User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Ranking in Africa AA#1 Incorrect?!
Duris
offline
Link
 
Rules say:

-----a. If there are only 2 teams, it's just based upon the head-to-head matchup
-----b. If there are more than 2 teams, then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. # of head-to-head wins against the other teams with the same record
2. # of points scored
3. # of points allowed.

Question is, what points are we talking about in #2 and #3. We talking about points the tied teams have in commen, or total points for the year? If it is total points tied teams have in commen, then!

DD 13-3, W against GB and EB. L against ZL. Points scored 95, allowed 56.
GB 13-3, W against ZL and EB. L against DD. Points scored 82, allowed 85.
EB 13-3, W against ZL. L against DD and GB. Points scored 62, allowed 79.
ZL 13-3, W against DD. L against GB and EB. Points scored 78, allowed 97.

Since the order is Ghana Buffalos (GB), Doinitin Djibouti (DD), EEORG Bastards (EB) and Zanzibar Leopards (ZL), it would seem that both GB and DD would switch and so would EB and ZL. Even if I only look at the W points scored, DD is ahead of GB by 74 to 72. So, unless Bort has changed something without posting it; I can find no way that GB should be ahead of DD based on the two wins or the one lose looking at these 3 criteria only.

If it's total points for the year, then I'm not sure because I can't quickly find that info this morning.

This needs to be addressed and corrected before the sims run!
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
I believe that it's total points scored for the season, which can be seen here;

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=86&conference_id=172&stat=other&sort=points_scored&playoffs=0
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
You have a 4-way tie at 13-3.

2 Ghana Buffalos 13-3 - beat EEORG and Zanzibar - 980 points scored
3 Doinitin Djibouti 13-3 - beat Ghana and EEORG - 893 points scored
4 EEORG Bastards 13-3 - beat Zanzibar - 872 points scored
5 Zanzibar Leopards 13-3 - beat Doinitin - 764 points scored

In multi-team ties, the first tie-breaker is the total number of head-to-head wins over the teams you're tied with. The second tie-breaker is total points scored.

The teams are sorted correctly.
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Duris
Rules say:

-----a. If there are only 2 teams, it's just based upon the head-to-head matchup
-----b. If there are more than 2 teams, then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. # of head-to-head wins against the other teams with the same record
2. # of points scored
3. # of points allowed.

Question is, what points are we talking about in #2 and #3. We talking about points the tied teams have in commen, or total points for the year? If it is total points tied teams have in commen, then!

DD 13-3, W against GB and EB. L against ZL. Points scored 95, allowed 56.
GB 13-3, W against ZL and EB. L against DD. Points scored 82, allowed 85.
EB 13-3, W against ZL. L against DD and GB. Points scored 62, allowed 79.
ZL 13-3, W against DD. L against GB and EB. Points scored 78, allowed 97.

Since the order is Ghana Buffalos (GB), Doinitin Djibouti (DD), EEORG Bastards (EB) and Zanzibar Leopards (ZL), it would seem that both GB and DD would switch and so would EB and ZL. Even if I only look at the W points scored, DD is ahead of GB by 74 to 72. So, unless Bort has changed something without posting it; I can find no way that GB should be ahead of DD based on the two wins or the one lose looking at these 3 criteria only.

If it's total points for the year, then I'm not sure because I can't quickly find that info this morning.

This needs to be addressed and corrected before the sims run!


