yards for a first.I also made the plays simple and covered each set of downs, you cannot get any simpler than that to run a test.I then ran every test on the tester that you could think of to make sure I had matches.Needless to say I did the same for the defense by matching every offensive formation with 2 basic defensive plays.

Well guess what maybe 20% of the time we ran what I called.I just finished running every play in the game through my AI tester and got the matches I place in the AI but the freakin game did not call them.Instead it decided to do it's own thing and before you ask yes I enabled both AI's and even set my basics to pretty much match my AI's since I was worried about them over riding my inputs.

For those of you who say you are having no problems with your AI I strongly suggest you run every play in a game through your AI as you are watching the game and then tell me your results.
Last edited Nov 22, 2008 16:56:22
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Maybe you called a output (not input!) that doesn't exist. Some defensive plays are not coded yet; if you enter them into your AI - it will play a basic AI play.

Check if you called something unusual for about 20% of the time.
 
Link
 
List your play settings - what were the 5 you entered? Link to the game they were supposed to me in. We'll help you find where you made your mistake.

Copy paste you Tester settings also.

Bort would need all that info to check it anyway.

CPU assist on?

Last edited Nov 22, 2008 20:17:41
 
Link
 
I have no probs at all with my AI. Sorry guy.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Here is the game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=256488

Offensive play
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=256488&pbp_id=4872292
here is a play and below is the tester results.

Matching Input
Input Named: 1st Down 1-30

Possible Outputs
20% I Outside (outside_run_off_tackle)
20% I Inside (inside_run)
20% SI Outside (outside_run_off_tackle)
20% TE Pass (pass)
20% SI Inside (inside_run)

The TE pass is out of the weak I.

Defensive Play
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=256488&pbp_id=4872625

Matching Input
Input Named: SG 3WR

Possible Outputs
100% 4-2-5 Cover 1 Blitz (nickel Cover 1 man)
Weak side shift 3 blitzers(both LB's and the SS)

None of the actual plays matched up with the plays called in the AI.I went back and retested and the results were worse than I thought.For several defensive formations I had only one input and it still could not get it right.There is no reason for either of these plays I have shown not to be run properly.I have not created plays out of the blue, I made it a point to keep them simple to see if the AI was calling the correct play.At times it would get close but never fully trigger the play.I also specifically called for SS blitzs on the majority of the defensive plays as an easy check while watching the replay.So if you look at the game count how many SS blitzs you find.

I would like for someone else to really test sample their game play by play and post their results for both offense and defense.
Last edited Nov 22, 2008 21:18:32
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
bump
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
For the offensive plays, please list ALL settings - even the ones not really set. Imagine the AI substituting a (not set) rushing direction with "left" for a play where you only got runs to the right in your playbook - check if for any possible setting there's a play in your playbook.

For the defensive play: did you put in 0 (zero) for the guys you don't want to blitz?

(if not, it will refer to basic AI - this maybe resulting in all 3 CBs beeing choosen to blitz - and that might not be coded)

Oh... and make sure to both save as preset and hit "update" after any changes.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
I have done everything as you suggested.The offensive play being substituted has no reason to be called since it did not replace a run play but instead a passplay..I have runs left and right in the playbook, those are the only plays listed in the AI for a first down and there was no reason not to hit on one of those.I did not put in multiple outlets for down and distance for each scenario, as I stated in my original post I keep it very simple because of this problem.If it wanted to call a pass play I made sure it had an option.I do not have a SG play till 2nd and 3rd.I have checked and double checked everything before coming here and posting.

Might I ask if you have teseted your AI play by play to see if there are any quirks.I appreciate the help and that is why I came here to post this.So please any info
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 07:49:43
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.