User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I know it's early, and I didn't worry about it last year since we had a slowbuild team that didn't accomplish much... but I was wondering if we do a league all star team? How is it handled? Owner submits his nominations? All owners only vote for 11 offense, 11 defense, KR, PR, K, P? Who handles it? Is there a league commitee or something? Do we split them up by Alpha and Zeta or combine them?

Any info is helpful.

I suggest owners can't vote for his own nominations.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I read all-conf. threads below. That answers almost all my questions. Do we vote after regular season or playoffs?
 
WolfbattXIX
offline
Link
 
Tough call on if they will even do one this year. Last years was kinda drama filled, and take a little too seriously.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I saw some of that. That's part of the reason I suggested not being able to vote for your own player. You could also limit your nominations per team. And you could either list ALL stats or NONE. And everyone could have a little write up on each player they nominate.

I of course will have to nominate my whole team.
 
lnept
offline
Link
 
thats exactly why no one does it, people nominate there entire team to be noble or whatever.

unless you were being sarcastic, then I retract that.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
I dont think people nominate multiple people on their team to be noble or whatever. I think its because they are placing the best player at that position on their team in the hat. What good is only nominating one player if 3 of your guys are better at their positions than the rest of the league, but they dont get nominated because you can only do one?

Why dont we just make it easy and let the owners nominate 1 player from every position on their team with their stats plus a writeup. Then we can all vote for who we believe was the best at that particular position. Stats dont always tell the story.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
I dont think people nominate multiple people on their team to be noble or whatever. I think its because they are placing the best player at that position on their team in the hat. What good is only nominating one player if 3 of your guys are better at their positions than the rest of the league, but they dont get nominated because you can only do one?

Why dont we just make it easy and let the owners nominate 1 player from every position on their team with their stats plus a writeup. Then we can all vote for who we believe was the best at that particular position. Stats dont always tell the story.


so everyone would pick their starting line up offense defense special teams?
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
No, the players that played the best. Right now our 3rd WR on our team has the most catches and TDs. Our backup ROLB has a fumble recovery for a TD too. Pick 1 O lineman that stood out above the rest on your team, 1 d lineman that stood out above the rest 1 LB and so forth.

Like for my team last season for MVP. My vote went to our backup center becasue of his STs play. He lead our team in tackles, had a couple forced fumbles and recoveries and was second in pancakes.

Doesnt have to be a starter, just players that stand out and why you feel they stand out.

I guess this will never work because you have the people that believe only one player should be nominated but they can have 2398673469 nominations but still lose the vote because another player with 1 nomination has better stats. Then you have other players that put anybody and everybody up for nomination for whatever reasons. Then you have people like me who believe that players that stand out should get nominated, even if its more than one player from the same team.

IMHO, if you're going to force only 1 nomination per team, then once a player has a nomination, they can no longer be nominated because they're already in the pool. Either that or just take out nominations all together and do just strait voting because it defeats the purpose of nominations if everybody nominates the same guy.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I wonder if you could have the nominations private and behind closed doors. That way owners wouldn't feel "required" to nominate all his players... if none of his players could see was picked.

Or nobody is allowed to nominate anyone from their own team. That'd be hard... and mostlikely the players with the highest "dominent" stat would get picked bacause most owners would probably be too lazy to research beyond the numbers... for instance if you look now, there are 2 guys leading in sacks with 8. But if nobody looked further into it, they wouldn't notice one of the guys got all his sacks against the worst team in the league.

There probably is no way to do it without bias, which is too bad because it's a nice little gesture for the players.
 
AlbinoBlind
offline
Link
 
you're supposed to do 3 nominations typically? i think?:

offensive MVP, Defensive MVP, and ST MVP.
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
I WILL BE IN CHARGE OF RECORDING VOTES

If, AND ONLY IF, I can get at least 10/16 owners, per conference, to be in the voting.

I may need a bit of help compiling a list of nominees.

I can organize it, put the list together, PM the owners, and tally the votes.

My thoughts, me and maybe 1 or 2 other GM's/owners would compile a list of eligible people. NO NOMINATIONS, that just does not work.

If people are down for this, tell me you will vote, or a GM of your team will vote. And I also need 1 or 2 people to volunteer to help put the list of players together.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
if its like you say yourself and another compiling a list of eligible people then I'm for it. If we have to resort to nominating our players then not so much...its not that I'm lazy...but people don't need to be nominating people that don't deserve to be on the list.

if its a group of people putting it together it should remove any biased thoughts. and i feel that there wouldn't be any biased picks from their own players, if they're taking the time out to do it right then i believe they would do it right.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 21:36:15
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I don't think I'd take part in a scenario where 2 or 3 or 4 owners only will compile a list.

I think a better scenario would be EVERY owner submits their starting lineup which does NOT all have to be from their team, but I predict they would be. The lineup would consist of.

1 qb
1 hb
1 fb
2 wr
1 te
2 t
2 g
1 c

2 dt
2 de
3 lb
2 cb
1 fs
1 ss

1 k
1 p
1 ST

Then after the regular season everyone picks who will go on to the final 3 sets. In other words, after the regular season we narrow it down to the final..


3 qb
3 hb
3 fb
6 wr
3 te
6 t
6 g
3 c

6 dt
6 de
9 lb
6 cb
3 fs
3 ss

3 k
3 p
3 ST


And after the postseason all the owners get to vote again from the narrowed down list and pick the top:

1 qb
1 hb
1 fb
2 wr
1 te
2 t
2 g
1 c

2 dt
2 de
3 lb
2 cb
1 fs
1 ss

1 k
1 p
1 ST

This would be the all-pro team. The initial vote would really weed out the "bias" and undeserving players... while still allowing each owner to get adequate representation.

Then the second vote is the "legit" one between players that should be deserving of a vote.

It's a little more work. But may be worth it if this is something owners may want to take part of. I will offer my services to see it become more "legit" and non-biased.
 
Jken043
offline
Link
 
stupid
 
bruiser 1234
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
I don't think I'd take part in a scenario where 2 or 3 or 4 owners only will compile a list.

I think a better scenario would be EVERY owner submits their starting lineup which does NOT all have to be from their team, but I predict they would be. The lineup would consist of.

1 qb
1 hb
1 fb
2 wr
1 te
2 t
2 g
1 c

2 dt
2 de
3 lb
2 cb
1 fs
1 ss

1 k
1 p
1 ST

Then after the regular season everyone picks who will go on to the final 3 sets. In other words, after the regular season we narrow it down to the final..


3 qb
3 hb
3 fb
6 wr
3 te
6 t
6 g
3 c

6 dt
6 de
9 lb
6 cb
3 fs
3 ss

3 k
3 p
3 ST


And after the postseason all the owners get to vote again from the narrowed down list and pick the top:

1 qb
1 hb
1 fb
2 wr
1 te
2 t
2 g
1 c

2 dt
2 de
3 lb
2 cb
1 fs
1 ss

1 k
1 p
1 ST

This would be the all-pro team. The initial vote would really weed out the "bias" and undeserving players... while still allowing each owner to get adequate representation.

Then the second vote is the "legit" one between players that should be deserving of a vote.

It's a little more work. But may be worth it if this is something owners may want to take part of. I will offer my services to see it become more "legit" and non-biased.


There would be max of 3 owners who actually do the work to do all of this
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.