… … … … … … … …,--~~~--,
… … … … … … … .,/:::____:::\
… … … … … … … .|ŻŻ::::::::ŻŻ|.........Chugga Chugga Chugga, GTFO of the way
… … … … … … … .|:::::::::::::::|… ...___
… … … … … ____... \:::::::::::::/...,-“. . . .”-,… … ,,--~~-,,____,,--~~~~--,,__
… … … … ..,/. .\::::Ż\,.\::::::::::/…/. . . . . . .\... .,-“. . . . . .”-,::::::::::_,,-“--,,_::: ŻŻ”~,,_
… … … … ..|. . ‘|:::::::|..\:::::::/… |. . . . . . . .|… |. . . . . . . . |:::::,,-“...|:::::::|’|”~-,,____”~,_
… … … … .,-“~”,---~~”----“----“----~“-,__. . . . '|_,-“~~~--,,_,,-“ŻŻŻ”’~~--’--,,,_|:'|/\„„/\,|::::|..ŻŻ
… … … ..,-“::::::::”-,:::::::::::::::::::::::::::”~~---“:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|’|( şoş )|:::|
… … … ./::::::::::::::\::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|:::’-----‘::::|
… … … ‘|:::::::::::::::|::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|:::::::::::::|
… … … .\::::::::::::::/,_::::::::::::::::::::::::________:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::’|:::::::::::::|
… … ... ..”-,:::::::,-“:::::ŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻ::::::::::::::::ŻŻ”’~~--,,__::::::::::::::::::|:::::::::::::|
… … … … ,”~~”::::::::::::::::,-------,::::::::::::::,,-~~~-,,___,,-~~~-,,~~~~----‘|::::::::::::::|
… … … .._,|::::::::::::::::::::::|::::::::|:::::::::::,-“;_,,--~~’,~,’~~~~;;;;’\_-----_,/’---------,-----‘
… … …,-“::\,__:::::::::::,-~~’,::::::::’~~-,:_,,”~”;;;;;;;;;;;\: /;;;;;;;;;;;;;;'\:ŻŻ::|;;;;;;;;;;;;|
… … …|,,~”Ż…Ż”~-,:::|:::::::|::::::::::::::|__’|;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;'|,|;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;|--~~|;;;;;;;;;;;;|
… .,,~”Ż…………….’\,”-,,__/______,-“… .\;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;/..\;;;;;;;;;;;;;;/---~~’\”’ŻŻŻŻ,/
…_”____,,,,---,~~_~,~”;;;’\___/;;;;;;;\... … .”-,;;;;;;;;,-“… .”-,,___,-“… … ..”~---~”
… … … .”~-~”… .. Ż\,__,/’… .’\,__,/’… … …”~--~”
 
jallred350
offline
Link
 
The points for the year match up with the current seedings.

GB-980
DD-893
EB-872
ZL-764

This info is in the blocking/other tab at the following link.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=86&conference_id=172&stat=other&playoffs=0
 
Ojete
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kalkmanc
Originally posted by Duris

Rules say:

-----a. If there are only 2 teams, it's just based upon the head-to-head matchup
-----b. If there are more than 2 teams, then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. # of head-to-head wins against the other teams with the same record
2. # of points scored
3. # of points allowed.

Question is, what points are we talking about in #2 and #3. We talking about points the tied teams have in commen, or total points for the year? If it is total points tied teams have in commen, then!

DD 13-3, W against GB and EB. L against ZL. Points scored 95, allowed 56.
GB 13-3, W against ZL and EB. L against DD. Points scored 82, allowed 85.
EB 13-3, W against ZL. L against DD and GB. Points scored 62, allowed 79.
ZL 13-3, W against DD. L against GB and EB. Points scored 78, allowed 97.

Since the order is Ghana Buffalos (GB), Doinitin Djibouti (DD), EEORG Bastards (EB) and Zanzibar Leopards (ZL), it would seem that both GB and DD would switch and so would EB and ZL. Even if I only look at the W points scored, DD is ahead of GB by 74 to 72. So, unless Bort has changed something without posting it; I can find no way that GB should be ahead of DD based on the two wins or the one lose looking at these 3 criteria only.

If it's total points for the year, then I'm not sure because I can't quickly find that info this morning.

This needs to be addressed and corrected before the sims run!


