User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
meathead013
offline
Link
 
this situation came up in a scrimmage yesterday

Play: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=195126&pbp_id=6530833

Situation: Qtr 1, 11:52 4th & 3 on OPP 35

Result: Trent Meatwards pass to JoJo Jenkins up the left side (6.5 yd gain) [tackle: Star Jones]

OAI Input: (for All Quarters - there are no separate Qtr 1 Inputs)

Name: 4th&2.5-4 O40-30 GoFor
Descr: Standard 2.5-4 yd goforit >=Opp40 +Outside FG Range
Qtr: All
Down: 4
Distance : 2.5-4
Spot: O40-O30
Special: Outside FG Range
Play: [play details withheld but one option is obviously a short pass]

Max FG Range: 52

AI Tester Settings:

Quarter: First
Time Remaining: 712 seconds
Ball Spot: Opponents 35
Down: Fourth
Yards to go: 3
Score: I'm trailing by 0

AI Tester Results:

Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal (field_goal)

Unmatched Inputs
...
Input Named: 4th&2.5-4 O40-30 GoFor
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? No

Analysis:

- mentally following the logic of the OAI Input the play called should have been a FG because 35LOS + 17longsnap = 52 yd FG (matches K max)

- the OAI Tester confirms this by indicating the play called should have been FG attempt

- and yet the actual play ran was a short pass
Last edited Oct 11, 2008 10:13:37
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Due to rounding it's possible the actual spot of the ball was just outside 35 yds. If that's true, that wouldn't trigger the FG attempt because the AI is probably based on "Absolute 52" not the "Approximated 52" yard field goal due to the spot of the ball.
Last edited Oct 11, 2008 10:15:02
 
meathead013
offline
Link
 
i always assumed everything was fixed at 0.5 increments so that would certainly explain it
 
meathead013
offline
Link
 
typical disclaimer: tyvm for your reply, that sounds reasonable. but you know this game - can anyone else confirm?
 
Link
 
I always thought 6.5 yard gain is considered a Medium gain.

0-3 Short
4-6 Medium
7-100 Long

I could be wrong but that is what I thought
 
meathead013
offline
Link
 
i believe that number extends based on the strength of your team and matchups
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
I tend not to use the "Outside FG Range" setting, since it's redundant. I think that's probably where the bug is here. Set up your AI without using that toggle.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.