User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Reply to a different suggestion thread: Offenses do need some level of taming, it seems (w/suggestions).
Ken1
offline
Link
 
http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?season=2008&seasonType=REG&d-447263-o=2&conference=ALL&tabSeq=2&role=TM&statisticCategory=TEAM_PASSING&d-447263-p=1&d-447263-s=PASSING_AVERAGE_YARDS&d-447263-n=1

Median NFL team yards per pass attempt: 6.9.
Median NFL team Completion%: 61.6%
Median NFL team yards per rush: 4.1

Median Africa Pro: 7.4/54.2%/4.4
Median USA Pro: 7.5/56.2%/4.6
Median Canada Pro: 7.9/55.3%/4.9
Median W. Europe Pro: 8.2/56.9%/5.0

Okay, I got lazy and didn't do the other four. Those four are enough to cause me to accept that the point is valid that offenses need some taming.

That doesn't mean unrealistically good pass rushes are okay however, IMO.

These were very different from those I found a few days ago, but those were quite early numbers.

Completion percentages remain low, even with the other numbers high, suggesting that long passes may be too easy to complete, and that if long pass accuracy is nerfed somewhat, people will throw shorter for realistic completion percentages and realistic yards per attempt.

Rushing averages are also somewhat high, and I'd suggest replacing the LB drop-off with the same delay they take upon blitzing. The drop-off was always artificial and unrealistic, anyway.
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
What about college? I would interested to see the Medians there.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Usama
What about college? I would interested to see the Medians there.


I can't get a median for the NCAA, that I can find.

The NCAA doesn't keep it on a site, and I can't even get team stats by conference anywhere that I can find, such as ESPN's site (where I thought I might be able to at least get a conference median for some conferences).

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Usama

What about college? I would interested to see the Medians there.


I can't get a median for the NCAA, that I can find.

The NCAA doesn't keep it on a site, and I can't even get team stats by conference anywhere that I can find, such as ESPN's site (where I thought I might be able to at least get a conference median for some conferences).



yeah that is strange you'd think espn of all places would have those stats
 
Link
 
much more parity in the NFL than GLB.

If you made GLB numbers = NFL numbers then when you had 2 even teams playing then there would be no offense at all.

GLB numbers should be a decent amount above NFL numbers imo.

The running game is a little too powerful though. Bort needs to make a better run stuffing defense.

And an easy way to hurt the passing game a little is to help the DE's get a few more sacks.

Bort watches games and can see all this though. I'm sure he's working on it.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
much more parity in the NFL than GLB.

If you made GLB numbers = NFL numbers then when you had 2 even teams playing then there would be no offense at all.

GLB numbers should be a decent amount above NFL numbers imo.

The running game is a little too powerful though. Bort needs to make a better run stuffing defense.

And an easy way to hurt the passing game a little is to help the DE's get a few more sacks.

Bort watches games and can see all this though. I'm sure he's working on it.


Having DE's get more sacks wouldn't change those numbers much. It would just make sacks unrealistic. I think zone defenses don't work well enough-- though better than last season, no doubt-- and QB's even on long passes rarely just miss the target.

I always hated the forced LB drop-off, but accepted its necessity so that rushing stats weren't too low. Now that they're a little too high instead, I can fully advocate for getting rid of it.

Since I'm using medians, I don't think I'd find anything that different in NCAA stats. Still, the level of differences in talent here is a lot more like the NCAA, so I'd be interested to see them. If we have NCAA-like stats, that's just as good as if we have NFL-like stats.

Last edited Nov 18, 2008 17:07:13
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
I understand where you are going with this, and I agree offenses are scoring too many points, but to be honest if you pay for an offensive player like a WR or RB and you are the third guy on the depth chart on a real NFL team you would be lucky to see 3-4 TD's a year. To make the game more fun, scoring may have to be a little higher than normal. You don't see Madden turning down the score.

The idea is to be somewhat realistic, but also fun for everyone, including some backups.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
The solution - as always - isn't in the averages, but the realism.

Right now, the game is missing:

- WRs actually staying down after a diving catch (will take quite some yardage off deep passes! Great catches will still happen, but no advance afterwards)

- WRs/HBs stepping out of bounds on purpose to avoid the hit (minor issue, but will take off some yards)

- LBs reading the run first / getting rid of the "forced drop back" - but this will require some major changes to vision, for LBs "normally" read the run too fast now (but they don't have a free sight at the runner normally, so there needs to be a major change to recognizing the play at the same time, including falling for play action and fakes)

- play action / fakes

- realistic tackling and missed tackles; without the ability to break tackles on a regular basis, powerbacks are pretty useless (I'm not talking about 5 broken tackles a game, but 1-2 broken tackles on about every 3 - 5 yd rush; of course, this should use up HUGE stamina).

- pass rush/ pass protection balance (blocks are held way too long when equally build lineman face; i.e. the DEs needs to get a good chance to power through the OT as the play goes on [swim / rip]; at the same time, OTs need to get a hand on a DE almost all the time)

- WRs getting separation instead of unreal catches // at the same time, pass catching needs some MAJOR rework - instead of a increasing "catching radius", they need to get close to the ball (WRs should need good vision to check the direction and altitude early and adjust due to agility/speed). Jumping and diving catches should lessen the chance to get the ball quite a bit.

Basically: everything that brings the SIM closer to reality will bring the averages closer to reality - for some things just work in GLB because it's not realistic. If you're looking at the long passes: it's really hard to complete them in real games, for it's hard to throw them as accurate as needed and the WR needs to judge the ball just perfectly when in good coverage (while the DB needs to fail to judge the ball - needs to be unable to get there). In GLB, there's just a increased catching radius: so the QB needs to just throw it up in the air and the WR needs little to no adjustment - for he'll get a catching roll if he's within 2-5 yards.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.