A Constructive Thread for people who want to fix the little glitches in play design that lead to exploit builds gaining excessive Sacks per game.
Please post any thing you think is wrong with current pass protection, try to include clear examples, and suggestions for a fix.
I'll update this post with the info periodically.
Here are some Issues raised in here (and in another thread that went off topic...)
1) OT SAs are ineffective because they are not able to engage blocks on DEs, due to the way the game is coded, allowing no contact between OT and DE.
2) OTs being forced to take a step back even when the DE is heading inside right away creating 'gimme sacks'.
3) OGs heading inside to triple team creating a inside path to the QB for the DE.
4) HB/FB not reading reacting to the DE but heading to triple team NT/DT. (Should be coded to read Outside in not inside out)
5) Weak DEs not suffering in the run game.
6) Too difficult to get pancakes in passing game. (According to Bort himself)
7) RGs heading all the way across the field to pick up a blitzing Weakside CB. (Indicating Zones of responsibility are far too large.)
Here are some Possible Solutions...
Originally posted by Deathblade
In pass blocking, the linemen make a "shell", or more commonly called, the pocket. Generally, they cover areas, and help out, or bump out of their area when needed. Granted, it isn't always that clean cut, but there really isn't any "blocking" assignments, it is more like zone defense instead of man to man.
Is the problem that the Pocket is not correctly designed?
Are OLs in man assignments instead of the 'zone' which is described here?
Given the way RG reacts on this play, it is possible:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=139457&pbp_id=8760549
Here is a suggested example of how it should look with zones marked: http://i288.photobucket.com/albums/ll164/mikeerogers/PassProtectPocket.jpg
Originally posted by
Possibility of keeping the HB/FB/TE in on pass plays, set via tactics screen.
Maybe even have this as a 'AutoAdjust' feature where the following logic is followed...
If sacks+hurries = [x] in [z] plays, then keep HB/FB/TE in to block?
Where x and z are set by the user, and who stays in set by the play design.
Borts Comments
Originally posted by Bort
Some of the things you're seeing might have to do with the fact that if a player is set to "block" for his assignment, he will always look for a target to block, and not "stay home."
Pass blocking works in zones like Mike described, but if there are no threats within a player's zone, he will end up looking outside his zone to find one, using his vision to find somebody who is trying to tackle the QB to block.
I could change that method and make them ignore players outside their zone, but you might end up with even more sacks and players standing around doing nothing. I guess I can play around with it and see...
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
This timing thing seems to be the key here to an easy answer...
If the HB/FB assignments are working correctly then test holding them steady them for a second or two and see how that looks.
Then add a short pause for the OGs as well and see how strong the Pass Protection is then.
I'll try playing around with the delay thing.
I think maybe the pocket "radius" could be a little smaller, too, now that I look at it. Smaller gaps = less ground to cover for the blockers when a defenders makes a move towards one of them.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Painmaker
Why do the offensive linemen (as well as supporting blockers such as FB or TE) each make their decisions as individuals in a vacuum? Blocking is a team function in the team sport that is football.
Is there any way you could implement communication between blockers on their assignments, or the fact that a FB should be able to recognize or predict which assignment the C and LG are going to be picking up so he attacks a 3rd rusher? Such "communication" could even vary in quality depending on each player's Vision and the C's Line General SA. Assignments could then be determined from inside-out. For even better simulation, high-Vision QBs could make presnap reads and alter their check-down order when they see more rushers than blockers.
They actually all do "know" who everyone is blocking and who is heading where even if they block's not engaged. It makes checks based on that to see who need help or which players are unblocked, etc. If they had no clue, they'd all calculate one guy as the highest risk and 5-on-1 him every play.
Please post any thing you think is wrong with current pass protection, try to include clear examples, and suggestions for a fix.
I'll update this post with the info periodically.
Here are some Issues raised in here (and in another thread that went off topic...)
1) OT SAs are ineffective because they are not able to engage blocks on DEs, due to the way the game is coded, allowing no contact between OT and DE.
2) OTs being forced to take a step back even when the DE is heading inside right away creating 'gimme sacks'.
3) OGs heading inside to triple team creating a inside path to the QB for the DE.
4) HB/FB not reading reacting to the DE but heading to triple team NT/DT. (Should be coded to read Outside in not inside out)
5) Weak DEs not suffering in the run game.
6) Too difficult to get pancakes in passing game. (According to Bort himself)
7) RGs heading all the way across the field to pick up a blitzing Weakside CB. (Indicating Zones of responsibility are far too large.)
Here are some Possible Solutions...
Originally posted by Deathblade
In pass blocking, the linemen make a "shell", or more commonly called, the pocket. Generally, they cover areas, and help out, or bump out of their area when needed. Granted, it isn't always that clean cut, but there really isn't any "blocking" assignments, it is more like zone defense instead of man to man.
Is the problem that the Pocket is not correctly designed?
Are OLs in man assignments instead of the 'zone' which is described here?
Given the way RG reacts on this play, it is possible:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=139457&pbp_id=8760549
Here is a suggested example of how it should look with zones marked: http://i288.photobucket.com/albums/ll164/mikeerogers/PassProtectPocket.jpg
Originally posted by
Possibility of keeping the HB/FB/TE in on pass plays, set via tactics screen.
Maybe even have this as a 'AutoAdjust' feature where the following logic is followed...
If sacks+hurries = [x] in [z] plays, then keep HB/FB/TE in to block?
Where x and z are set by the user, and who stays in set by the play design.
Borts Comments
Originally posted by Bort
Some of the things you're seeing might have to do with the fact that if a player is set to "block" for his assignment, he will always look for a target to block, and not "stay home."
Pass blocking works in zones like Mike described, but if there are no threats within a player's zone, he will end up looking outside his zone to find one, using his vision to find somebody who is trying to tackle the QB to block.
I could change that method and make them ignore players outside their zone, but you might end up with even more sacks and players standing around doing nothing. I guess I can play around with it and see...
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
This timing thing seems to be the key here to an easy answer...
If the HB/FB assignments are working correctly then test holding them steady them for a second or two and see how that looks.
Then add a short pause for the OGs as well and see how strong the Pass Protection is then.
I'll try playing around with the delay thing.
I think maybe the pocket "radius" could be a little smaller, too, now that I look at it. Smaller gaps = less ground to cover for the blockers when a defenders makes a move towards one of them.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Painmaker
Why do the offensive linemen (as well as supporting blockers such as FB or TE) each make their decisions as individuals in a vacuum? Blocking is a team function in the team sport that is football.
Is there any way you could implement communication between blockers on their assignments, or the fact that a FB should be able to recognize or predict which assignment the C and LG are going to be picking up so he attacks a 3rd rusher? Such "communication" could even vary in quality depending on each player's Vision and the C's Line General SA. Assignments could then be determined from inside-out. For even better simulation, high-Vision QBs could make presnap reads and alter their check-down order when they see more rushers than blockers.
They actually all do "know" who everyone is blocking and who is heading where even if they block's not engaged. It makes checks based on that to see who need help or which players are unblocked, etc. If they had no clue, they'd all calculate one guy as the highest risk and 5-on-1 him every play.

Last edited Oct 20, 2008 09:03:51





























