User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #1 > StickMan Brand Power Rankings...Week 6!
Page:
 
Stickman
offline
Link
 
So this isn't exactly how I wanted to break into the USA AA#1 forums...lol, but I've been asked to run my power rankings for you guys. And Since I know quite a few of you from your days in good ole' USA A#2, then I agreed. I see there are other power rankings already being done for this league, so I hope I do not step on any toes. But since pink_panther's rankings seem to be based on human evaluation, I think there's room for a numerical/statistical based ranking as well.

For those of you not familiar with my rankings, here's a rundown of how I compute them.

The rankings are based on two stats.
1) Per Game Success Factor
2) Quality Opponents

The Per Game Success Factor is loosely based on the DVOA stat published by The Football Outsiders: http://www.footballoutsiders.com/
where a team gets points per play bases on how well they move the football. Up to 1 point per play, with bonuses for TD's, FG's, long plays, and moving the ball inside the red zone. This value is calculated for both teams in a game, and the value used is the difference between the two teams. As an example, the week 1 game between the Indianola Legends
and the Golden state Gorillas.

Indianola moved the ball well enough to accumulate a score of 86.87, while GSG was only able to move the ball well enough to earn 31.71 points.

Indianola then came out of the game with a Success factor of 55.16, while GSG ended with a Factor of -55.16.

So, offense is accounted for by your team's success points, and your defense is accounted for by keeping the other team's success points low.

The scores for each game are totaled to yield the season long success factor score. The score is also capped, to prevent teams from running up the score too much against gutted/slow build/terrible teams. IF you followed any of my rankings last season, I've tweaked them a bit from them, to reward big plays a bit more, last season, it seemed like teams who mostly scored on big plays we're a bit penalized in the rankings, because they didn't have as many plays to accumulated success points. The second tweak is to the final scoring method, to allow for more separation between teams than what I had last season.


The second factor is a Quality Opponent Factor. This is simpler to explain. If you beat a team, you get 1 point for every win they have, if you lose to a team, you get -1 point for every loss they have.

Each of these factors is scaled to a maximum of 100 and added to get the final score, which is then ranked.

Thanks,
StickMan

1 - Iowa City Pariahs (E) (5-1-0) 135.21
2 - Indianola Legends (W) (5-1-0) 132.31
3 - Golden State Gorillas (W) (5-1-0) 129.17
4 - Chicago CBMB Bears (E) (4-2-0) 115.7
5 - Tallahassee Seminoles (W) (6-0-0) 114.84
6 - Lincoln Navigators (W) (5-1-0) 113.55
7 - Brainerd Warriors (E) (6-0-0) 108.55
8 - Carolina Hammer (E) (4-2-0) 104.96
9 - Flintown Thugs (E) (5-1-0) 101.33
10 - Chicago "MB" Bears (W) (5-1-0) 90.79
11 - Baltimore Kingz (E) (4-2-0) 76.53
12 - Miami Perfection (E) (4-2-0) 59.41
13 - Tulsa Wild Bunch (W) (4-2-0) 55.98
14 - Iowa Assassins (E) (4-2-0) 49.37
15 - Sin City Outlaws (W) (4-2-0) 47.47
16 - Albuquerque Rattlers (W) (3-3-0) 45.76
17 - San Antonio Rampage (E) (4-2-0) 38.95
18 - Milwaukee Free for All (W) (3-3-0) 15.98
19 - La Jolla Surf (W) (2-4-0) 9.37
20 - Hogtown Gators (E) (3-3-0) 3.19
21 - Rapid City Sioux (E) (2-4-0) -12.82
22 - Denver Wildcats (W) (2-4-0) -24
23 - Nashville NFLFever2.com (E) (1-5-0) -53.06
24 - Beantown Gearheads (E) (2-4-0) -66.29
25 - Chicago Farmers CPU (W) (1-5-0) -77.27
26 - Minnesota Shockers (W) (1-5-0) -121.11
27 - Fightin' Bananas (W) (1-5-0) -160.4
28 - Orange County Old Farmers (E) (0-5-1) -160.42
29 - Port City Mosquitos (W) (1-5-0) -181.34
30 - Buffalo Bisons (W) (0-6-0) -191.12
31 - Raleigh Red Wolves (E) (0-6-0) -221.57
32 - Orlando Outlaws (E) (0-5-1) -279.05
 
PyscoJester13
offline
Link
 
Nice.
 
Link
 
Thanks SM! Always a pleasure and greatly appreciate you taking the time to do this.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
The nice thing about Stickman's ratings is they always had us ranked higher than anyone else thought we should be.
 
pink_panther
offline
Link
 
the more the better. thanks for doing these.
 
sixwhat
offline
Link
 
Looks pretty legit
 
cabz
offline
Link
 
Nice list, Stickman.

