User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
Hey guys,

I have a new way of doing the rankings, but it doesn't give me an overall, but gives me more rankings. I will post an example once I get the formatting done we can see if you guys like them or not and how to figure an overall ranking.

Example
------------

Rank ….. Prv ….... Offense .............. Defense ........... Special Teams .... Team
................................. O/P/R ................... O/P/R ................ KR/PR/PT/FG
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 21 / 13 / 23 ......... 11 / 06 / 18 ......... 18 / 24 / 13 / 20 .... Asbury Park Rat Pack
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 30 / 32 / 28 ......... 26 / 09 / 28 ......... 22 / 31 / 06 / 03 .... Bangar PEACEING PUNISHINGMENTS
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 19 / 28 / 13 ......... 19 / 26 / 17 ......... 15 / 11 / 16 / 26 .... Beijing Drifters
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 07 / 14 / 10 ......... 07 / 04 / 11 ......... 06 / 03 / 01 / 04 .... Brutal Deluxe
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 17 / 15 / 20 ......... 06 / 03 / 10 ......... 11 / 08 / 22 / 24 .... Burma Black Dragons
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 11 / 03 / 16 ......... 25 / 25 / 13 ......... 23 / 14 / 04 / 01 .... Chiang Mai chiefs
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 10 / 21 / 01 ......... 02 / 08 / 01 ......... 08 / 10 / 23 / 25 .... Georgetown United
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 06 / 17 / 02 ......... 08 / 12 / 07 ......... 17 / 21 / 07 / 10 .... Hakone Heroes
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 24 / 16 / 17 ......... 15 / 07 / 15 ......... 19 / 17 / 02 / 18 .... Hong Kong Triads
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 09 / 01 / 21 ......... 22 / 32 / 19 ......... 16 / 15 / 26 / 07 .... Jakarta Wolves
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 16 / 02 / 24 ......... 29 / 30 / 26 ......... 29 / 32 / 10 / 12 .... Laos Chaos
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 03 / 11 / 04 ......... 01 / 05 / 04 ......... 03 / 06 / 18 / 11 .... Lea Lea Furniture
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 23 / 10 / 25 ......... 30 / 24 / 29 ......... 13 / 26 / 29 / 22 .... Los Angeles Kryptonite
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 08 / 06 / 12 ......... 18 / 23 / 20 ......... 24 / 04 / 27 / 16 .... Maldives Munching Moles
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 20 / 18 / 15 ......... 12 / 11 / 16 ......... 05 / 23 / 20 / 17 .... Manheim Magic
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 12 / 05 / 14 ......... 20 / 21 / 12 ......... 09 / 22 / 21 / 27 .... Manila Gorillas
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 02 / 22 / 05 ......... 10 / 28 / 05 ......... 01 / 02 / 12 / 13 .... Palembang Tigers
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 18 / 12 / 19 ......... 17 / 20 / 23 ......... 20 / 13 / 08 / 14 .... Panay Phoenix
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 28 / 25 / 27 ......... 27 / 18 / 27 ......... 30 / 29 / 09 / 09 .... Phnom Penh Samurai
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 29 / 29 / 30 ......... 28 / 16 / 30 ......... 21 / 25 / 17 / 02 .... Phuket Paupers
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 27 / 20 / 29 ......... 24 / 22 / 25 ......... 31 / 28 / 03 / 15 .... Rancho Cucamonga Killaz
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 31 / 23 / 32 ......... 31 / 31 / 31 ......... 27 / 30 / 31 / 31 .... Seoul Patrol
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 22 / 26 / 18 ......... 14 / 10 / 24 ......... 25 / 12 / 11 / 28 .... Seoul Snatchers
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 05 / 04 / 11 ......... 09 / 17 / 08 ......... 02 / 09 / 24 / 08 .... Shanghai Cheetahs
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 13 / 24 / 06 ......... 04 / 01 / 03 ......... 04 / 27 / 28 / 06 .... Singapore J.B. Lions
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 26 / 27 / 22 ......... 23 / 27 / 22 ......... 26 / 19 / 14 / 23 .... Singapore Stallions
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 15 / 30 / 07 ......... 03 / 02 / 06 ......... 12 / 07 / 15 / 05 .... Subic Bay Admirals
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 01 / 07 / 03 ......... 05 / 13 / 02 ......... 14 / 16 / 25 / 21 .... Sumatra Sting
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 25 / 09 / 26 ......... 16 / 15 / 21 ......... 07 / 18 / 19 / 19 .... Surabaya Poison Dart Frogs
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 14 / 19 / 09 ......... 21 / 29 / 14 ......... 10 / 05 / 30 / 29 .... Taipei Thunder
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 04 / 08 / 08 ......... 13 / 14 / 09 ......... 32 / 01 / 05 / 30 .... Taipei Yonghe soybean milk
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 32 / 31 / 31 ......... 32 / 19 / 32 ......... 28 / 20 / 32 / 32 .... The Zoolander School For Kids Who Can't Read Good
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 11:28:31
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
What do you guys think? Same basic format, just more information.
 
thefloppy1
offline
Link
 
Looks good.
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
How can we use those number to fairly rank teams to get a total overall ranking.

