User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > KRETCHFOOP’S FARM LEAGUE SUGGESTION
Page:
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Problem: There are still a fair amount of farm teams in GLB that are ruining parity. The one-team only per user was a failed attempt at preventing this. I know that adding new teams is a major cash cow for GLB and that leagues need to be filled in. However, looking at it from more of a systems perspective, the lack of parity and perennial issue of gutting is lessening the value of the game to owners and players alike – the same owners that are pumping in the money to develop this game. Demand must also meet supply or this game will quickly collapse.

Solution overview: All owners are allowed to purchase a farm team if they have owned the same team for a full season (then considered a franchise and the team would be labeled accordingly). This requirement is waived if the team has existed for 2 or more full seasons (once the level cap is removed). Farm teams will cost an additional 500 FP per season (can be paid for by a fellow GM).

This will be one large and separate league…similar to college football. Structure can eventually be added if deemed necessary. Schedules will be determined during the preseason based on the median level of the players for each team. There would be very few cupcake match ups. The best part is - there would be an additional 3 games (with experience) each season for these developing players. This would provide incentive for players to join a farm team with a real hope of supplanting a pro league starter. No wait, the best part is that there would then be bowl games! These would be great sources of revenue for the franchise. Otherwise, income would be less for these farm teams and they would not be a major source of revenue.

You can move players up and down for ½ the chemistry hit during the season. After the deadline it goes back to the normal hits. During the off season, you actually get ½ a point in chemistry for bringing up a player that was “in your system.” This is negated if you move them back down. This exploit would be abused…so they would have to code so that players that were with a “pro” team for ½ the season would not be eligible to play those extra games.

Benefits:

-Long-term contracts would be more likely used for those early developing players. However, contracts would have to be reworked so that there were buy-out clauses (should happen anyway).

-This would chip away at the gutting problem and keep the income going for Bort while allowing for a more quality product for users.

-This would alleviate some of the strain on the D-Leagues. Yeah, they are great and all…but the lack of available spots really does keep people from creating more new players (i.e. a kicker).

-This would allow for a more realistic career for players…go to the D-Leagues (high school), go to a farm team (college), then go to a pro team.

-Pro league players that do not boost will eventually be forced down into a farm team, but gain the additional experience, and have hope to make it back into the big leagues...possibly encouraging boosting.

What are your thoughts? Where are the holes and what can be added?
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
i would love to buy a farm team.

Now I had to find someone else to be willing to make one for my team and I did, but it would have been alot better if I could have just done it on my own
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
i would love to buy a farm team.

Now I had to find someone else to be willing to make one for my team and I did, but it would have been alot better if I could have just done it on my own


Agreed, same situation here. The work-around of having a 2nd person buy the farm team just makes it more difficult not impossible.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
i would love to buy a farm team.

Now I had to find someone else to be willing to make one for my team and I did, but it would have been alot better if I could have just done it on my own


Me 3.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I've come around to the view of allowing one official farm team per "regular" team.

The big advantage to having a team officially a farm team instead of unofficial as is done would be that moving players up and down would have minimized chemistry effects.

But there'd be a disadvantage, in that the fans would know it was a development team just developing players for another team rather than committed first to winning, and thus expected ticket prices would be much lower, likely requiring subsidies from the parent team.

Of course such subsidies would be allowed to be made (they normally couldn't be made between two teams), but the tradeoff to owning the farm team is that it couldn't function on its own.
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Wow pretty well thought out Kretch I am impressed. I like most of it but would like to see level caps fixed on farm teams. Say as an example only make it a level 16 cap where your contract automatically expires at level 16 and you are forced into the real leagues somewhere.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I've come around to the view of allowing one official farm team per "regular" team.

The big advantage to having a team officially a farm team instead of unofficial as is done would be that moving players up and down would have minimized chemistry effects.

But there'd be a disadvantage, in that the fans would know it was a development team just developing players for another team rather than committed first to winning, and thus expected ticket prices would be much lower, likely requiring subsidies from the parent team.

Of course such subsidies would be allowed to be made (they normally couldn't be made between two teams), but the tradeoff to owning the farm team is that it couldn't function on its own.


Currently teams that have a farm team have a huge advantage. Not only do they have a pipeline of developing players, but those players come over fully equipped and under long-term contracts. Also the new players coming out of the d-leagues going to the farm team can be signed by the parent club and sent over to the farm club for cash, thus infusing extra cash into the parent club.

Ken's idea would level the playing field a bit for the teams that don't have a farm club.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Wow pretty well thought out Kretch I am impressed. I like most of it but would like to see level caps fixed on farm teams. Say as an example only make it a level 16 cap where your contract automatically expires at level 16 and you are forced into the real leagues somewhere.


If this were the case...a lot of teams would not even bother. What are they going to do with a level 16, aside from letting him ride the bench?

The beauty of the college-like farm system is that matchups are based on team level...if "conferences" are established each season, they would be rather large and not confined to the 16 teams with some gut-jobs. If there was an inbalance, there would be a few inter-conference games...but with the larger pool, this would be less likely than the current system.

Kind of like the restructuring idea that Bort had without interferring directly with established teams. It would also be a test run and, if it didn't significantly resolve the gutting problem, it would open eyes to a new way to run the game.

Just my opinion.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Wow pretty well thought out Kretch I am impressed. I like most of it but would like to see level caps fixed on farm teams. Say as an example only make it a level 16 cap where your contract automatically expires at level 16 and you are forced into the real leagues somewhere.


LOL...then people would go back to the current system of a buddy buying a team and not caring if it wins, but using it as a development center.

The more you restrict and regulate the "farm teams" the more people will find another work around. If a farm team is developing for a quality 'pro' team then it will need to develop players into the mid 20s at least for them to be useful at the pro level.
 
DT35
offline
Link
 
Kretchfoop.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DT35
Kretchfoop.


Nice hat.
 
DT35
offline
Link
 
Did GeffJarcia do yours?
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DT35
Did GeffJarcia do yours?


Naw, I do my own work. I kind of half-assed this one. The third dimension has screwed me over!
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Bump...
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Problem: There are still a fair amount of farm teams in GLB that are ruining parity. The one-team only per user was a failed attempt at preventing this. I know that adding new teams is a major cash cow for GLB and that leagues need to be filled in. However, looking at it from more of a systems perspective, the lack of parity and perennial issue of gutting is lessening the value of the game to owners and players alike – the same owners that are pumping in the money to develop this game. Demand must also meet supply or this game will quickly collapse.

Solution overview: All owners are allowed to purchase a farm team if they have owned the same team for a full season (then considered a franchise and the team would be labeled accordingly). This requirement is waived if the team has existed for 2 or more full seasons (once the level cap is removed). Farm teams will cost an additional 500 FP per season (can be paid for by a fellow GM).


I made a suggestion much like this one a couple of months ago.

A completely separate league system for farm teams would be very awesome.

My suggestion involved a second system for players in their 2nd and 3rd seasons (D-league being the place for 1st season players). It would work like a minor league system, but after a player is over 3 seasons old (or maybe make it 4), he would have to leave. There has to be some limitation like this to keep parity in the farm leagues.

Farm leagues could have promotion and relegation just like the main system, but there would be no movement between the two systems.

But I could get behind a college system below the current system as well.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 16:54:37
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.