User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Says player is "Unavailable" - But he should be available...
Page:
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
I just signed a player in a trade. My teams games are played on the Even day, day 18. The team he played for ALSO had games on Day 18/Even day.

Today is Day 19, Odd Day. Why is he "Unavailable" in my depth chart when everyone else is available? He isn't gaining anything experience wise from the trade, he's moved from one team that played on even day to another team that plays on even day...


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=259513
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
This doesn't belong in the Bugs folder. People spew crap like this in here, so that real bugs hardly get attention.

It already says, there is a one day off-period travel period for the player, no matter when the game day is.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
This doesn't belong in the Bugs folder. People spew crap like this in here, so that real bugs hardly get attention.

It already says, there is a one day off-period travel period for the player, no matter when the game day is.


this
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
But the game is not until the following day after that, if he will be available for that game, regardless of where he is right now, why can't I add him to the depth chart for that game? Why Do I have to be forced to wait until right before the game to add him to the depth chart, when he should be available for it anyway?

If someone isn't eligible to play in a game then don't include them in any plays, I don't understand why they can't be placed on the depth chart in the mean time.
 
19MC67
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
This doesn't belong in the Bugs folder. People spew crap like this in here, so that real bugs hardly get attention.

It already says, there is a one day off-period travel period for the player, no matter when the game day is.


 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
But the game is not until the following day after that, if he will be available for that game, regardless of where he is right now, why can't I add him to the depth chart for that game? Why Do I have to be forced to wait until right before the game to add him to the depth chart, when he should be available for it anyway?

If someone isn't eligible to play in a game then don't include them in any plays, I don't understand why they can't be placed on the depth chart in the mean time.


This is simply nitpicking now.

Implementing this idea would require more coding then is simply necessary. The current functionality works, end of story.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Nitpicking? How is it nitpicking to want to be able to place a player on the depth chart who will be allowed to play in the game?


Seems like I'm not the only one with this opinion

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1186890
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 09:08:48
 
Skvan
offline
Link
 
Because he is NOT available today. Not for a real game or for a scrimmage. If you were allowed to put him in the DC today and you had a scrimmage today he would play. So the current functionality is exactly how it is supposed to be
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skvan
Because he is NOT available today. Not for a real game or for a scrimmage. If you were allowed to put him in the DC today and you had a scrimmage today he would play.



So change the functionality so that a player who isn't supposed to play does not play, but don't restrict them from being added to the depth chart... It's not a horrific concept.

We have no game today, we have a game tomorrow. I want him to play in that game like he should be able to, and I want to set my lineup today because I work tomorrow. Now I guess I have the option of staying up until 2:01 am and being cranky all day at work or driving 80mph on the way home to make sure I'm back by 5:55 to add him in...

I don't understand the logic behind not being able to add him to the depth chart for a game he will be eligible to play in
 
19MC67
offline
Link
 
OR you could take the 35 seconds it takes to change 1 depth chart setting BEFORE you go to work.
 
rbetesta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XSlugX
OR you could take the 35 seconds it takes to change 1 depth chart setting BEFORE you go to work.


but then he doesnt get to be an attention whore and whine
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Yup you're right, theres nothing wrong here.

I agree, It's completely unreasonable to be able to add someone to the depth chart for a game they will be allowed to play in.

What the fuck was I thinking?

Damn. What an idiot I am, maybe I'll just whine some more.


I guess, like "Retracting Trades" This is yet another example of a feature added as a half-assed way to fix something with a more direct and simple fix, that won't be updated for some unknown reason despite their being virtually no downside, and only an upside to doing it.



If a player is unable to play in a game, then simply do not include him in the simulation for that game, end of story.

I don't understand why sometimes we have to have these half ass fixes that only create just as many or more problems then they solve...
 
19MC67
offline
Link
 
Yeah Bort should rewrite the code so it knows that player X on the depth chart can't play this game instead of you having to wait to place him on the depth chart.

At best its an inconvenience, I have even had to get up 5 mins early to add a player to the depth chart. Its not a bug and it sure as hell isn't worth whining about on the BUG forum.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Don't forget, some games are played at a silly hour of the day and I wouldn't stay up until 3am just to add a player to the depth chart.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by XSlugX

At best its an inconvenience, I have even had to get up 5 mins early to add a player to the depth chart. Its not a bug and it sure as hell isn't worth whining about on the BUG forum.


It is a bug regardless, because my team has no game today, and there is no possibility of them having a game today because scrimmages cannot be arranged on the same day, so there is absolutely nothing he will be unavailable for to begin with.


Originally posted by Welsh76
Don't forget, some games are played at a silly hour of the day and I wouldn't stay up until 3am just to add a player to the depth chart.



Exactly - Do you guys really think I would waste my time here over an issue that will effect me maybe twice ever? What the hell do I really care, I only come on here when there are fundamental flaws in the way something works. There is a fundamental flaw in the retract trade option, and there is a fundamental flaw in this.

Not Working As Intended.

The Intention is to prevent players from playing games they are not eligible to play. The result is potentially preventing players from playing games they ARE eligible to play, because they cannot be added to depth charts despite there being no games that they will be uneligible for, such as my current situation, or the quoted situation where there is no time between rollover and kickoff that the owner can update the depth chart.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.