I'm afraid it's likely your D is set up all wrong bro. There are some good resources to help you out though.
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Plays_Redirect (click on plays by formation - direct link creates a smiley) shows the 10 possible offensive formation in GLB. By right your defense should either deal with these 10 formations individually or with some sort of coherent groupings. There are a few reasons for this, but the most compelling is that quite a few formations have a very limited playset which allows for pretty specific and favourable matchups.
Also,
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Developing_a_Successful_Defensive_AI has been recently updated and was excellent even before that in helping out beginners.
I don't think I need to really go on as the wiki itself is very intuitive and it's easy to find what you need. You're nowhere near my division so I wouldn't mind transferring the basic AI (only 16 inputs I believe) I use for my smallies team that would give you a good idea of how an AI built this way is meant to work and show you how it has to fit together in terms of input sequencing and so on.
Either way it's a lot of hard work to get the little circles to do something approaching what you want but in terms of results it is definitely worth it.