User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort CB staying with WR Re: SA of quick cut
Page:
 
KillerFX
offline
Link
 
I know bort made changes a while back to keep CB/FS/SS from over running slower WR/TE.

My concern is that when SA's fire i.e quick cut it causes the CB to do the following. See my CB carson Lee in the following examples.

For the record my CB has agility in the high 60's, speed 70's and vision close to 60. SA's are high for lock down corner with good first step and quick cut. I could give many examples from this game and others this season.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145143&pbp_id=2709258

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145143&pbp_id=2709267

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145143&pbp_id=2709278

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145143&pbp_id=2709314

now notice this where there is no cut and he stays in good position to the WR

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145143&pbp_id=2709290

Disclaimer!

Now I fully admit there may be other things going on that I am not aware of but this doesn't seem right.

I won this game by 70 points so this isn't about whining about a loss. Also my other CB don't have high quick cut and they don't do this. I am fine with the performance of my Corners in the games this season.



 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
That does look a little weird, but because of cruise control you can't really read anything into your performance.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
The corners on my expansion team act like that also, sometimes. (Both starters have 1-1-1-1-1 from their custom in shutdown corner)

I'm not digging up replays, but I've seen them act just like that, with no SA.


Edit:

Actually, it only seems to happen often at the CB1 position.

Switch your guys for a game and see if it happens again.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 00:54:06
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
I apollogize but.. uh.. what am I looking for? Sorry if I'm a bit dense.
 
KillerFX
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
That does look a little weird, but because of cruise control you can't really read anything into your performance.


Its happend in every game easy or tough. I noticed it last season but since I upped my quick cut this season it is happening every game.

again its not about getting beat on the play as my other CB's don't have it as high and it doesn't happen to them
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
The corners on my expansion team act like that also, sometimes. (Both starters have 1-1-1-1-1 from their custom in shutdown corner)

I'm not digging up replays, but I've seen them act just like that, with no SA.


Edit:

Actually, it only seems to happen often at the CB1 position.

Switch your guys for a game and see if it happens again.


The examples shown are in the CB3 spot.

And this is another of those in sim exploits that crop up.
A fast, agile CB with an investment in the more 'nimble' SAs often has decent covering positions on slower possession type WRs, but when making a cut, he suddenly speeds up and overshoots the coverage, because he ALWAYS seems to make the cuts at his Full potential, and not at the neccessary speed.

This leads to a better CB having a tougher time against weaker WR than against the better ones.

Its what I refer to as a Football Logic Flaw, and I dont think there would be a way to introduce a calculation to assess the needed speed of the cut each and every time for each and every player.

The issue being that while the CB is calculating the vector of the WR, he cant seem to account for the loss of speed a poorer WR will have during a cut transition.

The only way I have found to to deal with it is to 'underbuild' a player and use Equipment carfully to match up to different opposition.

Alternatively you can try a complex zone system to stop the out of sync nature of the match ups, but thats generally a bad idea.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 06:26:02
 
KillerFX
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Forbin

The corners on my expansion team act like that also, sometimes. (Both starters have 1-1-1-1-1 from their custom in shutdown corner)

I'm not digging up replays, but I've seen them act just like that, with no SA.


Edit:

Actually, it only seems to happen often at the CB1 position.

Switch your guys for a game and see if it happens again.


The examples shown are in the CB3 spot.

And this is another of those in sim exploits that crop up.
A fast, agile CB with an investment in the more 'nimble' SAs often has decent covering positions on slower possession type WRs, but when making a cut, he suddenly speeds up and overshoots the coverage, because he ALWAYS seems to make the cuts at his Full potential, and not at the neccessary speed.

This leads to a better CB having a tougher time against weaker WR than against the better ones.

Its what I refer to as a Football Logic Flaw, and I dont think there would be a way to introduce a calculation to assess the needed speed of the cut each and every time for each and every player.

The issue being that while the CB is calculating the vector of the WR, he cant seem to account for the loss of speed a poorer WR will have during a cut transition.

