What this allows:
Put any defender on any man you want(includes double teams).
Mix zone and man coverage.
Put any LB, CB, or safety into a coverage zone.
Optional/back-up plan for a defender in man coverage when his man goes to block or isn't on the field.
Shade/shift safeties.
*********SHORTENED VERSION**********
1) Individual percent chance to blitz per player on DEF. AI screen is redundant, just create separate plays for each blitz and modify the % chance to call the play. Scrap it and use the space for the below slections.
2) Individual players get assigned an action for the play. ZONE, MAN, RUSH. The action should be further specified in the following catagories.
ZONE--flat--normal--deep--coverage(1-4)--Spy
Man--WR(1-5)--TE(1-3)--HB--FB
Rush--Inside--outside(around appropriate end)--Direct route--For DT's --slant left (credit Ken1)--slant right ( " )
# of players put in coverage determines the shell. 1-5 determines their starting position when placing them in the field. would allow swapping safety sides, putting a CB in in the middle of the field in Cover3 flanked by safeties, etc.
3)Players assigned man coverage need a back-up/secondary target chosen by the DC. Combine with one and two or done separately. I think its more important/needed sooner than above, but works best combined. When a player's target blocks, the player makes a vision test for reaction and attempts to default to his secondary action: ZONE selection, secondary man target, or selected rush defined by the DC at the play's creation. I don't want the SS i just brought up to the line for run support to take off and play patty cake with a WR. If the TE blocks, you could choose to have the SS rush, cover a different target, or just play a zone depending on what your strategy for the play is.
4)Safeties could use a shift not unlike LB's. strong( middle/strong), weak(weak/middle), wide (spread toward sidelines more).
5)Safety coverage priorities: players in the coverage zones need a coverage focus as LB's have a run/pass focus. Defend deepest in zone, defend widest in zone, defend the middle of the zone.
6)option added to allow the LB's to be spread wide in addition to weak, center, strong.
As Ken1 stated, its a lot of work, but together, as a package, I believe that it would be very functional and flexible to help keep pace with further offensive improvements. I also think it would help solve quirky problems being experienced by DC's now.
If anything need to be done first, I would suggest starting with the safeties Then the LB's. Man coverage options applied there would alleviate problems with unintended coverages and legitimate Double Team coverages instead of coaxing the system. Also, would allow a defender on the strong side to focus on the HB so MLB and ROLB can be blitzed together.
Example of usefulness: Shotgun 3wr
DC could choose to put the SS on the hb or te and LOLB on the other. One's target stays in to block. That player then shifts to his alternate action: man cover for double teaming, zone, or blitz. Cover 0-1 would not automatically result in a double team of the TE. Safeties could be set double outside WR's. LB's and Safeties would pause then rush instead of tearing off to go cover a WR who is blocking way away from the play.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
What would the actions selection look like?
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The assignment for a given position would have 2 boxes under it instead of the single box for blitz percentage and "0-100" next to it. The first box is the primary action for the defender. The second box is his coverage option (back-up plan). When target A blocks or isn't on the field, the player makes an adjustment to his second box.
A line backer would look like this for a blitz:
________ROLB_________
[rush-direct] [-------------]
This is for covering the TE with the option to blitz if the TE stays to block:
_______LOLB___________
[Man-TE1 ] [rush-outside]
Want to cover the TE with your LB, but have him go out in pass coverage even if he blocks? You could put him in a zone or cover another man.
_______LOLB___________
[Man-TE1 ] [Zone-(short,normal, or deep)]
_______LOLB___________
[Man-TE1 ] [Man-HB1 ]
Want your DE to cover the HB in a pass, but clog the line if he runs?
_______LDE____________
[Man-HB1 ] [rush-stunt inside]
Brought that safety up to the line in cover1 to help the run defense but you want him to cover the TE on a pass?
_______SS_____________
[Man-TE1 ] [Rush-direct]
Got your safety covering the HB, but you want him to drop back deep when the HB pass blocks?
_______SS_____________
[Man-HB1 ] [Zone-deep]
Want that MLB to hold his ground and watch for a delay?
_______MLB____________
[zone-spy ] [---------------]
How about a Double wide receiver play?
___________SS___________
[Man-WR1] [Rush-direct]
__________CB2__________
[Man-WR1] [Rush-direct]
Cover 2? (if position of cover zone is determined by below system)
__________FS____________
[Coverage 2] [-------------]
__________SS____________
[Coverage 4] [-------------]
If the coverage priorities is implemented as well then use the second box to determine that for a coverage zone.
