User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Mercy Rule (lower it)
Page:
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Despite Bort's efforts to get rid of the 255-0 blowouts, there are still very unrealistic blowout wins happening (EG 140-0, 210-0, etc). So I propose this idea to finally end the 255-0 blowouts (or anything that's not even close)

Once a team is leading by at least 70 points in any point of the game, the game is "over". All stats counted and in-game breath do not lower/rise anymore. The game just "ends" there. While the teams still complete the game, the rest of the game is like a scrimmage (stats don't count, energy doesn't get lowered/raised).

Example:
Team A is leading 69-0 over Team B. Team A scores a TD run by their HB. The game's stats counted will end right after the XP is attempted, and breath will not change after that. The rest of the game will be completed as a scrimmage, but the only stats that are counted are up to the point when the score was made 76-0 (assuming the XP was made). Breath does not lower/rise anymore; a player's game ending-breath will be their breath after that last score

What this does:
-Eliminates blowout wins (of 140-0 or so)
-Lowers the amount of crazy stats in a game (no more 30 TDs in a game by a player!)
-Keeps the winning team's breath from dropping too much, and thus, not effecting their late season/postseason play as much

EDIT: Forgot an important part regarding XP (something around this would work; I don't know anything about the code though ):

100 (just a # I thought would work) / # of plays in the game = X

X * Normal XP gain = The amount of XP you'd get
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 23:56:28
 
JasonArgos
offline
Link
 
-1
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
what would happen to everyones snap count? Backups would be in trouble, as these games are where they get the most plays.
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
if everyone is given max xp +1 if not -2000000
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Forgot an important part regarding XP (something around this would work; I don't know anything about the code though ):

100 / # of plays in the game = X

X * Normal XP gain = The amount of XP you'd get

Originally posted by Knick
what would happen to everyones snap count? Backups would be in trouble, as these games are where they get the most plays.


See edit about the elevated XP
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 23:56:57
 
Nik Aitken
offline
Link
 
No.

/thread
 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nik.jd.aitken
No.

/thread


u always were the talker
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nik.jd.aitken
No.

/thread


You like the big blowouts that decide playoff spots, player awards, and kill your team's breath (and will hurt in the long run)?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I think this was brought up before, and we came up with cruise control instead. I agree that since we're not going to be able to completely stop people from quitting or just generally compiling sucky teams, it would be nice to have something to make those kind of games not count towards season stats or something.

I'm sure that if it were determined by score that somebody would figure out a way to manipulate their AI to pad stats without scoring too much.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
There's no way you can end the 255-0 scores, but Bort, may I propose this...

What really sucks too is that the league leaders ends up totally compromized by these blow out games. May I suggest that specifically the League Leaders board is revised? For instance...

Team A beats Team Z 255-0, in the game, RBs got 500 yards, WRs got 8 TDs, etc etc. Totally unrealistic. So perhaps you can write a formula that will collate all that info and FORCE it to be something realistic based on some mathematical percentage or average. So that in the end, on the League Leader board, for that game, the RB will end up being said to have gained say 180 yards. The WR will be said to have scored 3 TDs. Etc.

At least to uphold the integrity of the League Leaderboard. This may or may not also include those players' career stats. But for simplicity and nailing the more important thing (league leaders) at least do it for that even if the career stats get left as is.
Last edited Nov 12, 2008 01:23:08
 
greyghost
offline
Link
 
cry baby..don't lower anything, if you get your but whipped, to bad for you.
 
Omle
offline
Link
 
No way, Players still need the XP
 
greyghost
offline
Link
 
I agree players will get their xp's if the energy settings are correct.
 
- L -
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think this was brought up before, and we came up with cruise control instead. I agree that since we're not going to be able to completely stop people from quitting or just generally compiling sucky teams, it would be nice to have something to make those kind of games not count towards season stats or something.

I'm sure that if it were determined by score that somebody would figure out a way to manipulate their AI to pad stats without scoring too much.


oh what? I'd set the Kick/Punt Returner to be our Kicker/punter

And then, when ahead by 69 points, I'd set the Offense AI to QB Take Knee during downs 1-4 :-)

The only risk is getting INTs or Fumble Returns of TDs. I'd mitigate that risk by setting the points ahead thing to maybe 50 points instead of 69 points. Id also set everyone's tackling to wrap up and everyones coverage to "long" and "never go for the pick"


 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think this was brought up before, and we came up with cruise control instead. I agree that since we're not going to be able to completely stop people from quitting or just generally compiling sucky teams, it would be nice to have something to make those kind of games not count towards season stats or something.

I'm sure that if it were determined by score that somebody would figure out a way to manipulate their AI to pad stats without scoring too much.


If you must care about stats:
Give league stat awards based on players per game average stats against playoff teams only. This since the interconference could uneven the number of playoff teams faced.
This promotes sportsmanship by having superior teams rotate their starters for easy games and give the backups a field day.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.