Discussion on:
Kiloph is better because he has more PDs and less tackles than Shadow. Most of the CBs tackles come from when the WR they are covering makes the reception and then gets hit by the CB. Kiloph has defended more passes than Shadow, thus preventing more receptions, evidenced by his lower tackle count.
Also, Kiloph has racked up more PDs in less plays, as he plays out of the Nickel spot, while Shadow is the #1 CB on his team. Kiloph is averaging 54 plays a game, Shadow 58. This means Kiloph deflects a pass every 13.5 plays, while Shadow deflects one every 17.8.
EDIT: Kiloph also has a sack. This makes him bad-ass.
Also, you could make a very valid arguement for Shadow, based on the fact that he has more INTs/TDs, is a lower level, plays against the #1 WR on opposing teams, etc.
But since I'm biased, Kiloph is better