Big game week 7 with No. 3, Gorillas, vs. the No. 5, Seminoles. Go Gorillas!
 
pink_panther
offline
Link
 
Brainerd has beat the 4th, 8th, 9th, 11th, and 14th ranked teams. Our per game success factor must suck.
 
Stickman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pink_panther
Brainerd has beat the 4th, 8th, 9th, 11th, and 14th ranked teams. Our per game success factor must suck.


It does...you're currently ranked 20th in the success factor.

But, in those games you mentioned, the chicago game, you won, but walked out of there with a -12.24 success factor. Usually when a team wins, my system scores them with a positive value.

I looked at this game, and Brainerd had 2 defensive TD's, which are not highly accounted for in my system.

Against Carolina, you guys had another Defensive TD, yet still came out with a -11.09 success factor, and since you guys got outgained 413 to 276, I'm ok with that.

Against Flintown, again you came out with the win, but were outgained 380.5 to 281.5, which resulted in a negative 2.62 success factor.

And against the Kings, you (comparably) whupped up, with a success factor of 30.19

Maybe the defensive scoring is something I should work on, but it hadn't really happened that much, and when it did happen it was usually in a lop-sided game where the difference wasn't noticed. So I haven't made an effort to put more emphasis on defensive scoring, but I may have to.

I'm not highlighting these scores to try and put you guys down or to try and say that Brainerd should not have won those games. Brainerd won, and that's what matters. That's part of why I have the quality win factor to add in to the overall score. Brainerd is way at the top of the quality win score, earning the maximum of 100 possible points. The second place team in quality wins, Indianola, has 91.7 points, then it drops off a freaking cliff.....the 3rd place team, Iowa City, gets 50 points. So those wins are counting big for Brainerd. The success factor points will come, but for now, that's how I'm explaining my system and the placement of the teams.

Thanks,
StickMan
 
Doomsday
offline
Link
 
I love Stickman's rankings. I missed these since leaving A2. Thanx for taking the time SM. Hope you can do these for us every now and then when you can. GL to Beertown. Hope you join us up here next season... If we happen to stick around
 
commando
offline
Link
 
looks good stickman. +1 karma
 
makbeer
offline
Link
 
Stickman is baaaaaaaaaaaaack
 
ryanbrock
offline
Link
 
Thanks Stickman, AA1 appreciates it.
 
pink_panther
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stickman
Originally posted by pink_panther

Brainerd has beat the 4th, 8th, 9th, 11th, and 14th ranked teams. Our per game success factor must suck.


It does...you're currently ranked 20th in the success factor.

But, in those games you mentioned, the chicago game, you won, but walked out of there with a -12.24 success factor. Usually when a team wins, my system scores them with a positive value.

I looked at this game, and Brainerd had 2 defensive TD's, which are not highly accounted for in my system.

Against Carolina, you guys had another Defensive TD, yet still came out with a -11.09 success factor, and since you guys got outgained 413 to 276, I'm ok with that.

Against Flintown, again you came out with the win, but were outgained 380.5 to 281.5, which resulted in a negative 2.62 success factor.

And against the Kings, you (comparably) whupped up, with a success factor of 30.19

Maybe the defensive scoring is something I should work on, but it hadn't really happened that much, and when it did happen it was usually in a lop-sided game where the difference wasn't noticed. So I haven't made an effort to put more emphasis on defensive scoring, but I may have to.

I'm not highlighting these scores to try and put you guys down or to try and say that Brainerd should not have won those games. Brainerd won, and that's what matters. That's part of why I have the quality win factor to add in to the overall score. Brainerd is way at the top of the quality win score, earning the maximum of 100 possible points. The second place team in quality wins, Indianola, has 91.7 points, then it drops off a freaking cliff.....the 3rd place team, Iowa City, gets 50 points. So those wins are counting big for Brainerd. The success factor points will come, but for now, that's how I'm explaining my system and the placement of the teams.

Thanks,
StickMan


I love these rankings and didn't mean to complain at all. I know we have been winning ugly so it was to be expected. Thanks for the detailed explanation as I would have accepted "yes it does suck".
 
Stickman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pink_panther

I love these rankings and didn't mean to complain at all. I know we have been winning ugly so it was to be expected. Thanks for the detailed explanation as I would have accepted "yes it does suck".


No, no. It's fine. I've had WAY worse comments about my rankings, so no offense was taken. I just thought that I could take this as an opportunity to help everyone understand the rankings a bit more, and why I had you guys ranked 7th, even though you're undefeated.

Thanks,
StickMan
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.