User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
Is their a bug with the 3-3-5 formation? The sim says it's running:


Possible Outputs
60% 3-3-5 Blitz (nickel 3-4 Cover 2 man)
40% Nickle Blitz (nickel Cover 2 man)
***The formation under that output is set to 3-3-5, but for some reason it's running the 3-4. It's doing this to me in more then 1 Input and I've run the Defense test to make sure it wasn't a mistake by me. The right Input is chosen by the sim but it's not running the correct Output.

It also ran a Dime formation in another set that was supposed to be 3-3-5
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 14:27:58
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
3-3-5 is the same thing as Nickel 3-4.

Got a link to the play that you got that test output from?
 
aspenwolf
offline
Link
 
3-3-5 isn't the same as a 3-4, but i understand what you're saying

the 3-3-5 works fine, i've used it before a bunch. however, what else do you have for AI settings? 3rd down? 3rd and short? trailing behind? points ahead?

are the possible outputs in the OP in the basic settings? do you have other things that might override them
 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=196635&pbp_id=10036810

 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aspenwolf
3-3-5 isn't the same as a 3-4, but i understand what you're saying

the 3-3-5 works fine, i've used it before a bunch. however, what else do you have for AI settings? 3rd down? 3rd and short? trailing behind? points ahead?

are the possible outputs in the OP in the basic settings? do you have other things that might override them


I've run the defensive AI tester and it picks the Input that it should and then it even says it picks the 3-3-5 as I copied and pasted above, but if you see it says the output is 3-3-5, but it says nickel 3-4 cover 2 man in the (). When I went back to check I had the formation set as 3-3-5 I did and have no idea why I'd run a 3-4 in that situation. the reason I run the 3-3 5 is to make sure to have 3 CBs in the game and still get a pass rush from my LBs.

 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
Here is the same situation.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=196635&pbp_id=10036810

Here it ran the 3-4 with me covering the 3rd WR with a FS. The output says the 3-3-5 was to be run. I don't want a FS lined up on a WR.
 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
The Input is set for the Shotgun Formation and is the first Input I have at the top of the Defense AI. I know the Sim chooses it because I've tested it on every play it comes up.

Here the sim ran the input correctly. This is the same game as where it was running the wrong formation

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=196635&pbp_id=10036810
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 15:13:21
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lofaw
Here is the same situation.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=196635&pbp_id=10036810

Here it ran the 3-4 with me covering the 3rd WR with a FS. The output says the 3-3-5 was to be run. I don't want a FS lined up on a WR.


This is a 4-3 Man to Man look at the FS
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Need to check your AI settings for your formation against the weak I.
 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GT-Texans
Need to check your AI settings for your formation against the weak I.


Why is that?
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lofaw
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=196635&pbp_id=10036810



So that's the situation (time remaining, down, yards to first down, etc) that you input to get the test output you have in the first post?

You said "the formation under that output is set to 3-3-5, but for some reason it's running the 3-4".

Actually that's a 4-3. Still, if you did the test correctly then it shouldn't be running the 4-3. So I'm not sure what's up, from the information I have.

What is in the parentheses () is what will actually be used. Before that is just the name you gave it.

 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lofaw
Originally posted by GT-Texans

Need to check your AI settings for your formation against the weak I.


Why is that?


All your examples are when the offense is in the weak I.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
You were mentioning shotgun at one point and that was against the weak I formation.
 
Link
 
First off the FS's primary job is covering a WR that your going to have to deal with unless we can start putting our players where we want them and determining their separate path/assignments. If the settings were for a run defense then the SS would move up and watch the HB and TEs and the FS would cover the weak side WRs. Also it appears you have a cover 0(all man) which means it would bring the FS up to watch a man and since his assignment is usually a WR thats where he would be. Also, the biggest mistake most Dcs make is not putting a 0(zero) where you don't want the player to blitz. You leave one of those open and the computer will skip right over it and make up its own play so check those. My suggestion is cover 1 in this situation. I use the 3-3-5 a lot and Ive never had "problems". I think its a setting problem.
 
Lofaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER
First off the FS's primary job is covering a WR that your going to have to deal with unless we can start putting our players where we want them and determining their separate path/assignments. If the settings were for a run defense then the SS would move up and watch the HB and TEs and the FS would cover the weak side WRs. Also it appears you have a cover 0(all man) which means it would bring the FS up to watch a man and since his assignment is usually a WR thats where he would be. Also, the biggest mistake most Dcs make is not putting a 0(zero) where you don't want the player to blitz. You leave one of those open and the computer will skip right over it and make up its own play so check those. My suggestion is cover 1 in this situation. I use the 3-3-5 a lot and Ive never had "problems". I think its a setting problem.


In the 3-3-5 don't you have 3 CBs on the field to cover the 3 WRs? Then why would I need a FS to cover a WR? I've been doing this a long time and this is the 1st game I've had issues with the Defensive AI and I haven't changed that Input this season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.