User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Well Thought-Out Solution to Gutting
Page:
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally I had the complete proposal in this spot, but on suggestions from others I have replaced it. Below is the more digestible summary and a quick answering of Bort's problems with this type of system to give you an overview. You can find the complete proposal at the top of page three of this thread. Link to page 3: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1106137&page=3

Summary
When a team loses it's owner, instead of receiving a random Joe from the queue, their new owner is either appointed by the old owner out of the GMs or voted on by the team. If the owner is appointed by votes, the players vote again at the end of the year to decide if the team is disbanded or continues on. These votes are backed by contracts. If the team chooses to disband, or nobody volunteers to be on the ballot, or if the team is financially insolvent, then the team is erased and all the players are free agents. A new team is created at a bottom tier league and teams are promoted to take the place in each tier at and below the resetting team. The current relegation/promotion system will still be scheduled, but when extra intra-league flow is required from teams resetting, teams will be promoted based on an automatic ranking system. This system will value playoffs and the most recent years the highest.

Bort's Questions
These are from the stickied thread about problems with moving sold teams to the bottom tier. I actually didn't know this thread existed before I wrote up my proposal, but my system answers the "problems that haven't been worked out with the idea" quite nicely. Here they are answered in brief. For details on the answers below, see my complete proposal.

Originally posted by Bort
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

Besides the normal rules for promotion which my system follows, extra teams as needed are promoted based on a ranking system. Unfortunately, automatic ranking systems are a necessary evil in any system where teams are reset to the bottom. But they aren't as bad as people might make it out to be, and it is better than any alternative.
Originally posted by Bort
2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

My solution to this problem is electing an interim owner voted on by the players. He would have the power to manage tactics, but wouldn't be able to deal with contracts.
Originally posted by Bort
3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

My system doesn't allow teams to be sold mid season except at the bottom league, where these types of teams will be more expected.
Originally posted by bort
4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

One version of my proposed system allows for a player who wants to move a bunch of their players and take over a new team to advertise this. A player on a team that just lost it's owner could see that these new players would help out the team and could add the prospective owner to the ballot if he accepts. Then if most of the team agrees that he is a good fit, he can take over and move his players in at the end of the season. If this open ended ballot adding (of course with some restrictions) is deemed to be too much of a potential problem, then another solution to this under my system is for the prospective owner to find another owner who plans to retire at some point, and convincing him to let him become a GM of the team to be appointed after he retires.
Originally posted by bort
5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

My solution to this is to give the team a chance to save itself by voting on a new owner. If no suitable owner is found or the team itself doesn't want to be saved at the end of the season then it is reset.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 06:06:02
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
My first thought was to just post tl/dr.

My second thought was to give the idea some merit.

But then I decided tl;dr.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tordman
My first thought was to just post tl/dr.

My second thought was to give the idea some merit.

But then I decided tl;dr.


basically. I tried to start reading but got to Overview.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Ya, I know that is going to be the response of most people. But any good solution will not be simple.

I put a lot of thought into this so hopefully the right people will read it.


Also, I would way rather people not read it or post TL;DR then give it a half-assed attempt and make inaccurate judgments.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 18:47:38
 
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Ya, I know that is going to be the response of most people. But any good solution will not be simple.

I put a lot of thought into this so hopefully the right people will read it.


Well I read it, but I'm hardly the right people.
 
tordman
offline
Link
 
It's just too much info to digest, perhaps a condensed version?
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I would like a summarized version. Then if people have questions make them read the big one
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
The Solution: Overview
Have there only be three ways for a team to remain intact after an owner leaves:


That's your problem - reducing the number of ways that teams can remove together, by definition, does not reduce gutting. Come up with an idea that would actually fix gutting, place a single sentence that relates to that idea here.. and base everything else on that sentence.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
I would like a summarized version. Then if people have questions make them read the big one


I like this idea. I don't have the time now but probably later I will post a summarized version as a new thread and then link to this one if people want to read more.

Edit- unless this thread takes off.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 19:24:25
 
gravenimages
offline
Link
 
Take the time to read this one, it's worth it.

and +1.

Essentially, if a GM doesn't want to assume the team, keep them together with an interim owner with powers to set gameplans/depth charts but no hiring/firing capability. If 66% of the team votes to keep it together, the interim owner can purchase it for the normal flex cost at end of season. If they do not vote to keep it together, all players are released and the team disbanded at end of season. Additional teams are promoted to fill out the league next season.

Much more to it than that, but I think that's the basics.


 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by

The Solution: Overview
Have there only be three ways for a team to remain intact after an owner leaves:


That's your problem - reducing the number of ways that teams can remove together, by definition, does not reduce gutting. Come up with an idea that would actually fix gutting, place a single sentence that relates to that idea here.. and base everything else on that sentence.


You didn't read my whole post. The key is in the resetting of teams if no suitable replacement is found. The only teams that would have not been gutted under the current system that will be reset by my system are teams with very low cohesiveness with a new random owner. Teams that fall under this category are doomed, and are basically just pre-gutted teams. My system speeds up the process by forcing the team to reset at the bottom tier or by forcing the players to band together and increase cohesiveness.

Teams falling apart and becoming hopelessly uncompetitive will always be a problem. My system deals with this by flushing those teams out (much more effectively than is currently done), and gives much more of a chance to teams on the brink by allowing current players to take over through a vote.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 19:08:20
 
Brohl
offline
Link
 
It's very much worth the read. It isn't a magic bullet for the problem, but it does address the issue in a way that seems very fair and balanced. My guess would be it won't be well received because it bypasses the queue in most cases for prospective new owners.

I say +1
 
Gooseman
offline
Link
 
I really like where you're going with these suggestions, and your approach to the problem. I'm one of those people that can pretty much read a novel on an idea if I'm interested (I read the whole thing), but I do agree that a condensed version would be an excellent idea. I'm sure Bort would appreciate all of the suggestions that you have. Like you said, every suggestion is bound to have it's problems, but this is a pretty darn good start.

+1 as well.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 19:27:08
 
ky1732
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by tordman

My first thought was to just post tl/dr.

My second thought was to give the idea some merit.

But then I decided tl;dr.


basically. I tried to start reading but got to Overview.


thats about as far as i got too
 
Link
 
+1, i actually think this could work
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.