User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Evanrude
offline
Link
 
Originally posted in the newbie forum. I haven't found rational reasons for these:

Scenario: blitzing LILB from the 3-4, Cover 2, underneath zone, the coverage LB's do not account for the LILB blitzing. They don't divide the coverage field into thirds, but keep it as quarters. Please review the following example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=178077&pbp_id=7722053

The LOLB knows that the LCB has coverage, with a SS in deep- why did he go and double cover the receiver?

Perhaps it's just my thinking- but I have many plays with similar actions. Is it a GLB LB thing, or is my thinking flawed?

In this play,
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=178077&pbp_id=7722157
the RILB ends up way the hell over on the left side of the field, covering the WR with 2 other defenders, instead of staying home. Granted it's man, cover-2, but the RILB should blitz if his man isn't in a rout? No? And if his man is in route, why is it not the HB (evidently covered by the LILB?) or the FB, who ends up blocking here- which begs to question why de did not blitz. To wit:

Originally posted by
Underneath Coverage - The Underneath Coverage setting is going to do one of two things. If you set it towards Man to Man, your LBs will lineup against who they are covering. If this happens to be a HB or FB they will start behind the D-line and immediately move to where the HB/FB runs to. If a LB is playing man to man against a HB who ends up blocking, the LB will simply blitz. The Zone setting will force your LBs to back pedal upon the snap. They will then proceed to pickup and cover any receiver in their respective area.

http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Developing_a_Successful_Defensive_AI

Any insight is appreciated.

Thanks-

Evan
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 20:43:29
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Nice post (Its a rare occurance in the Bugs forum so I feel the need to congratulate you )

Yep GLB is not working as you would expect a real life defense to do.

When using the advanced AI keep in mind that the Sim is not robust enough to make free form assumptions for you.

You say 34 it does 34.
you say zone, it does zone.

you say blitz, it will blitz.

However it doesnt then realise that you need to change the Zone assignments, and move from under 4 to Under 3 Zone.

If you blitz a LB out of zone, be aware that for now at least, his zone will be empty.

Needs fixing, but also needs to be made more public knowledge.

With a little expeimentation, you can 'account' for these gaps in zone coverage to a certain extent.

and that part about a LB Blitzing if the HB stays in is a misconception, or a over simplification.

The LB will simply try to get close to the HB in question, and as he is next to the QB it appears the LB is blitzing.

If the LB somehow manages to get through the OLine (He wont) and the QB still has the ball he goes into tackle mode.

And finally, know that in Man Under in GLB, LBs follow their Back across the opposite side of the field instead of allowing a strong/weak read to occur.
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 20:32:24
 
Evanrude
offline
Link
 
*Bows to the smarter man*

Thanks, Mike, for your insight- I do appreciate it.

Does this relegate me to use *cough* cover 1 when I try to blitz a LB, under-3 zone?

Pains me to say it.

But thanks again-

Evan
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
There are various schools of thought on that subject

If you stick to Blitzing the WILB from zone Under then your usually ok, about 7/10 times.
Of course thats not really a great help!

Using Cover 1 does give you more security inside, but it kinda leaves the CBs exposed, a lot. Not too mention it relegates the FS to a spectator!

Play around with the Shifts, who you blitz, and from what starting points etc.

Eventually you'll find one that pinches the LB zones and with semi decent builds, you get the effect your looking for, but its hard work and very time consuming to find them all.

Last edited Oct 16, 2008 21:03:32
 
Evanrude
offline
Link
 
Again, thanks Mike.

Sounds kinda like the 3-4 pooched, as far as I'm concerned.

Pint's on me.

Evan

 
artec
offline
Link
 
I have yet to see the 3-4 We tired it and it just did not work. So we went back to the 4-3
 
Link
 
Good post, definitely something that deserves to be looked at. I also had a problem here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=166161&pbp_id=8134679

Not the 3-4, rather another coverage issue out of the 3-3-5. Blitzing 5 guys with a Cover 1 shell should leave enough defenders to man up on each eligible receiver. Instead of this happening however, the SS and LOLB decide to double cover the TE and leave the HB wide open. Is this another bug or a user mistake? Thanks.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Bit of both really.

You would expect the LB to hand off the TE to the SS when he sees the HB leave the backfield, but it just doesnt happen.

But the sim doesnt make assumptions well at all.

It is doing exactly what you asked of it, so its not broken or buggy, its just that what its doing doesnt always fit Football Logic exactly.

However you can send an extra man from the Cover 1 without leaving the HB open, you just need to experiment to find out who.

Oh and the 34 defense is very effective when used correctly, with players built to implement it.
 
Evanrude
offline
Link
 
Trial by fire tends to be painful...

Perhaps some coding dividing the field by halves/thirds/quarters depending on the under-coverage. It seems that there should be a way to code the AI LB's to be a little more intuitive (doubling-up on a WR, leaving zone of responsibility, for instance).

But then, I don't code for a living...
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.