User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Petition to Fix XPs
Page:
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1113184&page=last#8757966

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1087552

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=871352&page=1

I know Bort has said that he didn't touch anything and that this is all on the players themselves.

Unfortunately, the areas of weakness that Bort says contribute to the excessive amount of misses on XPs have all been covered by various players who are still missing XPs.

There is absolutely no reason why players with nearly 100 kicking, 50+ strength, vision, and confidence should not be able to nail a TEN YARD kick nearly every time. I've seen players with 30+ agility that miss XPs, 25 jumping, 25 agility, 11 in automatic, etc., etc.

Every area that has been addressed as a possible issue for kickers missing XPs (including stamina) has been met by a player who has no deficiencies in those areas who is still missing extra points.

I am making this thread as a way to consolidate our concerns. I am begging that this issue be looked at. Even if Bort has not touched anything, there is something horribly wrong with the way XPs are being calculated. There is no reason why the amount of misses is so high and I feel very strongly that it should be addressed.

Also, the three links I provided have all of the arguments listed for what is going on. Please try to keep this thread free from those arguments. This is only meant to be a way to document the amount of concern GLB has with the issue. The discussion can be had in any of those three threads. Thank you.
 
therichone
offline
Link
 
another related one http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=125791
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 23:07:08
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho


There is absolutely no reason why players with nearly 100 kicking, 50+ strength, vision, and confidence should not be able to nail a TEN YARD kick nearly every time. I've seen players with 30+ agility that miss XPs, 25 jumping, 25 agility, 11 in automatic, etc., etc.


Can you link some replays or games that show a Kicker of that caliber actually missing excessive amounts of XPs - OTHER than when the game's a complete blowout, and teh Kicker's leg's about to fall off by the end, and he *GASP* shanks one?
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 23:07:18
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Anarcho

I am making this thread as a way to consolidate our concerns. I am begging that this issue be looked at. Even if Bort has not touched anything, there is something horribly wrong with the way XPs are being calculated. There is no reason why the amount of misses is so high and I feel very strongly that it should be addressed.


I agree 100% that the amount of missed XP's is crazy, I noticed it started doing that last season on a more frequent basis.
 
Anarcho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Originally posted by Anarcho



There is absolutely no reason why players with nearly 100 kicking, 50+ strength, vision, and confidence should not be able to nail a TEN YARD kick nearly every time. I've seen players with 30+ agility that miss XPs, 25 jumping, 25 agility, 11 in automatic, etc., etc.


Can you link some replays or games that show a Kicker of that caliber actually missing excessive amounts of XPs - OTHER than when the game's a complete blowout, and teh Kicker's leg's about to fall off by the end, and he *GASP* shanks one?


There have been various threads that have documented the problems with XPs these past few seasons.

From experience, the kicker on our own team has missed XPs on his very first play of the game at least twice before. The only explanation that has been given for that is that he has low speed, agility, and jumping.

Problem with that is that other kickers who have high speed, agility, and jumping have documented the same problems.

Again though, this isn't meant to site evidence. There are three recent threads for it already.

This is just so we can have one place to voice our concern instead of a half-dozen smaller threads that go generally unnoticed.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
I have a Kicker in the high 20's lvl area, and he barely misses anything, including 40+ FGs, not to mention XPs...

Just the past game, he kicked 1 FG and 52 XPs during the game - it was a complete blowout against a gutted team and he ended the game with 16 energy.

He missed the FG which was toward the end of the game, when he had already kicked about 40 times, and only missed 4 XPs out of 51...

SO for those of you not able to process this information this late that's:

0/1 FG, 48/52 XP

The ones he missed were all, exclusively, at the end of this game.

I don't see a problem...
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Originally posted by Anarcho



There is absolutely no reason why players with nearly 100 kicking, 50+ strength, vision, and confidence should not be able to nail a TEN YARD kick nearly every time. I've seen players with 30+ agility that miss XPs, 25 jumping, 25 agility, 11 in automatic, etc., etc.