[coverage 2] [cover-deep]
[coverage 4] [cover-wide]
--------------------------------------------------------------------
How safeties **could** work in this system:
--------------------------------------------------------------------
5 coverage positions might be more appropriate for coverage. If you think of position 1 and 5 as being the closest to the sidelines and 3 being the center then I think you could pretty much arrange a safety shift by placing them in the proper position. That would be just one way of implementing a safety shift and could be done with out making the DC mess with another box.
Using this method, the number of players that have coverage selected for their primary function would determine the shell or starting positions. Then they would drop back to the spot you selected for their coverage position (1-5).
If you wanted a nothing fancy cover 2 set up then you would put the FS and SS in coverage zones 2 and 4. FS would have [ coverage 2] selected. SS would have [coverage 4] selected.
side_______zone areas_________side
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|---------------FS----------------SS--------------|
If you wanted them to shade to one side or the other you could use zones 1 and 3 to put one over the outside and the other over the center.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|-------FS---------------SS-----------------------|
To shade them to the other side you could select zones 3 and 5.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|------------------------FS--------------SS-------|
To spread them wide, put them in zones 1 and 5.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|------FS--------------------------------SS-------|
For cover 3 plays you could say put FS at coverage 1, CB3 could have Coverage 5 selected, and the SS would have coverage 3 selected.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|-------FS--------------SS------------CB3------|
Cover 4:
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|------CB4-------FS--------SS------CB3------|
One possible way of doing the safety shift in the system I propose. Using 7 possible positions would give the DC even more control of how where the safeties line up and where.
Center 4
|------1-----2-----3-----4-----5-----6-----7------|
Just an additional thought on how to implement determining safety play and giving the DC the power to shift the safeties for better coverage.
*******************Original Post******************
Going back several pages I only see one somewhat similar post. If I didn't go back far enough, skipped it, or was otherwise blind I am sure there will be no shortage of folks to tell me so.
In my efforts to find better pass coverage I have found that Safeties are limited in covering deep and there are several issues in developing the coverage assignments. Control of the assignments and some predictability in the intended results are required to make an effective defensive plan.
Here are some of the issues I am sure everyone has wrestled with and complained about:
1) Safeties in the deep zones don't seem to read the developing play well.
2) Safeties tend to cover the deep middle and leave the WR open over top of your CB on the sides.
3) It is a difficult hit or miss game to arrange some form of double man coverage. Unless of course you intend to double the TE...that's practically assured.
4) LOLB will not defer coverage of the TE to the SS or vice versa in cover 1. One of my teams nearly died in the playoffs by implementing a 43 cover 1 where the ROLB and MLB were blitzed. Great if you want to double the TE but terrible if the receiving HB is left open all day because neither the LOLB or the SS cover the HB as was expected.
5) There are some strange behaviors of defenders when their assigned man blocks instead of running a route. An example would be cover 1 or cover 0 where a TE blocks for a run so the Safety runs away from the play to cover a WR instead of staying home to make the play. This is also the behavior that I observe in LB's backing away from the line of scrimmage on a run.
Here are some things I would like to be implemented in some form or fashion:
1) Though some people probably like the ability to select a number of blitzers and assign a percent chance to blitz from X,Y,or Z position, I find that the system is not intuitive, clumsy, and unnecessary when the same effect can be generated by just creating a separate play for each combination of blitzers and setting their chance to 100 percent. Instead of setting a percent chance to rush, you just select the positions that rush. You then adjust the amount of blitzing from each position by adjust the percentage that its specific blitz is called from. I know this sounds more like a tip than a productive modification to defensive play calling, but it works better with in the scope of the other suggestions. The individual position chance within a play can be scrapped.
2) Each position should have more specific instructions on its assigned function in a play. This will be selected by first checking a box under the position's place on the play creator for zone, man, or rush. There should be a drop down box to select the type of zone, man coverage assignment, or Rush. Or you skip the check box and select directly the specific option from a single drop down box.
EXAMPLES:
DT: (default to Rush, man coverage is not necessary)
Check rush or zone then select option.