- Average of all ranks? (Lowest avg. = Higher overall rank)
- Average of just overall offense and defense ranks?

Any other ideas?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chiefy27
How can we use those number to fairly rank teams to get a total overall ranking.

- Average of all ranks? (Lowest avg. = Higher overall rank)
- Average of just overall offense and defense ranks?

Any other ideas?


(Offense Overall + 31 / Offense Overall) + (Defense Overall + 31 / Defense Overall) + (ST Overall + 31 / (Defense Overall / 3))


Well, that's really basic..I don't even know how well it would work.



Actually, that's total crap. It gives too big of an advantage on rank 1 vs. rank 2. Need to get the totals closer together with a larger divisor or something.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 16:44:35
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
I was working on the rest of the teams stats and I'm having trouble getting things to work out right. May be a little while before I post the rest of the teams. It may be easier to figure something out once all the teams are in.
 
rutgar
offline
Link
 
If you like, go ahead and post things when you get all the teams and we can hammer away at that.
 
octa62
offline
Link
 
What About:

Rank ..... Prv …… Offense ............ Defense ............ Special Teams ...... Team
................................ L/C/P/R .................. L/C/P/R ................ KR/PR/PT/FG
Alpha
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 21 / 14 / 13 / 23 ......... 11 / 08 / 06 / 18 ......... 18 / 24 / 13 / 20 ..... Asbury Park Rat Pack

L= League Overall
C= Conference Overall
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 00:10:31
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
All teams done now.
 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by chiefy27

How can we use those number to fairly rank teams to get a total overall ranking.

- Average of all ranks? (Lowest avg. = Higher overall rank)
- Average of just overall offense and defense ranks?

Any other ideas?


(Offense Overall + 31 / Offense Overall) + (Defense Overall + 31 / Defense Overall) + (ST Overall + 31 / (Defense Overall / 3))


Well, that's really basic..I don't even know how well it would work.



Actually, that's total crap. It gives too big of an advantage on rank 1 vs. rank 2. Need to get the totals closer together with a larger divisor or something.


Also there is no ST Overall.
 
Bandits
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by octa62
What About:

Rank ..... Prv …… Offense ............ Defense ............ Special Teams ...... Team
................................ L/C/P/R .................. L/C/P/R ................ KR/PR/PT/FG
Alpha
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 21 / 14 / 13 / 23 ......... 11 / 08 / 06 / 18 ......... 18 / 24 / 13 / 20 ..... Asbury Park Rat Pack

L= League Overall
C= Conference Overall


I think we should have a ranking for our own league as well as the conference.

 
chiefy27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bandits
Originally posted by octa62

What About:

Rank ..... Prv …… Offense ............ Defense ............ Special Teams ...... Team
................................ L/C/P/R .................. L/C/P/R ................ KR/PR/PT/FG
Alpha
... 00 ...... N/A ..... 21 / 14 / 13 / 23 ......... 11 / 08 / 06 / 18 ......... 18 / 24 / 13 / 20 ..... Asbury Park Rat Pack

L= League Overall
C= Conference Overall


I think we should have a ranking for our own league as well as the conference.



In my old way of doing the rankings it was split out into conferences and sorted by overall rank giving you both without having to add a column. I will be doing the same thing once we can figure out the best way to come up with a overall ranking.
 
marshks
offline
Link
 
Honestly, it doesn't look to me like these rankings are as accurate as the old ones. I guess I'll wait to see how you do overall, but I felt like the old rankings were pretty much on the money and these look skewed.

For example, no offense to Lea Lea, but this would seem to show them as the best team in the league. While they are very good, I think there are several better teams in the league.
 
rutgar
offline
Link
 
I've tried a couple of different things with the Offensive and Defensive ratings. For example, a normalization....

(total offense - total defense) / (total offense + total defense) where being ranked 1st gives a value of 32 and being ranked 32nd gives a value of 1.

The problem I'm seeing is that without including wins, total offense and total defense numbers don't mean a whole lot. The problem is that the best teams will rack up incredible amounts of yardage against the worst teams and completely shut them down. In those situations, the winner might gain 900 yards and hold the loser to 100 yards.

Even 11 games into the season, I find rankings based solely on these totals to be off because some of the better teams have already played the 3-4 teams they can pad their stats on, while other teams have only played 1 of them. At that point, you're talking about massive differences in total offense in defense that won't normalize until everyone has played everyone.

I believe the old spreadsheet took this into account, at least it looks like it did. 800 yards of advantage against a horrible team doesn't mean nearly as much as 200 yards of advantage against quality opponents.

By somehow getting wins in the mix, a strength of schedule can be determined. Normalizing total offense and total defense by SOS may provide something useful.

I'll play around with it some more tomorrow and see how it goes.
 
marshks
offline
Link
 
In the meantime, I would love to see an update on the old rankings if you get a chance. I like sharing those on our team forum each week...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.