User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Current Restructuring Poll Results
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
@ 5:00 PM EST on Thursday, September 25, 2008

Question 1: Would you be in favor of doing a one-time league restructure based on team levels, at the end of the current season?

A. Yes, I want to play teams at my own level, no matter where that is
----------------------6,344.....+132 (2%)

B. Yes, but only if I can stay in my current region
----------------------2,426.....+47 (2%)

C. No, but I would like to see an increased promotion/relegation count
----------------------2,236.....+39 (2%)

D. No, I really like the leagues the way they are
----------------------1,352.....+25 (2%)

Looking into the results

1. Total Votes: 12,358
2. For some form of restructuring: 71%
3. Against leaving current region: 49%
4. Increased promotion/relegation vs. restructuring: 18%
5. Keep things 100% status quo: 11%

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Question 2: What type of league structure would you prefer to see, independent of what we decide to do with sold/gutted teams?

A. The current league structure is great. It allows me to fight my way to the top.
----------------------4,648.....+84 (2%)

B. One giant pyramid or bow-tie structure. Really makes it great to get to the top.
----------------------2,109.....+41 (2%)

C. Something similar to NCAA. I would like to be able to choose part of my schedule.
----------------------2,026.....+47 (2.5%)

D. Split up the current leagues into smaller versions, with 3 tiers each.
----------------------1,060.....+22 (2%)

E. Just put everyone into one giant pool and have them play teams of equal level in various tournaments.
----------------------916.....+13 (1.5%)

F. All leagues completely separate. I don't like promotion/relegation.
----------------------340.....+5 (1.5%)

Looking into the results

1. Total Votes: 11,099
2. Still want a pyramid structure: 70%
3. Anything but the current structure: 58%
4. Keep the current league structure: 42%
5. Want to choose schedule: 18%
6. Massive tournament structure: 8%
7. Thousands of separate leagues: 3%
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 15:04:54
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
If people find this useful, let me know what a good (and fair) amount of time would be between updates and I'll do my best to keep things updated.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
I honestly think what this says is that whatever you put as option #1 will win. Hell, I'd bet that somewhere around 1/2 of the players don't even know what the term "region" means and how it applies to their team. Sure, most reading and posting in the forums do, but we represent a relatively small % of players in this game.

Of the 10 agents I have on my team, 8 of them never read the forums at all, don't have a clue what regions mean and almost all of the info they get regarding how this game works is from myself and the 2 other agents on the team that do read the forums. A fairly simular % (little higher, but not much) occurs on the other 3 teams I GM for.

IMO, Bort believes that a MUCH higher % of users track the forums and try to keep up with what's going on, termonology and how things work than really do. Most of my guys just want to watch their players play and get Ws
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I honestly think what this says is that whatever you put as option #1 will win. Hell, I'd bet that somewhere around 1/2 of the players don't even know what the term "region" means and how it applies to their team. Sure, most reading and posting in the forums do, but we represent a relatively small % of players in this game.

Of the 10 agents I have on my team, 8 of them never read the forums at all, don't have a clue what regions mean and almost all of the info they get regarding how this game works is from myself and the 2 other agents on the team that do read the forums. A fairly simular % (little higher, but not much) occurs on the other 3 teams I GM for.

IMO, Bort believes that a MUCH higher % of users track the forums and try to keep up with what's going on, termonology and how things work than really do. Most of my guys just want to watch their players play and get Ws


Actually, I don't think the answer with the highest vote is winning, persay.

On the 2nd question, 58% of respondents want anything but the current league structure. Sure, 42% want things to stay status quo and the other 58% of the vote is split among multiple options, but in raw terms, almost 3 in 5 don't think the current structure is the best option for the game.

Now, take into account your argument that some people may just vote for the 1st option (hence the questions with the single largest vote tallies) and you could hypothesize that it is a much higher % of people that don't like the current league structure.

Did a little deeper, and right now almost 3 in 4 want some sort of pyramid structure, be it the status quo, one massive pyramid, or more three-tiered pyramid leagues.

And that is just question #2. You can draw more out of the numbers for question #1, as I've pointed out above.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Thinking of it in raw business terms, if 1/2 of your consumer base would be upset if you knocked off the current regional structure (as per question #1), would you want to do that? I think most successful businesses would say no.

So while the "winning" answer to question #1 is to not worry about regional ties and just put the best vs. the best, it only represents (currently) about 51% of the total vote...not nearly enough, in my opinion, to annoy 49% of users by moving them out of their regions.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Hope you're right. I really do believe that the poll is an extremely flawed gauge of what most players and/or owners want (I'd like to think the owners would have slightly more pull in this, since many specifically bought teams in regions they wanted to be in)
 
PP
offline
Link
 
PS But I do applaud Bort for trying.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
For the second poll, I support the 3 tier system. But barring that, having what we have now, with nothing lower than BBB leagues, is cool too.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Quit "interpreting the polls" because you disagree with the winning vote, imo.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
Quit "interpreting the polls" because you disagree with the winning vote, imo.


Quit reading into something that isn't there....this is strictly a numerical analysis of the votes, nothing more, nothing less. There is another thread devoted to the polls where people can cry, whine and bitch all they want.
 
fliphusker
offline
Link
 
If teams change regeons, they should get the chance to change their team names. How good would it be having my Bangkok Bangers in a Canadian league?

I think it would be more fun to have 8 divisions with 4 teams per division. Play teqams in your division 2x/year and then rotate the other games.

This is just like the NFL does and we are trying to run this game like the NFL, so simply make it more like it.


I do see so many teams that simply hate going into the season, as they know they simply will not be able to compete with other teams. This will just more interest in the game. Which would prob add more money into the game, thus keeping the game stable
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fliphusker
If teams change regeons, they should get the chance to change their team names. How good would it be having my Bangkok Bangers in a Canadian league?


Go look at many if not most/all leagues and you'll find at least a few teams with names that have nothing to do with their region.

Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:55:43
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
5:00 pm EST update

interesting that the 1st poll has over 1,000 more votes
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 15:05:30
 
Montclaire
offline
Link
 
I haven't voted because I'm not strongly for/against any particular option. I like/dislike pieces of each, but not strongly enough to exclude.

I will say that I do not envy Bort & the ADMINs for the task of trying to find the optimum solution. Any changes or non-changes will simply result in new ways around it and lots of disgruntled folks.

Sincere thanks for trying and giving us a voice, though. Good luck!
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 15:27:56
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
I honestly think what this says is that whatever you put as option #1 will win. Hell, I'd bet that somewhere around 1/2 of the players don't even know what the term "region" means and how it applies to their team. Sure, most reading and posting in the forums do, but we represent a relatively small % of players in this game.


Exactly.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.