User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
1freebird
offline
Link
 
Ok this is a very rudimentary ranking. I just put in the raw numbers based on each aspect of the Defense as reported by GLB. Each team got a number 1 - 32 depending on the STATS pages. MsTkl I went backwards from bottom to top as fewer MsTlks in my opinion should hold more weight.

Anyway enjoy yourself ripping it apart if you feel the need.


Team
1 … Bacolod Skullcrushers
2 … Phnom Penh Kung Fu Panda
3 … Gobi Desert Wolves
4 … Bangkok Black Knights
5 … Danang Screaming Gulls
6 … Batdambang Killer Koalas
7 … Mt. Diablo Mudskippers
8 … Davao City Pirates
9 … Cebu Roaring Tigers
10 … Tokyo Kamikaze
11 … Chengdu Dragons
12 … Singapore Grifters
13 … Bogor Lions
14 … Hellas Hokies
15 … Pekin Dragons
16 … Seoul Power
Team
1 … Shaolin Zen Masters CPU
2 … Jakarta Cobras
3 … Baltimore Beatdown
4 … Bangkok Bulldozers
5 … Shanghai Knights
6 … West Indies Warriors
7 … Malaysia White Tigers
8 … Scranton Regional Managers
9 … Padang Orangutans
10 … Bangalore Monsoon
11 … Hobo Jaw Fightin' Mooses
12 … Springfield Ghostriders
13 … D League Ligers
14 … Bayside Shakedown
15 … Haiphong Scorpions
16 … Deimon Devil Bats
 
Punker2p2
offline
Link
 
I appreciate the effort, and I'm curious to know what formula you used. Some of the results that look a bit odd to me -

Bangkok seems pretty high as #4. They're giving up 30.1 points per game (#10 in the conference)? West Indies is giving up 10.5 ppg (#2 in the conference)...seems deserving of a higher ranking than #6.

 
6Kings
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punker2p2
I appreciate the effort, and I'm curious to know what formula you used. Some of the results that look a bit odd to me -

Bangkok seems pretty high as #4. They're giving up 30.1 points per game (#10 in the conference)? West Indies is giving up 10.5 ppg (#2 in the conference)...seems deserving of a higher ranking than #6.



To lazy to look, but Bangkok may have given up many points on offensive TO's or special team returns, West Indies may be blowing teams out by such a large margin that they may be giving up big passing yards late in games. Just like in the NFL, a top run defense may give up plenty of yards through the air because teams will not even bother to run against them, often times skews the overall dominance of a defense.

Great work freebird!
 
1freebird
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punker2p2
I appreciate the effort, and I'm curious to know what formula you used. Some of the results that look a bit odd to me -

Bangkok seems pretty high as #4. They're giving up 30.1 points per game (#10 in the conference)? West Indies is giving up 10.5 ppg (#2 in the conference)...seems deserving of a higher ranking than #6.



I sorted each stat page putting the best stat on top and numbering them 1 to 32 as I stated before. Then I added up across the columns to get a total for the 11 games so far.

Here is an example

Bangkok Scored these numbers for their Defensive efforts.

Conf..Player................G...Tk..MsTk..Hurry..Sack..SackYd..PD..Int..Int-Ret-Yds..Int-Ret-TD..FFum..Fum-Rec..Fum-Ret-Yds..Fum-Ret-TD..Sfty-DT...RDT..PDT..TOT

Zeta..Bangkok Bulldozers....11..6...23..1...14..17..13..17..18..16..2...3...4...4...10...148..32..64..22


While West Indies scored this for their Defensive efforts.

Zeta..West Indies Warriors..11..23..2...3...7...7...1...2...1...1...28..20..13..18..32..158..17..5..50

So even though WIW have the better record with the better offense. Bangkok has a decent Defense that can make plays.

I would say kind of like Baltimore, Their O is hurting right now, But their D is still top notch. ( and I am not a Ravens Fan by any stretch of the word)

DT = Total Defensive score
Bangkok = 148
West Indies = 158

RDT = Running Defense Total score

Bangkok = 32
West Indies = 17

PDT = Passing Defense Total score

Bangkok = 64
West Indies = 5

TOT = TurnOver Total score

Bangkok = 22
West Indies = 50

So looking at the entire picture Mathematically Bangkok is higher due to the Turn Over Ratio at this point. The way I am doing it may still be flawed do to the Takles being so skewed with some defenses on the filed more then others. I may play with that somewhat and see if I can come up with a better calculation system.