Can you link some replays or games that show a Kicker of that caliber actually missing excessive amounts of XPs - OTHER than when the game's a complete blowout, and teh Kicker's leg's about to fall off by the end, and he *GASP* shanks one?


Here you go.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=145034

 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
0/1 on a 40-49 yd FG and 7/10 XPs isn't really all that terrible...I was expecting to see like...

0/3 FG and 2/10 XP or something, the way a big stink was being made about it...
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
eh, missing 3 PAT's out of 10 is ridiculous, especially for a level 33 kicker with the attributes my kicker has. I don't mind missing one, or two when it's against a gutted team, but 3 out of 10 is way too much. I wasn't worried about the FG, I expect some of those to be missed, but PAT's at the college and pro level are completed at a much higher rate than anything we are currently seeing.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Well yeah you do have a point, but is this happening on every game your Kicker plays, or was this a one-time-only thing?

Sometimes, even in Professional Sports, things that people think are impossible happen...such as perhaps a team making a huge comeback - one of those miracle quality comebacks - only to need the XP to tie and go into overtime in a game everyone said was over at halftime...to see the Kicker shank the XP...

Insanity happens in sports...if this isn't an every-game occurrence, I'd chalk it up to the fact that your guy is human, too, and makes mistakes sometimes...
 
Enpassant
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
eh, missing 3 PAT's out of 10 is ridiculous, especially for a level 33 kicker with the attributes my kicker has. I don't mind missing one, or two when it's against a gutted team, but 3 out of 10 is way too much. I wasn't worried about the FG, I expect some of those to be missed, but PAT's at the college and pro level are completed at a much higher rate than anything we are currently seeing.


I agree 100%
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Well yeah you do have a point, but is this happening on every game your Kicker plays, or was this a one-time-only thing?

Sometimes, even in Professional Sports, things that people think are impossible happen...such as perhaps a team making a huge comeback - one of those miracle quality comebacks - only to need the XP to tie and go into overtime in a game everyone said was over at halftime...to see the Kicker shank the XP...

Insanity happens in sports...if this isn't an every-game occurrence, I'd chalk it up to the fact that your guy is human, too, and makes mistakes sometimes...


No fuck that, everyone is perfect in GLB because we all have perfect builds.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Outside of games against gutted teams, no, this is the 1st time this has happened (which is probably why it caught my eye more than usual). Just seemed out of the ordinary. I'm not overly concerned, I'd just like to see PAT conversions be a bit higher than they currently are and was providing an example of an anomaly.
 
CharcoalCody
offline
Link
 
I don't know what the exact issue is, but gaining skill points should NOT cause kickers to start missing XPs more regularly. At the very least, the programmers should explain which attributes have an inverse relationship with kicking XPs, or eliminate the problem. The idea that spending money to boost, will actually hurt a player is troubling.

It would be one thing if it was just a player or two. You could figure that they were snake-bitten outliers. But this seems to be an issue for many kickers.
 
Greenday4537
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Well yeah you do have a point, but is this happening on every game your Kicker plays, or was this a one-time-only thing?

Sometimes, even in Professional Sports, things that people think are impossible happen...such as perhaps a team making a huge comeback - one of those miracle quality comebacks - only to need the XP to tie and go into overtime in a game everyone said was over at halftime...to see the Kicker shank the XP...

Insanity happens in sports...if this isn't an every-game occurrence, I'd chalk it up to the fact that your guy is human, too, and makes mistakes sometimes...


I don't know many pro-kickers that shank multiple missed XPs every season. Hm, no missed extra points this season in the NFL. 7 kickers missed ONE extra point in 2007 and 2 missed TWO extra points in 2007. 8 kickers missed ONE extra point in 2006 and only 1 missed two in 2006.

You get my point. It just doesn't happen this often each season for kickers.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.