Rush--(direct), (right), (left), (stunt left), (stunt right)
Zone--(short), (spy)
DE: (default rush)
Rush--(inside),(outside),(stunt inside)
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3)
Zone--(Flat, short, spy)
LB:
Rush--(direct, Outiside [around his appropriate side of the line])
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3,WR1,WR2,WR3,WR4,WR5)
Zone--(Spy, Flat, short, deep, coverage 1-5)
CB:
Rush--default/direct
Zone--(Spy, Flat, short, deep, coverage 1-5)
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3,WR1,WR2,WR3,WR4,WR5)
Safeties: (default to Cover Zone)
Zone--(Spy, Flat, short, deep, coverage 1-5)
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3,WR1,WR2,WR3,WR4,WR5)
Rush--(direct, Outiside [around his appropriate side of the line])
Where the FS and the SS line up would be determined by the number of DB's that have the coverage zone selected. This in effect determines the coverage shell. Theoretically, in this system you could have anyone play the cover 1 spot, 2 spot, etc. It would give the D.C. a powerful and flexible tool that would address most situations and be nearly complete.
3) NO TARGET/OPEN Target/double coverage assignemtns--More urgent in my opinion than the first two options is defensive assignment issues. This suggestion just fits nicely with the above in place. I noticed recently a good example of the problem in a game one of my teams played. When in 43cover 1 and the MLB and ROLB are blitzed, no one covers the HB and the TE gets double covered. The AI needs to have a check to see if all available receivers are covered before double covering a receiver. In this case one of them should have deferred coverage to the other one and picked up the RB.
Some sort of assignment check should be performed when the SS is in man coverage so that we can blitz the Middle and weak LB's without shooting ourselves in the foot. It is just common sense that one or the other should defer coverage. Now, I understand that this can be solved by not blitzing the Mid and Weak LB's together, but that fundamentally limits the options that you have to attack the O-Line. Yes, I could use it to my advantage should I want to double the TE, but the TE damn near gets triple covered the way safeties play. I see it as a hole in the system. I shouldn't have to "jerry-rig" the system and align planets just the right way to get everything covered. The suggestion #2 could solve this issue by allowing the D.C. to specifically assign coverages. I am sure that DC's all over GLB would love it if they were able to create a legitimate Double Wide play by just selecting Man coverage for the safeties and giving them an outside receiver on either side.
Still there will be times where something doesn't match up correctly. Take the Shotgun 3WR formation for example. Lets say you select a nickel cover 2 for the defense. Both safeties are put into cover zones and each CB is assigned a separate WR. One LB is given the HB and the other is given the TE. Depending on the specific play that comes out of that shotgun, you may have a TE and a HB, a TE only, or a HB only. Each position can be given a "default" action designated by the D.C. when assigning man coverage during play creation just like his orignal defensive assignment was. The halfback stays in to block, the LB assigned to him suddenly has no one to cover, the D.C. decided that that LB would default to another action if his coverage target was made unavailable on this specific play. The LB makes a vision check and then proceeds to his secondary option.
The default would be selected just as the original assignment was. By having that selected per play it would increase the work of the D.C., but it would keep the play functioning with in his defensive philosophy. If one is not selected by the DC, the game could choose a simple Zone on its own. This may not be necessary for Cb's, DT's, and perhaps DE's, but I feel it is ****VITAL WHEN SAFETIES AND LINEBACKERS ARE INVOLVED IN MAN COVERAGE****.
4) I would like the ability to shift the Safeties to one side or the other. Shift it to the strong side to have the strong safety play closer to the sideline and FS in the middle or vice versa. A third option would be to shift them wide.
5) Safety cover priorities. Select cover the widest, deepest, or middle of his area.
6) An option to spread the LB's wide in addition to center, strong, and weak.
I understand that I am not familiar with the work involved coding/programming the sim and do not have a great understanding of the individual cogs of the AI. My biggest suggestion seemed to me to present a different, more flexible approach to the Defensive AI. It would eliminate some of the hit or miss involved with trying to get the defense to cover the way you intend. It may sound a little overwhelming to some users selecting each player's assignment and a default per play, but you could make the play book as general or specific as you want it by making more plays for more specific situations. It is my belief that the people who really use the advanced AI are the only who really enjoy managing and developing strategies. For those who don't enjoy it, the basic AI would still work and a few created plays could be made to cover a large number of situations.
That's it for now. Flame on.
Put any defender on any man you want(includes double teams).
Mix zone and man coverage.
Put any LB, CB, or safety into a coverage zone.
