User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
In my last scrimmage game the defensive AI ran plays that are no longer in my play book. I took them out 2 days ago which should have been more than enough time for the next game IMO.

As I look closer some of the defensive plays that were called don't exist anywhere in my defensive AI. My best guess is they were old plays as some of them look familiar but for different formations.

I was trying different things in this scrimmage game so I had no real expectations for the game itself. I modified the defensive AI at the end of our season to simpify the play calling. I have ran the tester many times for each situation. The tester always shows the right outputs but the plays on the field sometimes don't match what the tester shows.

Most of the inputs in question are very close to the top of my AI. The situation matches perfectly but he play called does not match my outputs. I don't have an output further down that matches the play in the sim. I used to, but that was two days ago.

Below is one example of what I am talking about. The problem is not limited to this play but it is a good example of what I am talking about.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=207569&pbp_id=11947629

Enter Situation
Quarter: 2nd
Time Remaining: 622 seconds
Ball Spot: Opponent's 48.5 yd line
Down: 1st
Yards to go: 10 yds
Score: I'm trailing by 11 points
Opponent Formation: Strong I
Number of Wide Receivers: 2

None of the outputs that the AI tester found match the play shown in the sim. I have nothing even close to what the sim showed. I did however have a similar play 2 days ago but I took it out because it did not work for my team. That play I had two days ago was actually an output for a different input. Either way the play in the sim is not in my AI and nothing like has been in the AI for at least two days.

I am very careful with the AI. I understand that human error is very common and I can accept the fact that this may be my fault. I would really like to know if it is my fault, and what I did wrong, so I can fix the problem. If it is not my fault it may be a bug. So I am posting it here.

Fixed spelling and grammer
Last edited Oct 30, 2008 14:56:39
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.