User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Cover 3 Defense is Broken in the 3-3-5
islander1
offline
Link
 
I've now tried all 4 linebacker shifts in the 3-3-5, Cover 3 shell. Not a single one puts anyone (LB or SS) on the WR2 in short coverage.

See plays below:

1) Strongside shift
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=144993&pbp_id=9154373

2) Center Shift
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=197020&pbp_id=8851862

note: looks a lot like the strongside shift, doesn't it. No typos in my testing, Bort can test this himself.

3) Weak Shift
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=197020&pbp_id=8853186

4) Basic Shift (used 'basic settings', just for giggles)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=197020&pbp_id=8848688

In all instances, no one goes to cover the WR2 short.

Now, compare this to the 4-2-5 C3, and you'll see the WR2 short is covered - by either the SS or an LB.

Examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195296&pbp_id=5459062

and

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195296&pbp_id=5459014


I'd have hoped that one of the things was going to happen:

weak shift --> the ROLB goes to short coverage on the WR1, the SS cycles down to short coverage on the WR2

strong shift --> The opposite. the LOLB slides out for short man coverage on the WR2, and the SS stays over where he is now, covering the WR1 in short man coverage.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 14:04:47
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
...
Now, compare this to the 4-2-5 C3, and you'll see the WR2 short is covered - by either the SS or an LB.

Examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195296&pbp_id=5459062

and

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195296&pbp_id=5459014

...


You show plays when the HB stays to block. Search for the ones the HB goes on a pass route!

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by islander1

...
Now, compare this to the 4-2-5 C3, and you'll see the WR2 short is covered - by either the SS or an LB.

Examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195296&pbp_id=5459062

and

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195296&pbp_id=5459014

...


You show plays when the HB stays to block. Search for the ones the HB goes on a pass route!



Oh, I know. There's a reason I don't use the 4-2-5. Either the HB or TE is uncovered. This would be why I tried out the 3-3-5. Because that would settle that.

Let's use a strongside shift C3 3-3-5 as an example:

1 LB for the WR2 shallow coverage (your choice of who, it really doesnt matter to me)
1 LB for the TE
1 LB for the HB

except it doesn't happen as I feel it should (I'm not a college DC or anything, I'm working with common sense as the match engine assigns defensive responsibilities to offensive threats in the man-to-man environment).

If you look at some plays with the 3-3-5 cover 3, not only is the WR2 uncovered but the leftover LB (the ROLB) just paths off aimlessly into the secondary on every passing play.

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
...

Let's use a strongside shift C3 3-3-5 as an example:

1 LB for the WR2 shallow coverage (your choice of who, it really doesnt matter to me)
1 LB for the TE
1 LB for the HB

except it doesn't happen as I feel it should (I'm not a college DC or anything, I'm working with common sense as the match engine assigns defensive responsibilities to offensive threats in the man-to-man environment).

If you look at some plays with the 3-3-5 cover 3, not only is the WR2 uncovered but the leftover LB (the ROLB) just paths off aimlessly into the secondary on every passing play.



That's why I only quoted parts of your OP to disagree with.



Your right about the rest though. 3 guys playing 3 deep zones and 3 guys playing at the line just leaves 5 guys to cover 5 receivers - even on man coverage underneath. But I've never tried a 3-3-5 cover 3 either.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Well don't waste your time, because it's busted

The ROLB does absolutely nothing in the play set. I was trying to augment my deep pass defense. Running double teams don't seem to work, as both CB's typically fall for the same move. It's dumb.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Firstly the shifts work as far as initial starting placement, just compare the MLB starting position in each play linked to see the difference.

As for the Cover 3 being broken, well, most people assume that the Cover 3 includes a LB/DB taking the underneath coverage on a WR (As the SS is doing in your play links) on both sides of the field.

It doesnt.

Against 2 WRs it will be set up like that most often.

However as soon as there is an additional WR in the package, one of the LB/DBs that are usually out on the underneath cover on WR2 moves over to man up on the slot reciever, Not one of the LBs.

In the 335, you cannot expect one of the LBs to split out to replace the CB that has moved across to cover the Slot.

It is an illogical input request, you simply cannot use Cover 3 with a 335 Man Under and expect double coverage on both sides and the slot to be covered.

The AI is running what was requested, but the request is not logical.

If you restrict the Cover 3 335 to Vs 2WR only, you should see the effects you were looking for.



Last edited Oct 20, 2008 19:35:50
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Mike, what does the ROLB exactly do?

Additional coverage on the slot receiver (double coverage + deep coverage by a CB)? Additional coverage on the HB (like the MLB)?

Since the SS and the additional CB are already moved over to the weakside WRs, the ROLB is without coverage assignment i.m.h.o.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 

< Removed to not give away gameplans >
Last edited Oct 21, 2008 00:38:05
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Firstly the shifts work as far as initial starting placement, just compare the MLB starting position in each play linked to see the difference.

As for the Cover 3 being broken, well, most people assume that the Cover 3 includes a LB/DB taking the underneath coverage on a WR (As the SS is doing in your play links) on both sides of the field.

It doesnt.

Against 2 WRs it will be set up like that most often.

However as soon as there is an additional WR in the package, one of the LB/DBs that are usually out on the underneath cover on WR2 moves over to man up on the slot reciever, Not one of the LBs.

In the 335, you cannot expect one of the LBs to split out to replace the CB that has moved across to cover the Slot.

It is an illogical input request, you simply cannot use Cover 3 with a 335 Man Under and expect double coverage on both sides and the slot to be covered.

The AI is running what was requested, but the request is not logical.

If you restrict the Cover 3 335 to Vs 2WR only, you should see the effects you were looking for.





Mike, if my request isn't logical, why does it happen in the 4-2-5 cover 3?

I'm not arguing, I'm simply stating it works for a 4 man defensive line, but not a 3 man?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Replied to your PM
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Replied to your PM


Yep, and with that, I think this thread can be closed/locked. At least insofar as the bug portion is concerned.

Going to try a 3-2-6 tomorrow morning and see what happens. Hopefully what I expect.

Thanks for setting me straight, Mike!
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 21:48:25
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.