Optional/back-up plan for a defender in man coverage when his man goes to block or isn't on the field.
Shade/shift safeties.
*********SHORTENED VERSION**********
1) Individual percent chance to blitz per player on DEF. AI screen is redundant, just create separate plays for each blitz and modify the % chance to call the play. Scrap it and use the space for the below slections.
2) Individual players get assigned an action for the play. ZONE, MAN, RUSH. The action should be further specified in the following catagories.
ZONE--flat--normal--deep--coverage(1-4)--Spy
Man--WR(1-5)--TE(1-3)--HB--FB
Rush--Inside--outside(around appropriate end)--Direct route--For DT's --slant left (credit Ken1)--slant right ( " )
# of players put in coverage determines the shell. 1-5 determines their starting position when placing them in the field. would allow swapping safety sides, putting a CB in in the middle of the field in Cover3 flanked by safeties, etc.
3)Players assigned man coverage need a back-up/secondary target chosen by the DC. Combine with one and two or done separately. I think its more important/needed sooner than above, but works best combined. When a player's target blocks, the player makes a vision test for reaction and attempts to default to his secondary action: ZONE selection, secondary man target, or selected rush defined by the DC at the play's creation. I don't want the SS i just brought up to the line for run support to take off and play patty cake with a WR. If the TE blocks, you could choose to have the SS rush, cover a different target, or just play a zone depending on what your strategy for the play is.
4)Safeties could use a shift not unlike LB's. strong( middle/strong), weak(weak/middle), wide (spread toward sidelines more).
5)Safety coverage priorities: players in the coverage zones need a coverage focus as LB's have a run/pass focus. Defend deepest in zone, defend widest in zone, defend the middle of the zone.
6)option added to allow the LB's to be spread wide in addition to weak, center, strong.
As Ken1 stated, its a lot of work, but together, as a package, I believe that it would be very functional and flexible to help keep pace with further offensive improvements. I also think it would help solve quirky problems being experienced by DC's now.
If anything need to be done first, I would suggest starting with the safeties Then the LB's. Man coverage options applied there would alleviate problems with unintended coverages and legitimate Double Team coverages instead of coaxing the system. Also, would allow a defender on the strong side to focus on the HB so MLB and ROLB can be blitzed together.
Example of usefulness: Shotgun 3wr
DC could choose to put the SS on the hb or te and LOLB on the other. One's target stays in to block. That player then shifts to his alternate action: man cover for double teaming, zone, or blitz. Cover 0-1 would not automatically result in a double team of the TE. Safeties could be set double outside WR's. LB's and Safeties would pause then rush instead of tearing off to go cover a WR who is blocking way away from the play.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
What would the actions selection look like?
--------------------------------------------------------------------
The assignment for a given position would have 2 boxes under it instead of the single box for blitz percentage and "0-100" next to it. The first box is the primary action for the defender. The second box is his coverage option (back-up plan). When target A blocks or isn't on the field, the player makes an adjustment to his second box.
A line backer would look like this for a blitz:
________ROLB_________
[rush-direct] [-------------]
This is for covering the TE with the option to blitz if the TE stays to block:
_______LOLB___________
[Man-TE1 ] [rush-outside]
Want to cover the TE with your LB, but have him go out in pass coverage even if he blocks? You could put him in a zone or cover another man.
_______LOLB___________
[Man-TE1 ] [Zone-(short,normal, or deep)]
_______LOLB___________
[Man-TE1 ] [Man-HB1 ]
Want your DE to cover the HB in a pass, but clog the line if he runs?
_______LDE____________
[Man-HB1 ] [rush-stunt inside]
Brought that safety up to the line in cover1 to help the run defense but you want him to cover the TE on a pass?
_______SS_____________
[Man-TE1 ] [Rush-direct]
Got your safety covering the HB, but you want him to drop back deep when the HB pass blocks?
_______SS_____________
[Man-HB1 ] [Zone-deep]
Want that MLB to hold his ground and watch for a delay?
_______MLB____________
[zone-spy ] [---------------]
How about a Double wide receiver play?
___________SS___________
[Man-WR1] [Rush-direct]
__________CB2__________
[Man-WR1] [Rush-direct]
Cover 2? (if position of cover zone is determined by below system)
__________FS____________
[Coverage 2] [-------------]
__________SS____________
[Coverage 4] [-------------]
If the coverage priorities is implemented as well then use the second box to determine that for a coverage zone.
