User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > No Return - Punt Return - PR locked in place
Rezit
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1459654

Might want to check this play out. The Punt Returner DID NOT move after the ball went past him. Some sort of error in the play for sure.

Rez
 
Silky
offline
Link
 
If I was to guess the PR thought the ball was going to go into the end zone. He didn't want to risk running back, picking up the ball, get tackled on the three and possibly fumble. I don't see a particular problem with this and it happens in the pro's. The only difference is in the pro's the PR will try to block the gunner to give the ball a couple more seconds to go into the end zone.
 
Kasz216
offline
Link
 
Huh, same thing happened to me. I just thought i had low vision.
 
Durin
offline
Link
 
That's no bug, that's standard procedure on every football team. Catching the punt always includes the risk of fumbling it. No go figure out what happens if the PR fumbles on the own 4. And there really is no difference between just letting the punt get downed inside the 5 or taking it back to the 7 or 8.
If you've ever watched an NFL game, this is what happens when the punt goes inside the 10. Only difference may be that the Return Guy waves for a Fair Catch in RL, but in GLB the players have no arms, so...
 
giants66
offline
Link
 
maby he just took a nap. football players get tired too you no
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezit
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1459654

Might want to check this play out. The Punt Returner DID NOT move after the ball went past him. Some sort of error in the play for sure.

Rez


Your punt returner put his heels on the 10 and didn't move back to try to make the "great return". If more guys in the NFL did that more guys would stick as PR's. That's perfect football fundamentals as I see it. Coach "pop warner" or "rocket football" and try to teach rugrats this and you will pull your hair out watching them back up to the two and field it and not even get back to the 10. Take the odds that it goes into the endzone, they are much better.

I would be more concerned with Matt Rojas comming so close to touching the ball that could have then been picked up by Lance Sessions (who ended up touching it first) for a touchdown.
Last edited Apr 29, 2008 20:33:54
 
Link
 
No this is a bug. It happens a lot and there is nothing to explain it. The ball always gos over my PR head and lands at the 1 all the time. Its annoying and mite lose a game for us but we will never know.
Last edited Apr 29, 2008 20:45:08
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli
No this is a bug. It happens a lot and there is nothing to explain it. The ball always gos over my PR head and lands at the 1 all the time. Its annoying and mite lose a game for us but we will never know.


It's not a bug. If you have someone else that has a play where the PR backs up inside the 10 constantly then ok, but I doubt that's happening. This is based off real football where the coach pulls his hair out if you field the ball inside the 10 not Madden. Again, it's a smarter play to let the ball go inside the 10 on a punt then to field it.
 
bashman
offline
Link
 
Agree. It's called football fundamentals!!! Almost all PR are told to not catch the ball inside the 10 and instead rather hope for a TB.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bashman
Agree. It's called football fundamentals!!! Almost all PR are told to not catch the ball inside the 10 and instead rather hope for a TB.


no the bug is that the ball stops at the 1 yrd line. I can show you about 5-10 replays where this has happen to my PR.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli
Originally posted by bashman

Agree. It's called football fundamentals!!! Almost all PR are told to not catch the ball inside the 10 and instead rather hope for a TB.


no the bug is that the ball stops at the 1 yrd line. I can show you about 5-10 replays where this has happen to my PR.


Now the coding of the ball actually being punted and stopping at the one yard line might be off if this is happening alot. The punt returner not moving isn't a bug though (as the OP was saying). The odds of a ball punted (even by pro's on any given sunday) and landing on the one are very slim and almost never happen without a member of the punting team downing the ball there or diving into the endzone and knocking it back in the field of play. So if this is happening alot it's probably something that should be looked at.
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Your most likely playing a good punter
 
emehl
offline
Link
 
watch a real football game and you will see the same thing happen. PR's dont touch it in that situation.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.