User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Post how Top Performers are Determined
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
This is a weird suggestion...since it is more of a question. How are top performers decided, exactly? I see a disproportionate amount of defensive players make the list every game. Is it a some sort of scoring formula similar to fantasy football? I don't see why this is not posted. It is not like it would be giving away uber important information. I am just curious.

If this has been posted, please provide the link. Thanks.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Top player threats: the offensive line!

(EDIT: and kicker and punter)
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 12:17:00
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Top player threats: the offensive line!


NO!

He wants TOP PERFORMERS.

The 5 players on the box score screen.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Bort once said he was considering changing top player threats so that top performers (season-wise) would be up there.

Still, I am just curious about the top peformers. Top player threats is a dead horse.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Top performers: the kicker! (10/10 XP)
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I've seen a few games which ought not to have any.

I'd say whoever was responsible for the most points (2), yards from scrimmage (2), or turnovers/tackles (1).

Or maybe have 2 offense, 2 defense, and 1 extra, e.g. yards from scrimmage leader, scoring leader, tackles leader, turnovers/sacks leader, and whoever is left.

Since it's a sim it's got to be some sort of formula, right?
 
LulzDot
offline
Link
 
Right now after looking at every single player on our team I can say with some certainty that the top "player" or "performer" right now is whoever has the highest ranking on paper. Since it is relatively easy to get linemen up since their are fewer skills that they have to level up.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lonewolfpg
Right now after looking at every single player on our team I can say with some certainty that the top "player" or "performer" right now is whoever has the highest ranking on paper. Since it is relatively easy to get linemen up since their are fewer skills that they have to level up.


Read this:

Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by dmfa41

Top player threats: the offensive line!


NO!

He wants TOP PERFORMERS.

The 5 players on the box score screen.


 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
'sup Greg? Yeah, I blew that, my bad.

I'd suggest an algorithm similar to the ones fantasy football leagues use for points:
- Offense: Yards/10 + points scored with deductions for things like fumbles, INTs
- O-Lineman: 1.5*Pancakes
- Tackles + 3*FF-FR + 4*INTs + points for defense

It would be nice to know, and with the algorithm, reward top performers as such, e.g. game ball in the form of a bonus token, shopping token, attribute bonus in next game, et cetera.

That being said, a HB who runs for 120 yards and 2 touchdowns would equal a G with 16 pancakes and a FS with 14 tackles, FF, FR, and INT. You could add a coefficient to adjust it to the relative scales of an outstanding game between those three groups.

(EDIT: add pancakes for linemen)
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 12:46:59
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
I haven't done the research on your games, but I looked at just my last 5 and here is how top performers broke down:

QB 4 times
HB 10 times
WR 4 times
LB 4 times (same guy all 4)
CB 2 times
SS 1 time

My experience, I see more offense. Then again, just my team, only last 5 games.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I'd say whoever was responsible for the most points (2), yards from scrimmage (2), or turnovers/tackles (1).

Or maybe have 2 offense, 2 defense, and 1 extra, e.g. yards from scrimmage leader, scoring leader, tackles leader, turnovers/sacks leader, and whoever is left.

Originally posted by dmfa41
You could add a coefficient to adjust it to the relative scales of an outstanding game between those three groups.


I think we're on the same page.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Algorithms and coefficients, nice. Way to keep me inter.......zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I feel ya. The title is "Post how Top Performers are Determined," and it's a computer simulation, so...exciting, I know. I don't know how in the world people study this stuff.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
You had me here:

Originally posted by dmfa41
'sup Greg? Yeah, I blew that, my bad.

I'd suggest an algorithm similar to the ones fantasy football leagues use for points:
- Offense: Yards/10 + points scored with deductions for things like fumbles, INTs
- O-Lineman: 1.5*Pancakes
- Tackles + 3*FF-FR + 4*INTs + points for defense


Then you lost me with all of the intelligent stuff. Dumb it down for the rest of us, huh?
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Think fantasy football points.

OK. It's fairly common to have a RB go for 120 yards and 2 touchdowns, which would be 24 points in that formula.

That would mean an OL would have to have 16 pancakes to equal it using that formula. We had a few guys get above 10 in college (that was one of our weekly objectives, 50/game) on occasion, but it was pretty rare.

Also, using that formula, a defensive player would need 24 tackles (I've seen 21), or 13 tackles, 1 FR, and 2 INTs, or some insane amount like that. So let's just say a CB gets 5 tackles and 2 INTs - a pretty damn good day.

So you could change how much FF/FR/INTs are worth or add a multiplier of 1.5 or so to the defense's total score to elevate what would be considered a badass defensive game to the same numerical value as a badass offensive game.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.