[coverage 2] [cover-deep]
[coverage 4] [cover-wide]
--------------------------------------------------------------------
How safeties **could** work in this system:
--------------------------------------------------------------------
5 coverage positions might be more appropriate for coverage. If you think of position 1 and 5 as being the closest to the sidelines and 3 being the center then I think you could pretty much arrange a safety shift by placing them in the proper position. That would be just one way of implementing a safety shift and could be done with out making the DC mess with another box.
Using this method, the number of players that have coverage selected for their primary function would determine the shell or starting positions. Then they would drop back to the spot you selected for their coverage position (1-5).
If you wanted a nothing fancy cover 2 set up then you would put the FS and SS in coverage zones 2 and 4. FS would have [ coverage 2] selected. SS would have [coverage 4] selected.
side_______zone areas_________side
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|---------------FS----------------SS--------------|
If you wanted them to shade to one side or the other you could use zones 1 and 3 to put one over the outside and the other over the center.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|-------FS---------------SS-----------------------|
To shade them to the other side you could select zones 3 and 5.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|------------------------FS--------------SS-------|
To spread them wide, put them in zones 1 and 5.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|------FS--------------------------------SS-------|
For cover 3 plays you could say put FS at coverage 1, CB3 could have Coverage 5 selected, and the SS would have coverage 3 selected.
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|-------FS--------------SS------------CB3------|
Cover 4:
|-------1--------2--------3-------4-------5-------|
|------CB4-------FS--------SS------CB3------|
One possible way of doing the safety shift in the system I propose. Using 7 possible positions would give the DC even more control of how where the safeties line up and where.
Center 4
|------1-----2-----3-----4-----5-----6-----7------|
Just an additional thought on how to implement determining safety play and giving the DC the power to shift the safeties for better coverage.
*******************Original Post******************
Going back several pages I only see one somewhat similar post. If I didn't go back far enough, skipped it, or was otherwise blind I am sure there will be no shortage of folks to tell me so.
In my efforts to find better pass coverage I have found that Safeties are limited in covering deep and there are several issues in developing the coverage assignments. Control of the assignments and some predictability in the intended results are required to make an effective defensive plan.
Here are some of the issues I am sure everyone has wrestled with and complained about:
1) Safeties in the deep zones don't seem to read the developing play well.
2) Safeties tend to cover the deep middle and leave the WR open over top of your CB on the sides.
3) It is a difficult hit or miss game to arrange some form of double man coverage. Unless of course you intend to double the TE...that's practically assured.
4) LOLB will not defer coverage of the TE to the SS or vice versa in cover 1. One of my teams nearly died in the playoffs by implementing a 43 cover 1 where the ROLB and MLB were blitzed. Great if you want to double the TE but terrible if the receiving HB is left open all day because neither the LOLB or the SS cover the HB as was expected.
5) There are some strange behaviors of defenders when their assigned man blocks instead of running a route. An example would be cover 1 or cover 0 where a TE blocks for a run so the Safety runs away from the play to cover a WR instead of staying home to make the play. This is also the behavior that I observe in LB's backing away from the line of scrimmage on a run.
Here are some things I would like to be implemented in some form or fashion:
1) Though some people probably like the ability to select a number of blitzers and assign a percent chance to blitz from X,Y,or Z position, I find that the system is not intuitive, clumsy, and unnecessary when the same effect can be generated by just creating a separate play for each combination of blitzers and setting their chance to 100 percent. Instead of setting a percent chance to rush, you just select the positions that rush. You then adjust the amount of blitzing from each position by adjust the percentage that its specific blitz is called from. I know this sounds more like a tip than a productive modification to defensive play calling, but it works better with in the scope of the other suggestions. The individual position chance within a play can be scrapped.
2) Each position should have more specific instructions on its assigned function in a play. This will be selected by first checking a box under the position's place on the play creator for zone, man, or rush. There should be a drop down box to select the type of zone, man coverage assignment, or Rush. Or you skip the check box and select directly the specific option from a single drop down box.
EXAMPLES:
DT: (default to Rush, man coverage is not necessary)
Check rush or zone then select option.
