OK, only one game in, but I'm getting on this now as opposed to waiting. I'm not saying fumble forcing chance has been increased, but it seems something in the formula is causing fumbles TOO often.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=225016
My RB, Shizzle, had two fumbles. He has 87 strength, 40 carrying, 36 vision, 35 confidence, and 5 in cover up. If these fumbles were caused by an NT or DT, I could understand that, since they probably have highter strength and tackling compared to Shizzle's Strength and carrying. However...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1210939 -- an FS caused one.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1215707 -- SS caused the other.
Before people try to blame this on confidence, Shizzle had two plays, one for 4.5 yards and one for 5 yards before this. Even if someone had auta of intimidation along with other morale hitting SAs, Shizzle shouldn't have fumbled this early as a result of confidence. On the second one, his team just stopped a drive via a turnover on downs -- shouldn't that BOOST someone's confidence? Not to mention, he had a good game up to that point, running for nearly 6 YPC with 2 touchdowns.
Considering the positions that caused this and the speed they were running, I'm thinking the effect of speed on fumbles is far higher than it should be. I understand that collision speed could result in more fumbles, but wouldn't someone who knows they are about to be hit hard cover the ball up a bit? Can we please do something about fumbles before they get to be ridiculously excessive?
And to counter the argument I know I'll see -- I highly doubt adding on 8 more carrying (to softcap) would prevent these fumbles. Do you need 75 carrying to lower the rate to any sort of a realistic level? 80? More? This RB, on the team I own, fumbles less than my RB, and he has far less strength and cover up, with similar carrying: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31567 . And he fumbles less in a tougher league, to boot.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=225016
My RB, Shizzle, had two fumbles. He has 87 strength, 40 carrying, 36 vision, 35 confidence, and 5 in cover up. If these fumbles were caused by an NT or DT, I could understand that, since they probably have highter strength and tackling compared to Shizzle's Strength and carrying. However...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1210939 -- an FS caused one.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1215707 -- SS caused the other.
Before people try to blame this on confidence, Shizzle had two plays, one for 4.5 yards and one for 5 yards before this. Even if someone had auta of intimidation along with other morale hitting SAs, Shizzle shouldn't have fumbled this early as a result of confidence. On the second one, his team just stopped a drive via a turnover on downs -- shouldn't that BOOST someone's confidence? Not to mention, he had a good game up to that point, running for nearly 6 YPC with 2 touchdowns.
Considering the positions that caused this and the speed they were running, I'm thinking the effect of speed on fumbles is far higher than it should be. I understand that collision speed could result in more fumbles, but wouldn't someone who knows they are about to be hit hard cover the ball up a bit? Can we please do something about fumbles before they get to be ridiculously excessive?
And to counter the argument I know I'll see -- I highly doubt adding on 8 more carrying (to softcap) would prevent these fumbles. Do you need 75 carrying to lower the rate to any sort of a realistic level? 80? More? This RB, on the team I own, fumbles less than my RB, and he has far less strength and cover up, with similar carrying: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31567 . And he fumbles less in a tougher league, to boot.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 12:20:38






