The only way I have found to to deal with it is to 'underbuild' a player and use Equipment carfully to match up to different opposition.

Alternatively you can try a complex zone system to stop the out of sync nature of the match ups, but thats generally a bad idea.


that makes complete sense. So my next question would be has bort addressed this?

I mean as you can see this actually has a big impact on my games.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
#1 - playing in a blowout this means your skills were damped down and you weren't playing at 100%.

#2 - on at least one play it looks like the CB got faked (pump or head) and didn't adjust.

#3 - CB's even the best won't have perfect coverage. They will cut late or be a step slow to read on occasion.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KillerFX

that makes complete sense. So my next question would be has bort addressed this?

I mean as you can see this actually has a big impact on my games.


I dont think it has been specifically addressed.

However he did solve a Very similar issue in regards to LBs in zone coverage a few seasons back.

It was the same basic thing, speed and agility above a certain level and they fly back too deep, and accelerrated into cuts too much, and therefore were out of position consistently.

As this happened to every player on every play it was a lot easier to see.

Now with this specific case for CBs, it is not much of an issue when both WR and CB are of similar speed/agility.

It actually helps if the CB is of a lesser build than the WR.

Then we have to allow that replays are not really whats happening, etc etc etc

As you can see from this thread 99% of people dont evene realise whats happening when you spell it out for them.

I think that the only way to fix it would be if Bort somehow managed to get the WR to make his calculations, and come up with his final position after the cut is made, then to have the CB know that point before making his cut.

With the CBs abilities the only factor in how smoothly he makes the cut.

Personally I think that would be too much work and the results far too overpowering for CBs.
It also goes against every other calculation in GLB.

It would be like freezing the play to let the CB catch up, rather than having him react.

I think you just need to be aware that there is a 'Sweetspot' for Agility/Speed/SAs combined and that you need to understand what is happening in replays, and adjust accordingly.

If Bort could come up with a better way to fix it then great, maybe its a sequence of events thing, but I dont think it is going to be the number 1 priority for a little while.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 11:10:08
 
Den
offline
Link
 
Rather than have the Calc refer to a 'spot'...

Maybe add a step when computing a CB's speed while in man coverage? Every Tick look at WR's current speed and make the CB's max speed drop to WR's current speed + 2-5%?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Maybe, would depend on how the calcs are set up now, if cuts can happen in between Ticks and how First Step and Quick Cut SAs work precisely in the calcs.?

Would make sense though. certainly be intrested to see how it looks in a few tests.
 
Montclaire
offline
Link
 
Mike Rogers,

I fully understand what you are saying and it makes complete sense.

However, I've noticed the same behaviour in my own CB. While his agility is relatively high for his level (24), he has no points in the quick cut yet. I've yet to notice a discernible pattern as to why/when it happens, either. Against both higher/lower level WR (I play nickle in a AA lge covering WRs lvl 18-35), he primarily covers very well with instances of this behavior.

I'm sure that quick cut may exacerbate the situation, but isn't necessarily the culprit in my experiences.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
I can easily see the problem, and I see it on my teams as well. But, I'd never thought that this was the problem.

I don't see why it would be a problem to throttle SA just like the regular skills (but always have their full potential available, of course).
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Are you sure it's quick cut and not just the CB making mistakes? They can make mistakes and get faked when receivers make cuts in their routes.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Montclaire,

I think you slightly miss understand.

I dont think Quick Cut is the culprit (As it is a WR SA)

But the problem is merely that a CB can be a lot better at making changes of direction than the WR he is playing against, and because of that be beaten by that WR time and time again.

This is because the CB can maintain hgher speed during and after the cut than the WR.

The result is that the CB appears to run away from the WR for a second until the sim allows him to recalculate, causing some 'artificial' seperation.

By being good at his job, the CB suffers, and thats the issue.

Again I dont think there is an issue outside of when the cut occurs.

Th CB is simply unable to alter how he moves during the cut, as he cannot know the WRs agility or quick cuts level.

This means that he over compensates against lesser opposition, no matter how well he is built.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.