User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > About time to get rid of auto-LB drop
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I don't need to post plays for people to know what I'm talking about. With the "blitz delay" now nerfing most LB's with a 1-3 tick delay, as per Bort, and the improved blocking on most runs and pass protection, I think we can get rid of the 3-5 step drop LBers take if they aren't blitzing.

Or, set the drop up based on the LB personal setting (playing the pass, balanced, or the run) + the play setting (pass, balanced or run).

If the LB is playing the run and the team wants him focusing on the run that play, he should step forward right at the snap, not backwards.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
He only added the delay on blitzers I think...and blitzing wasn't what was supposedly killing the run instantly.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
He only added the delay on blitzers I think...and blitzing wasn't what was supposedly killing the run instantly.


Key part of the statement.

The delay is on blitzers.

The auto 3-5 yard drop by LBers was put in when offenses were having trouble moving the ball. They are no longer having trouble, and that earlier change is no longer required and really handicaps the D.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE

The auto 3-5 yard drop by LBers was put in when offenses were having trouble moving the ball. They are no longer having trouble, and that earlier change is no longer required and really handicaps the D.


This is true.

But saying that it can be removed now that there is a delay kind of isn't a good reason since it is completely unrelated. It was added, as far as I know, because LB's were making the reads too soon and stopping the ball at the line every play, so Bort made LB's that are not blitzing drop back every play.

He changed the way blitzers react when the ball is snapped, that is irrelevant when it comes to making reads too soon, and stuffing the run every single play. Don't get me wrong, I would like to see it removed...I would also like to see the delay put on every single defensive player, not just blitzers, but I do not think the blitz delay is an argument to get rid of it. If the entire defense had a delay, which Bort mentioned, then yeah the drop back could be done away with, and the delay would be the reason it could be, but until that happens, it is unrelated.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
See, the reason I combine them:

Because of the drop, LBers who were not blitzing were pretty much taken out of run defense, at least until the ball got past the line, by an team who had a half decent runnning game. The way to try and handle this (the only way to get LBers moving forward) was to blitz them.

Now, there is a delay on the blitz, which in my opinion nerfs the abilities of a LB back even further.

Anyways, that is where I am going with it.

I've also noticed that defenders, LBers in particular, appear to seek out a blocker to engage rather than go after the ball carrier. This is one example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214498&pbp_id=1659032

I know the dots aren't exact, yadda, yadda, yadda...but the LB reads the play right, makes his move, but then just appears to engage the RT. No missed tackle.

The other thing I'm noticing is that HB's seem to squeeze, at full speed, through almost any "hole", if there is even a hole. 1 example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=214498&pbp_id=1659052

Again, I know the dots aren't exact, but a goalline D with 5-7 players crammed up, the o-line getting little to no push, a DT in the backfield right away...I can't see, thinking of watching an actual football league, how a back pulls this one off from 5-yards out at full speed.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but right now I'm having a lot of trouble determining what can be done on defense to have anything resembling effectiveness on a consistent basis.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Just to be clear, I only want there to be balance on both sides of the ball -- I don't want to see either side completely overpowered.

However, if I'm just missing something obvious, please feel free to point it out -- that would make me happy as well
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE

Correct me if I'm wrong, but right now I'm having a lot of trouble determining what can be done on defense to have anything resembling effectiveness on a consistent basis.


To be fair, defense isn't supposed to be "consistent". Only the best defenses will be near 100% consistent.

I do agree though...it is pretty hard to do well against a team of equal level. I see a lot more 42-41 games than I see 7-6 games.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Especially now that the Offense has a better Adv AI...I know last season the bitching was that the D has a better AI but you would think they would wait to release an offensive playbook and release the offensive and defensive playbooks in the same offseason...
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
release the offensive and defensive playbooks in the same offseason...


They did.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Zadith

release the offensive and defensive playbooks in the same offseason...


They did.


lol - if you're talking about the defensive presets vs. the new offensive plays and ability to built a custom playbook..you're right, but the value of this is MUCH higher on offense vs. defense -- lots of defensive presets that either look poorly designed or appear to be something we can just call through the old AI.

What the offense got on top of this, that the defense did not --- position specific depth charts AND the ability to call from these depth charts at any time. I don't need to explain how this can be used and abused against a defense.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I agree with Scace.

Defense used to be overpowered. Now that offenses are strong enough to handle it, just replace the ridiculous backup (which is a kludge, because it wouldn't happen in real life) with the same 1-3 tick delay blitzers get.

Seeing LB's back up in called run defenses looks awful, and it's now no longer necessary.


Last edited Nov 13, 2008 00:49:51
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

Defense used to be overpowered. Now that offenses are strong enough to handle it, just replace the ridiculous backup (which is a kludge, because it wouldn't happen in real life) with the same 1-3 second delay blitzers get.


I actually said that. If the entire defense got the 1-3 second delay, then I would be all for it.

But only blitzers having the delay isn't a reason to get rid of it.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I agree with Scace.

Defense used to be overpowered. Now that offenses are strong enough to handle it, just replace the ridiculous backup (which is a kludge, because it wouldn't happen in real life) with the same 1-3 tick delay blitzers get.

Seeing LB's back up in called run defenses looks awful, and it's now no longer necessary.




This -- put the delay on everyone but based on vision -- higher vision = less delay...ridiculous vision should be almost zero delay, fast read of the play.

Bort, what do you think? I think its time to at least consider removing the auto-LB backup, and this seems like a logical and reasonable way to do so.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Isn't the delay already based on vision? Pretty sure that was what Bort said, but I'm the only one that seems to have heard.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
What I'd love to see is make EVERY player make a vision check to see how quickly they get moving off the snap. Maybe give the offense a slight edge on this roll because they KNOW the snap count, but if a OL makes a bad roll and a DL makes a great roll, the DL gets the jump.

Then just get rid of dropping back and the blitz delay. Simple as pie.

Heck if you just wanted to make the range longer for different positions, that's cool.

Offense: 1-2 tick delay
DL: 1-3 delay
LB/Safeties: 1-4 delay
CB: 1-2 delay

or something like that.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.