Rush--(direct), (right), (left), (stunt left), (stunt right)
Zone--(short), (spy)
DE: (default rush)
Rush--(inside),(outside),(stunt inside)
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3)
Zone--(Flat, short, spy)
LB:
Rush--(direct, Outiside [around his appropriate side of the line])
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3,WR1,WR2,WR3,WR4,WR5)
Zone--(Spy, Flat, short, deep, coverage 1-5)
CB:
Rush--default/direct
Zone--(Spy, Flat, short, deep, coverage 1-5)
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3,WR1,WR2,WR3,WR4,WR5)
Safeties: (default to Cover Zone)
Zone--(Spy, Flat, short, deep, coverage 1-5)
Man--(HB,FB,TE1,TE2,TE3,WR1,WR2,WR3,WR4,WR5)
Rush--(direct, Outiside [around his appropriate side of the line])
Where the FS and the SS line up would be determined by the number of DB's that have the coverage zone selected. This in effect determines the coverage shell. Theoretically, in this system you could have anyone play the cover 1 spot, 2 spot, etc. It would give the D.C. a powerful and flexible tool that would address most situations and be nearly complete.
3) NO TARGET/OPEN Target/double coverage assignemtns--More urgent in my opinion than the first two options is defensive assignment issues. This suggestion just fits nicely with the above in place. I noticed recently a good example of the problem in a game one of my teams played. When in 43cover 1 and the MLB and ROLB are blitzed, no one covers the HB and the TE gets double covered. The AI needs to have a check to see if all available receivers are covered before double covering a receiver. In this case one of them should have deferred coverage to the other one and picked up the RB.
Some sort of assignment check should be performed when the SS is in man coverage so that we can blitz the Middle and weak LB's without shooting ourselves in the foot. It is just common sense that one or the other should defer coverage. Now, I understand that this can be solved by not blitzing the Mid and Weak LB's together, but that fundamentally limits the options that you have to attack the O-Line. Yes, I could use it to my advantage should I want to double the TE, but the TE damn near gets triple covered the way safeties play. I see it as a hole in the system. I shouldn't have to "jerry-rig" the system and align planets just the right way to get everything covered. The suggestion #2 could solve this issue by allowing the D.C. to specifically assign coverages. I am sure that DC's all over GLB would love it if they were able to create a legitimate Double Wide play by just selecting Man coverage for the safeties and giving them an outside receiver on either side.
Still there will be times where something doesn't match up correctly. Take the Shotgun 3WR formation for example. Lets say you select a nickel cover 2 for the defense. Both safeties are put into cover zones and each CB is assigned a separate WR. One LB is given the HB and the other is given the TE. Depending on the specific play that comes out of that shotgun, you may have a TE and a HB, a TE only, or a HB only. Each position can be given a "default" action designated by the D.C. when assigning man coverage during play creation just like his orignal defensive assignment was. The halfback stays in to block, the LB assigned to him suddenly has no one to cover, the D.C. decided that that LB would default to another action if his coverage target was made unavailable on this specific play. The LB makes a vision check and then proceeds to his secondary option.
The default would be selected just as the original assignment was. By having that selected per play it would increase the work of the D.C., but it would keep the play functioning with in his defensive philosophy. If one is not selected by the DC, the game could choose a simple Zone on its own. This may not be necessary for Cb's, DT's, and perhaps DE's, but I feel it is ****VITAL WHEN SAFETIES AND LINEBACKERS ARE INVOLVED IN MAN COVERAGE****.
4) I would like the ability to shift the Safeties to one side or the other. Shift it to the strong side to have the strong safety play closer to the sideline and FS in the middle or vice versa. A third option would be to shift them wide.
5) Safety cover priorities. Select cover the widest, deepest, or middle of his area.
6) An option to spread the LB's wide in addition to center, strong, and weak.
I understand that I am not familiar with the work involved coding/programming the sim and do not have a great understanding of the individual cogs of the AI. My biggest suggestion seemed to me to present a different, more flexible approach to the Defensive AI. It would eliminate some of the hit or miss involved with trying to get the defense to cover the way you intend. It may sound a little overwhelming to some users selecting each player's assignment and a default per play, but you could make the play book as general or specific as you want it by making more plays for more specific situations. It is my belief that the people who really use the advanced AI are the only who really enjoy managing and developing strategies. For those who don't enjoy it, the basic AI would still work and a few created plays could be made to cover a large number of situations.
That's it for now. Flame on.
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 05:15:57






