… … … … … … … …,--~~~--,
… … … … … … … .,/:::____:::\
… … … … … … … .|ŻŻ::::::::ŻŻ|.........Chugga Chugga Chugga, GTFO of the way
… … … … … … … .|:::::::::::::::|… ...___
… … … … … ____... \:::::::::::::/...,-“. . . .”-,… … ,,--~~-,,____,,--~~~~--,,__
… … … … ..,/. .\::::Ż\,.\::::::::::/…/. . . . . . .\... .,-“. . . . . .”-,::::::::::_,,-“--,,_::: ŻŻ”~,,_
… … … … ..|. . ‘|:::::::|..\:::::::/… |. . . . . . . .|… |. . . . . . . . |:::::,,-“...|:::::::|’|”~-,,____”~,_
… … … … .,-“~”,---~~”----“----“----~“-,__. . . . '|_,-“~~~--,,_,,-“ŻŻŻ”’~~--’--,,,_|:'|/\„„/\,|::::|..ŻŻ
… … … ..,-“::::::::”-,:::::::::::::::::::::::::::”~~---“:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|’|( şoş )|:::|
… … … ./::::::::::::::\::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|:::’-----‘::::|
… … … ‘|:::::::::::::::|::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|:::::::::::::|
… … … .\::::::::::::::/,_::::::::::::::::::::::::________:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::’|:::::::::::::|
… … ... ..”-,:::::::,-“:::::ŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻ::::::::::::::::ŻŻ”’~~--,,__::::::::::::::::::|:::::::::::::|
… … … … ,”~~”::::::::::::::::,-------,::::::::::::::,,-~~~-,,___,,-~~~-,,~~~~----‘|::::::::::::::|
… … … .._,|::::::::::::::::::::::|::::::::|:::::::::::,-“;_,,--~~’,~,’~~~~;;;;’\_-----_,/’---------,-----‘
… … …,-“::\,__:::::::::::,-~~’,::::::::’~~-,:_,,”~”;;;;;;;;;;;\: /;;;;;;;;;;;;;;'\:ŻŻ::|;;;;;;;;;;;;|
… … …|,,~”Ż…Ż”~-,:::|:::::::|::::::::::::::|__’|;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;'|,|;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;|--~~|;;;;;;;;;;;;|
… .,,~”Ż…………….’\,”-,,__/______,-“… .\;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;/..\;;;;;;;;;;;;;;/---~~’\”’ŻŻŻŻ,/
…_”____,,,,---,~~_~,~”;;;’\___/;;;;;;;\... … .”-,;;;;;;;;,-“… .”-,,___,-“… … ..”~---~”
… … … .”~-~”… .. Ż\,__,/’… .’\,__,/’… … …”~--~”


That train seems to be going backwards...
 
Duris
offline
Link
 
Well common sense would suggest that if your dealing with a tie you'd only use the points for and points against with the tied teams. However, I guess common sense doesn't exist and everyone should just turn off that AI stuff to put in your backups should the score get out of hand...How Silly!
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Duris
Well common sense would suggest that if your dealing with a tie you'd only use the points for and points against with the tied teams. However, I guess common sense doesn't exist and everyone should just turn off that AI stuff to put in your backups should the score get out of hand...How Silly!


You can do that, but that only helps if you need help in a multi-team tie-breaker. And it could hurt you long-run by keeping your backups from building up more XP.

It's a judgement call... take steps for a scenario that might affect you but probably won't (multi-team tie-breaker), or get your backups valuable XP. I know which one I'd choose.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Originally posted by Duris

Well common sense would suggest that if your dealing with a tie you'd only use the points for and points against with the tied teams. However, I guess common sense doesn't exist and everyone should just turn off that AI stuff to put in your backups should the score get out of hand...How Silly!


You can do that, but that only helps if you need help in a multi-team tie-breaker. And it could hurt you long-run by keeping your backups from building up more XP.

It's a judgement call... take steps for a scenario that might affect you but probably won't (multi-team tie-breaker), or get your backups valuable XP. I know which one I'd choose.


Agreed, go for the points scored!
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
FEAR DD
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by Novus

Originally posted by Duris


Well common sense would suggest that if your dealing with a tie you'd only use the points for and points against with the tied teams. However, I guess common sense doesn't exist and everyone should just turn off that AI stuff to put in your backups should the score get out of hand...How Silly!


You can do that, but that only helps if you need help in a multi-team tie-breaker. And it could hurt you long-run by keeping your backups from building up more XP.

It's a judgement call... take steps for a scenario that might affect you but probably won't (multi-team tie-breaker), or get your backups valuable XP. I know which one I'd choose.


Agreed, go for the points scored!