I will post the Breakdown of ranking for Passing, Rushing and Turnovers. Maybe with out the Tackles and Miss Tackle Numbers it will look more realistic.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 15:38:20
 
1freebird
offline
Link
 
Numbers just not right, will work on it more
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 15:39:30
 
Punker2p2
offline
Link
 
I do appreciate the effort, and I'm not trying to slag on you - just want to give my opinion.

I would say that some stats should be weighted much more heavily than others - TDs allowed, points per game allowed, yards allowed rushing, yards allowed passing, etc. Things like tackles are mega dependent on the team situation rather than the actual quality of your defense.
 
bigtony2tone
offline
Link
 
I think you could just put up rankings for rush defense, pass defense, total defense(yards). Stats like points allowed, sacks/hurries, turnovers, and the like should weigh heavily whereas tackles doesn't really matter at all. Great effort though. I've been contemplating doing something similar, but just can't get myself to do it.
 
1freebird
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punker2p2
I do appreciate the effort, and I'm not trying to slag on you - just want to give my opinion.

I would say that some stats should be weighted much more heavily than others - TDs allowed, points per game allowed, yards allowed rushing, yards allowed passing, etc. Things like tackles are mega dependent on the team situation rather than the actual quality of your defense.


No offense taken, it is good to have others interested enough to give opinion. I just need to go back and get more numbers and rework it some. Will try to do that in the next couple days.

In the mean time I will just keep posting the Power Rankings and Projection made by Garretfoster and Satchmo-n-Dizzy's.

I am more defensive minded and wanted to show a pure defense rating.

If you like I can send you the spread sheet and we can collaborate on making it better.
 
Gamble0709
offline
Link
 
Whoohoo! GO PANDAS!
 
crazysauer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punker2p2
I appreciate the effort, and I'm curious to know what formula you used. Some of the results that look a bit odd to me -

Bangkok seems pretty high as #4. They're giving up 30.1 points per game (#10 in the conference)? West Indies is giving up 10.5 ppg (#2 in the conference)...seems deserving of a higher ranking than #6.



We're also just reaching the easiest part of our schedule, so a lot of teams may have already gotten their walkthrough games out of the way. We've only allowed 10 points in our last three games. Our defense boasts the number 1 league leader in sacks, and out corners play shut down D for the most part (big lack of interceptions for some reason) and often don't get thrown to (in my opinion).

Im not saying we're a top tier team, but we DID upset the number one seed in last years playoffs in a grinding defensive slugfest. And I think you for putting the rankings together Freebird and sparking some good football conversation.
 
BlackSamurai
offline
Link
 
My guy (Jon Jon'zz) is the heart and soul of the Black Knights defense! Seriously, if you took Ray Lewis and multiplied him by 3 you'd have the beginnings of an idea of how JJ afects the morale of the day on one of his bad day.
 
1freebird
offline
Link
 
Changed from what I was trying to create to just extracting the Defense ratings from the power rankings and sorting that by top to bottom per Conference. Why re-invent the wheel when I can just cut and past the spare tire LOL.

 
Punker2p2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazysauer

Our defense boasts the number 1 league leader in sacks, and out corners play shut down D for the most part (big lack of interceptions for some reason) and often don't get thrown to (in my opinion).


I mean Bangkok Bulldozers, not Bangkok Black Knights. Sorry for not clarifying.
 
j44j92
offline
Link
 
Yea coming from the owner of Bangkok Bulldozers i really think that there are some numbers skewed in there somewhere, Our defense plays fine against lower level teams but against equal level or better it seems like there giving up 40ppg.
I also dont think tackles should really even be apart of the rankings at all because a good defense that gets you 3 and out almost every time isnt going to have near the tackles of a worse defense will, or say you have a good offense that just keeps the defense off the field.
 
crazysauer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punker2p2
Originally posted by crazysauer


Our defense boasts the number 1 league leader in sacks, and out corners play shut down D for the most part (big lack of interceptions for some reason) and often don't get thrown to (in my opinion).


I mean Bangkok Bulldozers, not Bangkok Black Knights. Sorry for not clarifying.


Haha, what are the odds both Bangkok teams were ranked 4th in their respective conferences...
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.