That's what I would do considering the 1 seed gets 3 more home games than the 5 seed if all goes as it should. Anyway, I think make points scored against the tied teams would be a good suggestion.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ojete
Originally posted by kalkmanc

Originally posted by Duris


Rules say:

-----a. If there are only 2 teams, it's just based upon the head-to-head matchup
-----b. If there are more than 2 teams, then it's based upon these factor in this order:
1. # of head-to-head wins against the other teams with the same record
2. # of points scored
3. # of points allowed.

Question is, what points are we talking about in #2 and #3. We talking about points the tied teams have in commen, or total points for the year? If it is total points tied teams have in commen, then!

DD 13-3, W against GB and EB. L against ZL. Points scored 95, allowed 56.
GB 13-3, W against ZL and EB. L against DD. Points scored 82, allowed 85.
EB 13-3, W against ZL. L against DD and GB. Points scored 62, allowed 79.
ZL 13-3, W against DD. L against GB and EB. Points scored 78, allowed 97.

Since the order is Ghana Buffalos (GB), Doinitin Djibouti (DD), EEORG Bastards (EB) and Zanzibar Leopards (ZL), it would seem that both GB and DD would switch and so would EB and ZL. Even if I only look at the W points scored, DD is ahead of GB by 74 to 72. So, unless Bort has changed something without posting it; I can find no way that GB should be ahead of DD based on the two wins or the one lose looking at these 3 criteria only.

If it's total points for the year, then I'm not sure because I can't quickly find that info this morning.

This needs to be addressed and corrected before the sims run!


… … … … … … … …,--~~~--,
… … … … … … … .,/:::____:::\
… … … … … … … .|ŻŻ::::::::ŻŻ|.........Chugga Chugga Chugga, GTFO of the way
… … … … … … … .|:::::::::::::::|… ...___
… … … … … ____... \:::::::::::::/...,-“. . . .”-,… … ,,--~~-,,____,,--~~~~--,,__
… … … … ..,/. .\::::Ż\,.\::::::::::/…/. . . . . . .\... .,-“. . . . . .”-,::::::::::_,,-“--,,_::: ŻŻ”~,,_
… … … … ..|. . ‘|:::::::|..\:::::::/… |. . . . . . . .|… |. . . . . . . . |:::::,,-“...|:::::::|’|”~-,,____”~,_
… … … … .,-“~”,---~~”----“----“----~“-,__. . . . '|_,-“~~~--,,_,,-“ŻŻŻ”’~~--’--,,,_|:'|/\„„/\,|::::|..ŻŻ
… … … ..,-“::::::::”-,:::::::::::::::::::::::::::”~~---“:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|’|( şoş )|:::|
… … … ./::::::::::::::\::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|:::’-----‘::::|
… … … ‘|:::::::::::::::|::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::|:::::::::::::|
… … … .\::::::::::::::/,_::::::::::::::::::::::::________:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::’|:::::::::::::|
… … ... ..”-,:::::::,-“:::::ŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻ::::::::::::::::ŻŻ”’~~--,,__::::::::::::::::::|:::::::::::::|
… … … … ,”~~”::::::::::::::::,-------,::::::::::::::,,-~~~-,,___,,-~~~-,,~~~~----‘|::::::::::::::|
… … … .._,|::::::::::::::::::::::|::::::::|:::::::::::,-“;_,,--~~’,~,’~~~~;;;;’\_-----_,/’---------,-----‘
… … …,-“::\,__:::::::::::,-~~’,::::::::’~~-,:_,,”~”;;;;;;;;;;;\: /;;;;;;;;;;;;;;'\:ŻŻ::|;;;;;;;;;;;;|
… … …|,,~”Ż…Ż”~-,:::|:::::::|::::::::::::::|__’|;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;'|,|;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;|--~~|;;;;;;;;;;;;|
… .,,~”Ż…………….’\,”-,,__/______,-“… .\;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;/..\;;;;;;;;;;;;;;/---~~’\”’ŻŻŻŻ,/
…_”____,,,,---,~~_~,~”;;;’\___/;;;;;;;\... … .”-,;;;;;;;;,-“… .”-,,___,-“… … ..”~---~”
… … … .”~-~”… .. Ż\,__,/’… .’\,__,/’… … …”~--~”


That train seems to be going backwards...

I thought they go both ways
 
Nomad_Hokie
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't want to play us either,
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
FEAR DD


 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.